New York State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
If a New York marina buys floating cement docks and installs them with its own employees, is the purchase a tax-exempt capital improvement or taxable tangible personal property?
Taxable. Because the marina bought the floating cement docks uninstalled and installed them using its own employees, it purchased only tangible personal property — not a capital-improvement installati…
When someone assumes an existing long-term car lease, is sales tax due again on the remaining payments even though the original lessee already prepaid all the lease's sales tax?
Taxable again. The Department concluded that when someone ASSUMES an existing long-term motor-vehicle lease, that assumption is a new, separate taxable sale — possession of the vehicle transfers to th…
Did a New York resident who bought a car in Maine (and paid Maine sales tax) owe New York use tax when she registered it in New York, with no credit for the Maine tax?
Use tax was due. The Department concluded that a New York resident who bought, registered, and paid sales tax on a vehicle in Maine still owed New York compensating use tax when she registered it in N…
When a fabricator sells custom curtain walls to a contractor who installs them on a New York building, is it a tax-free capital improvement — and is the fabricator taxed only on its raw materials?
Mixed. Installing the curtain walls IS a tax-exempt capital improvement (it meets the three-prong test in Tax Law § 1101(b)(9)). BUT the fabricator's sale of the curtain walls to the contractor is a t…
How does New York sales tax apply to a contractor's purchase, sale, and installation of residential and commercial solar energy systems?
It varies by component and timing. Solar modules, racking, and inverters bought for installation at a specific customer's residence or commercial premises qualify as solar energy systems equipment, ex…
Does New York sales or use tax apply to a sculpture bought from a NY dealer but delivered abroad and later displayed in New York?
No. New York sales tax is a destination tax: it turns on where the buyer takes possession. Here the Florida buyer authorized a museum to retrieve the sculpture, and the museum's contract carrier (the …
Are auto repairs done out of state taxable in New York if the repaired car is delivered to the customer in New York?
Yes. Repair and maintenance of tangible personal property is a destination tax: what controls is where the repaired property is delivered to the customer. Here the dealer's body shop is in New Jersey,…
Is the purchase of commercial vessels delivered in New York subject to sales tax, and on the full price?
It is taxable, but only on the first $230,000 of each vessel. Vessels are tangible personal property, and a sale is taxable where the property is delivered. Here the three sightseeing ships were bough…
Is the sale and installation of a custom closet-organizing system a nontaxable capital improvement?
No - it is taxable. Installing tangible personal property is taxable unless the result is a capital improvement, which requires all three tests: it substantially adds value or prolongs the property's …
Is equipment a repair shop buys to perform taxable repairs itself subject to sales tax?
Yes. A car dealer's purchase of a wheel-alignment machine is a taxable retail sale of tangible personal property. The machine is used to perform the dealer's repair and alignment work, which is a taxa…
Can a foreign company buying materials delivered to a New York affiliate use resale certificates, and must it register?
It must register, and it may buy for resale only on materials it truly resells without using. The Canadian company has its suppliers drop-ship raw materials to its New York affiliate; because possessi…
Are interior lighting design services taxable if the plans are delivered to the client electronically?
Yes. New York taxes interior decorating and design services - which include lighting design - whether or not any tangible property changes hands. Delivering the design plans electronically rather than…
Are a cloud DNS-security firm's services taxable in New York, does its data center create nexus, and are its software plug-ins a separate taxable sale?
Yes to nexus and to tax. The firm (and its predecessor LLC) has had New York nexus at least since 2006, when it established a data center here -- physical property in the state is more than a slight p…
Does a retailer collect NY sales tax when it sells built-in appliances on an installed basis, or is that a capital improvement?
Selling built-in appliances installed is a capital improvement, so the retailer doesn't collect tax from the customer -- the retailer pays the tax on the appliance instead. Publication 862 classifies …
Are an online provider's legal-document services (wills, entity formation, registered agent, trademarks, legal plans) subject to NY sales tax?
No -- none of these services is subject to sales tax, because each one's primary function is producing documents or providing a legal or agent service, not furnishing information, and legal and regist…
If I use a grantor trust's swap power to trade tangible personal property I own for trust property of equal value, is that subject to NY sales or use tax?
Yes. Even though a grantor (defective) trust is ignored for income tax, the trust and the settlor are separate taxpayers for sales tax. Swapping tangible personal property to the trust in exchange for…
Is buying a commercial charter vessel subject to NY sales/use tax if it's in NY under six months a year, or if its hailing port reads 'New York, NY'?
The purchase is exempt from NY sales and use tax if the vessel is a commercial vessel used primarily in interstate or foreign commerce -- meaning 50% or more of the receipts from its activities come f…
Are a NY company's R&D services for its out-of-state parent taxable when the resulting reports or samples are delivered outside New York?
No NY sales or use tax is due. The Department didn't need to decide whether the work is a taxable information service or nontaxable research and development, because sales tax is a destination tax: th…
Is the charge to install a large water slide at an amusement park a tax-exempt capital improvement, even on leased land?
