New York State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a construction contractor buy materials tax-free using a customer's Direct Payment Permit?
No. A contractor must still pay sales tax on all materials it buys for repair or capital-improvement work, even when the customer holds a Direct Payment Permit -- the permit only excuses the contracto…
Does a Canadian manufacturer owe New York sales or use tax on custom window-washing equipment sold to a contractor and permanently installed on a New York high-rise?
Yes. Selling custom window-washing and maintenance equipment to a general contractor who permanently installs it on a New York high-rise is a taxable retail sale (or a taxable use if bought out of sta…
When a company sells and installs custom in-ground swimming pools under a lump-sum contract, does it charge its customer sales tax on the installed pool, or does it instead pay tax itself on materials as a contractor?
The installed pool is treated as a capital improvement, not a retail sale -- the company's lump-sum charge to the customer for the pool and its installation isn't subject to sales tax, but the company…
Is installing custom shutters and blinds as original equipment in a new home, before construction is finished, a tax-exempt capital improvement?
It depends on the item. Custom shutters installed as part of the original finish carpentry before construction was complete -- enclosing the window and door casings -- are excluded from tax as part of…
Are an underwater/topside inspection and reporting subconsultant's services for government infrastructure projects subject to New York sales tax?
It depends on what the inspection and reporting is for. If the services support a real-property repair or maintenance project, they're taxable as maintaining real property; if they support a capital i…
Is a law firm's floor-by-floor office reconstruction (including asbestos removal and re-fireproofing) an exempt capital improvement or a taxable repair service?
Mostly exempt -- the wall, HVAC, plumbing, millwork, and fireproofing work on Petitioner's headquarters build-out (including redoing failed fireproofing) qualifies as an exempt capital improvement bec…
Is a special assessment that a country club charges members to build a safety tunnel subject to New York's club dues tax?
Yes -- even though the tunnel Mount Kisco Country Club built under a state highway is a genuine capital improvement built for members' safety, the special assessment the club charged members to fund i…
Which items a plumbing supplier sells to contractors working for tax-exempt organizations are exempt from New York sales tax as building materials, and which stay taxable as contractor supplies?
It splits item by item -- materials that physically become part of the exempt organization's building, like flux, solder, pipe joint compounds, Teflon tape, PVC cement and primer, oakum, and lead used…
Is a can/bottle recycler's pickup service taxable as real-property maintenance, and do its can-sorting machines and electrical transformer qualify for the production-equipment sales tax exemption?
All three ways: the recycler's container-pickup and recycling service isn't taxable real-property maintenance, its can-sorting machines qualify for the production-equipment exemption because they hand…
Can a New York City Industrial Development Agency sale-leaseback structure let PaineWebber buy and lease office build-out improvements and equipment sales-tax-free by having its agents purchase everything on the IDA's behalf?
Yes, with conditions -- the New York City Industrial Development Agency's proposed sale-leaseback structure for PaineWebber's office build-out ("Tenant Improvements") and equipment/software ("Project …
Is a kitchen and bathroom renovation company that controls the whole job but has its customers separately sign contracts with the installing tradespeople a retailer of the cabinets it sells, or a contractor performing a capital improvement?
The renovation firm is a contractor, not a retailer -- because it controls every aspect of the renovation (design, pricing, and which tradespeople the customer must use), it must pay sales tax itself …
Are stair lifts, patient lifts, home elevators and dumbwaiters sold to help disabled people exempt from New York sales tax as medical equipment or prosthetic aids?
Portable stair lifts, evacuation devices, and patient lifts sold to help disabled people are exempt from New York sales tax as medical equipment or prosthetic aids; residential elevators installed for…
Is a large multi-task garage waterproofing and restoration project a nontaxable capital improvement, or a taxable repair, when some individual tasks look like ordinary maintenance?
A large garage waterproofing and restoration project -- covering roof deck waterproofing, structural steel and concrete work, asphalt paving, walkway replacement, railings and other tasks across nine …
Do track-mounted or portable moveable partitions qualify as an exempt capital improvement, or are they taxable tangible personal property?
No -- operable, accordion, and portable moveable partitions don't qualify as a capital improvement even though the tracks are bolted into the ceiling structure, because merely mounting panels on rolle…
Are elevator consulting firms' inspection, evaluation, design, and expert-witness services subject to New York sales tax?
No -- a group of elevator consulting firms' inspections, performance evaluations, code-compliance reviews, modernization studies, traffic-capacity studies, design/specification work, bid analysis, pos…
How does New York sales and use tax apply to a kitchen cabinet and countertop manufacturer that sells its products both installed and uninstalled?
It depends on whether the sale is installed or uninstalled -- a kitchen cabinet and countertop manufacturer must collect sales tax when selling cabinets uninstalled, but when it installs cabinets or c…
Is an environmental consulting firm's installation of a petroleum-leak remediation system, its water/soil sampling, and its reports subject to New York sales tax?
It depends entirely on the capital-improvement test -- if an environmental consulting firm's installation of a petroleum-leak remediation system (and any related tank removal/replacement) satisfies al…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(42)S: Is a specific method of waterproofing leaking basement wall cracks -- installing a permanent interior drainage system rather than patching the cracks -- a tax-exempt capital improvement or a taxable repair service?
It's a capital improvement, exempt from sales tax to the customer. Sta Dry Systems Inc. doesn't patch or inject cracked basement walls -- instead it permanently reroutes leaking water into the floor d…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(41)S: Does an environmental contractor's installation of soil and groundwater treatment systems at contaminated gas station sites qualify as a tax-exempt "capital improvement" to real property?
It depends on the facts of each installation -- the Department can't decide that question in the abstract, but it laid out the test. Envirotrac Ltd. installs soil and/or groundwater treatment systems …
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(37)S: A contractor who hires a plumber and mason as subcontractors on a pool job asks whether he has to pay sales tax to those subcontractors, or whether he can instead give them a Contractor Exempt Purchase Certificate (Form ST-120.1).
It depends on what kind of job the contractor is doing for the property owner. If the contractor's own work for the customer is a TAXABLE service (an installation that doesn't become part of real prop…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(36)S: When Viacom finances office build-outs, equipment, and maintenance contracts through the New York City Industrial Development Agency's bond program to stay headquartered in the city, are those purchases, the resulting lease (debt-service) payments, intercompany reimbursements, the $1 buyout option, and an early-removal penalty all exempt from sales and use tax?
Yes, with one open factual question and one hard carve-out. Because title to the improvements and equipment runs through the New York City Industrial Development Agency (IDA) under General Municipal L…
I'm buying a building and gutting it down to the four exterior walls to add a story and a half. Does that rehab count as a fresh 'qualifying capital improvement' under New York's builders' exemption from the Real Property Transfer Gains Tax, even though the building already existed before I bought it?
Yes -- the gut rehabilitation qualified. Dashal 67, LLC planned to buy a five-story building for about $2.5 million and immediately gut-rehabilitate it down to its four exterior walls while adding a s…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(32)S: Is installing custom-cut, permanently anchored closet shelving a tax-exempt capital improvement, and does it matter whether it's going into a brand-new building or an existing one?
It depends on whether the building is new or existing. Home Insulation & Supply Inc. installs closet shelving cut to the exact size of each closet, permanently anchored with screws, nails, or similar …
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(30)S: Is applying a slip-resistant chemical treatment to tile, terrazzo, or concrete floors -- often done for ADA compliance -- subject to sales tax, and does it matter whether the floor is brand new or already existing?
It depends on whether the floor is new or existing. FST Services applies a permanent chemical treatment to hard mineral floors (ceramic, quarry tile, concrete, terrazzo) that boosts slip resistance fo…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(8)S: Is the removal, disposal, and decontamination of waste from tanks at an EPA Superfund cleanup site a taxable real-property maintenance service, or an exempt capital improvement, when the site's overall final remediation plan hasn't been determined yet?
Taxable, at least for now -- because the ultimate capital-improvement outcome can't yet be established. Frontier Chemical Royal Avenue Superfund Site is a group of companies designated "potentially re…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-96(7)S: Does a computer-services tenant in an Economic Development Zone building qualify for the sales tax refund/credit on construction materials used to build or rehabilitate the building, even though it isn't the one buying the materials?
The building itself qualifies for the EDZ construction-materials refund, but Petitioner personally does not, unless Petitioner is the one who actually buys the materials and pays the tax. Gloria S. Fr…
New York Advisory Opinion TSB-A-95(42)S: In CS First Boston's proposed NYC IDA headquarters-retention deal -- where the building owner, Metlife, pays for and owns most leasehold improvements for regulatory-capital reasons while the IDA holds legal title -- are the purchases of Eligible Personalty, the Improvements, Metlife's reimbursements, and CS First Boston's debt-service payments exempt from sales and use tax?
Exempt, but with a genuinely fact-dependent condition on the Improvements question that this opinion couldn't resolve outright. CS First Boston Corporation ("CS First Boston") proposed a roughly 20-ye…
Is installing a new private cable television system for an apartment/condo complex an exempt capital improvement, or a taxable installation of tangible personal property?
Both, split by component. Burying the trunk cable, wiring buildings from the wall outlet to the cable pedestal, building the cable pedestal, and splicing/activating the cable lines are capital improve…
Does a factory-manufactured home dealer owe sales tax on homes it buys and resells already-installed, and is the installation work of a related but separately-owned installation company subject to sales tax?
Homes sold and installed as permanent capital improvements (not mobile homes, not display models) escape sales tax on both the dealer's purchase and its resale, with the manufacturer owing the use tax…
Is a custom-fitted canvas awning, installed at a homeowner's residence to block sun from entering the living and dining rooms, an exempt capital improvement, or taxable?
Taxable. Canvas awnings are categorically NOT treated as a capital improvement under the Department's own published guidance and prior precedent, regardless of how custom-fitted or substantial the ins…
Is 'guniting' an existing in-ground concrete swimming pool -- coating it with marble dust to extend its life 10-15 years -- an exempt capital improvement, or a taxable repair?
Taxable repair, not a capital improvement -- even though the coating substantially prolongs the pool's useful life, it's treated the same as a similar protective coating applied to storage tanks in a …
Is installing easily-relocatable, floor-to-ceiling moveable walls a tax-exempt capital improvement, and can the installer accept a Certificate of Capital Improvement on the sale?
No, moveable walls that can be relocated without damaging the building fail two of the three required capital-improvement tests, so their installation is a taxable service, not an exempt capital impro…
Is the sale and installation of a residential direct-broadcast satellite receiving system a tax-exempt capital improvement, or is it a taxable sale of tangible personal property?
It's split -- the underground wiring and the concrete-based support pole ARE tax-exempt capital improvements, but the microwave antenna/dish itself keeps its identity as tangible personal property (it…
Are a Morgan Stanley financing affiliate's purchases, leases, and maintenance contracts for a New York City office building -- entered as the disclosed agent of the New York City Industrial Development Agency (IDA) -- exempt from sales and use tax?
Yes, generally -- purchases, leases, and maintenance/repair/service contracts entered by the financing affiliate as the IDA's disclosed agent are exempt from sales and use tax, and so are the lease pa…
Is installing a patented lawn-fertilization control device as part of a new or existing underground sprinkler system a tax-exempt capital improvement, and does that change if it's just replacing an existing pump?
Yes -- installing the device as part of a new underground sprinkler system, or adding it to an existing one, is a capital improvement and not subject to sales tax, because it permanently increases the…
Is a research firm's government-funded pilot plant, built to test a new pollution-control process at a power station, exempt from sales and use tax as research equipment, government property, production machinery, or a capital improvement?
Partly. Tangible personal property bought for use directly and predominantly in the experimental/laboratory research is exempt. Property that becomes part of a permanent capital improvement (the shelt…
When a kitchen contractor sells cabinets, does it collect sales tax from the customer, or pay tax on its own purchase of the cabinets?
It depends on whether the contractor installs them. If the contractor merely sells the cabinets without installing them, it is making a retail sale and must collect sales tax from the customer under T…
Is restoration of a building's deteriorated balconies and catwalks a tax-exempt capital improvement or a taxable repair?
It is a taxable repair, not a capital improvement. A co-op hired a contractor to inspect, test, clean, patch, and coat the deteriorated concrete of its balconies and catwalks -- removing cracked and s…
In a bond-financed sale-leaseback structure with a city industrial development agency (IDA), are a corporate tenant's affiliate's purchases, leases, and maintenance contracts -- made as the IDA's disclosed agent -- exempt from state and local sales and use tax?
Yes, generally -- purchases, leases, and maintenance/repair/service contracts entered as the IDA's disclosed agent are exempt from sales and use tax as long as the IDA is the true owner/lessor/lessee …
In a New York City Industrial Development Agency (IDA) sale-leaseback financing arrangement, are a company's affiliated 'Group Agents' purchases, lease payments, and buyout payments to the IDA exempt from sales and use tax, no matter which affiliate actually pays the vendor or how bond proceeds are routed?
Yes, generally -- purchases and leases made by any affiliated Group Agent acting as the IDA's disclosed agent, and inter-affiliate cost allocations and reimbursements, are exempt from sales and use ta…
When a heating contractor rents mobile boilers to supply temporary heat to an exempt organization's building while installing a permanent system, does the contractor owe sales or use tax on the boiler rental?
Yes. Although the contractor's service of providing temporary heat to the exempt organization is not taxable, the contractor owes sales or use tax on the mobile boilers it rents, because rented equipm…
Are a company's charges for supplying temporary environmental field technicians to prime contractors subject to New York sales tax?
It depends on the work. A temp-staffing company must collect tax on personnel who perform taxable services, but the charges are exempt when the prime contractor buys the services for resale or for a c…
Is the sale and installation of custom interior window shutters a tax-exempt capital improvement to real property, or a taxable sale?
Taxable. The Department ruled that custom interior window shutters are like blinds and draperies, not a capital improvement, so their sale and installation stays subject to sales tax.
Which pieces of a salt mine's equipment — conveyors, elevators, screening, mining machinery, roof bolts, and power-distribution gear — qualify for New York's production-machinery sales tax exemption?
Conveyors, elevators, screening systems, and salt-mining machinery qualify for the § 1115(a)(12) production exemption. Roof bolts and general power-distribution equipment (substations, transformers, c…
In the modified opinion, are an asbestos contractor's plastic bags and poly taxable, and what changes when the removal is part of a capital improvement?
Same core result as the original opinion — disposal bags are 'actually transferred' (not taxable) and plastic poly is consumed by the contractor (taxable) — but this modified opinion adds that when th…
Is removing an old lighting system and installing a new hardwired energy-efficient one a capital improvement, so the contractor doesn't charge the customer sales tax?
Yes. Installing a new, permanently hardwired energy-efficient lighting system is a capital improvement, so the contractor doesn't charge the customer sales tax (with Form ST-124) — but the contractor …
Is a subcontractor's charge to erect tubular scaffolding or pipe framing for a building renovation subject to New York sales tax?
Yes. A subcontractor's charge to erect tubular scaffolding or pipe framing is subject to New York State and local sales tax. Scaffolding is not a tax-exempt 'temporary facility' — and it's taxable whe…
Are a company's labor and material charges to close its portion of a town-owned landfill subject to New York sales and use tax?
No. Closing the landfill is a capital improvement, so the labor charges aren't taxable; and because the materials become an integral part of the exempt Town of Wilna's land, the materials aren't taxab…
Is replacing an underground fuel oil storage tank a nontaxable capital improvement, even though it can eventually be taken out of service?
Yes. Installing a replacement underground fuel oil tank — poured on a concrete slab, buried, and asphalted — is a capital improvement, so the work isn't taxable. No local law forces its removal when o…
Is a discounted group-sales amusement-park ticket taxable when admission is called 'free,' and is installing a fiberglass tubeslide a nontaxable capital improvement?
The whole group ticket is taxable unless it separately states admission and rides. An amusement park's ride charges escape tax only when its pay-one-price ticket separately states the taxable admissio…
Does a builder owe sales tax on factory manufactured homes it buys, and does it matter who hires and pays the crane crew that sets the home on the foundation?
It depends on who arranged the installation. An uninstalled factory manufactured home is taxable tangible personal property, but a home sold with installation as a component of the sale (a capital imp…
Is installing a synthetic-turf putting green on real property a nontaxable capital improvement, or a taxable installation service?
It's a nontaxable capital improvement — with a catch. Installing a permanent synthetic-turf putting green on real property qualifies as a capital improvement under Tax Law §§ 1105(c)(3) and 1101(b)(9)…
Is microfilming blueprints and reports required for building permits a nontaxable capital improvement, or a taxable sale of tangible personal property?
It's taxable. Microfilming blueprints, applications, and inspection reports for architects, engineers, and developers is a sale of tangible personal property subject to sales tax under Tax Law § 1105(…
Is an airline's purchase and installation of a custom baggage-conveyor system in a leased airport terminal exempt when title vests in the exempt Port Authority?
It's exempt. Where an airline buys and installs a custom baggage-conveyor system in a terminal it leases from the Port Authority, and the lease provides that title to the installation vests immediatel…
Are the materials a contractor pours into a farm bunker silo's floor and walls exempt from New York sales and use tax as farm-silo property?
Mostly exempt, with one taxable slice. Materials a contractor incorporates into a farm bunker silo used to make and store silage are exempt from New York sales and use tax under Tax Law § 1115(a)(6) b…
Are a company's permanently installed fabric canopies and awnings a nontaxable capital improvement, and what about illuminated awning signs?
It splits. Permanently installed custom canopies and awnings made of durable plastic fabrics (vinyl, polyester, acrylic, or modacrylic) that are welded and bolted to a building qualify as a capital im…
Is asbestos removal taxable in New York when it is done as part of a capital improvement, such as reinsulating pipes and boilers?
No — not on these facts. Asbestos removal by itself is a taxable service (maintaining/repairing real property under Tax Law § 1105(c)(5)). But when the removal is a constituent part of a capital impro…
Can an interior design and space-planning service qualify for the capital-improvement exclusion from New York sales tax?
No. Hafner Associates' interior design and space-planning services — layouts, lighting design, millwork elevations, finishes and furnishings specifications, and project management presented on bluepri…
Are a contractor's cable-TV installation and testing charges to a cable company taxable, and when do resale, capital-improvement, or exempt-organization rules apply?
Generally taxable, with several carve-outs. A contractor's charges to a cable-TV company for the 13 listed services (testing, splicing, wiring, trenching, drop-cable installs, pole transfers, etc.) ar…
Can a customer give a contractor a capital-improvement certificate after the contract is signed and the first tax invoice is paid, and who then owes tax?
Yes, the customer can furnish the certificate later, with limits. Once Action Scale receives a properly completed Certificate of Capital Improvement, it must stop collecting sales tax on future invoic…
Browse New York rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by New York's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.