Yes. The water slide is a capital improvement, so the charge to install it is exempt from sales and use tax. It substantially adds value, is permanently affixed (bolted to concrete piers, with in-grou…
Is an online assessment software tool taxable, and are the custom reports it generates from a customer's own data taxable?
Two different answers. Licensing the online assessment tool to third-party consultants is a taxable sale of prewritten computer software (sourced to where it's accessed), and the developer's own use o…
Is selling advertising space on installed displays a taxable service in NY, and are the charges to install, repair, and supply those displays taxable?
The advertising sales are not taxable, but the related installation, repair, and materials charges are. Selling advertising space on digital, backlit, scroll, wrap, and banner displays is not one of t…
Must a New York gun dealer (FFL) collect sales tax when transferring a firearm the buyer purchased from an out-of-state seller, and is its transfer fee taxable?
No on both. When a New York buyer purchases a gun directly from an out-of-state seller (FFL) and pays that seller, federal law requires the gun to ship to a New York FFL who runs the background check …
How does NY sales and use tax apply to a stair and railing manufacturer that also installs its products?
As a fabricator that installs its own product, the company is a contractor. Installing or entirely replacing stairs is generally a nontaxable capital improvement, so its charges to sell-and-install st…
Does the 2009 law (Part N-1) narrowing NY's aircraft exemptions apply to an aircraft bought out-of-state before the law's effective date but first used in NY afterward?
No. Part N-1 of Chapter 57 of the Laws of 2009, which narrowed both the nonresident use-tax exemption and the commercial-aircraft exemption, applies only to sales made and uses occurring after its Jun…
Is buying and leasing an aircraft interest through a fractional-style program a taxable property purchase or a nontaxable transportation service?
It's a taxable purchase of tangible personal property, not a nontaxable transportation service. Whether a program like this is taxable property or an exempt transportation service turns on whether dom…
Is a software license taxed in full because the buyer's NY office is the bill-to address, or only on the NY users?
Only on the portion attributable to users located in New York. Prewritten software is tangible personal property (Tax Law 1101(b)(6)), and a license to use it is taxed where possession is transferred …
How is a custom window fabricator that also installs taxed on materials, fabrication, and installation?
As a contractor. A fabricator that installs its own product is a contractor, and installing complete windows is a capital improvement -- so the charge to furnish and install windows isn't taxable. The…
Does a contractor owe NY tax on the waste portion of granite/marble/stone slabs used in a capital improvement?
Yes. A contractor's purchase of stone slabs to use in a capital improvement is a taxable retail purchase (sales tax if delivered in NY, use tax if bought outside and used here), and the tax is based o…
Are free college textbooks/review copies sent to professors and critics exempt as promotional material, or is use tax due?
Use tax is due. Free books distributed in NY to authors, book critics, professors, awards committees, and exhibitors don't qualify for the printed-promotional-material exemption in Tax Law 1115(n)(4),…
When a landlord reimburses a commercial tenant for the cost of building out the leased space, does the landlord owe sales or use tax on that reimbursement?
No. A landlord's disbursements from a 'Tenant Fund' to reimburse a commercial tenant for the cost of Initial Alterations (build-out) to the leased premises are not receipts from a sale of tangible per…
My company provides automated voice-calling services to airlines, banks, and other businesses using proprietary software we keep entirely in-house — is our calling-service fee or our own software subject to New York sales or use tax?
Not taxable. An automated voice-message provider's fees for placing calls to customer-designated recipients aren't subject to New York sales tax, because the service isn't among the enumerated taxable…
My out-of-state satellite Internet provider furnishes required equipment to New York customers through third-party dealers, and I've never paid New York sales tax on the equipment purchase itself — do I owe New York use tax on that equipment?
Mostly exempt in practice. An out-of-state satellite Internet provider owes New York use tax (not sales tax) on customer premises equipment it furnishes to New York customers as an integral part of it…
My company provides automated voice-calling services to airlines, banks, and other businesses using proprietary software we keep entirely in-house — is our calling-service fee or our own software subject to New York sales or use tax?
Not taxable. An automated voice-message provider's fees for placing calls to customer-designated recipients aren't subject to New York sales tax, because the service isn't among the enumerated taxable…
My company prints and mails direct-mail advertising coupons for local merchants from an out-of-state printing plant to addresses all over the country, including New York -- do I owe New York sales or use tax on the mailings that go to New York addresses?
Mostly exempt. A national direct-mail advertiser's printed coupon materials, produced and mailed out of state to New York recipients on behalf of its franchisees' advertiser-clients, are exempt promot…
My family-owned ferry company runs the only vehicle ferry between two New York towns, is regulated by the county, and serves as an emergency evacuation route -- can we get a refund or credit of the sales and use tax we've paid on our ferry boats?
No refund under the old rule, but a new exemption applies going forward. A private, county-regulated vehicle ferry company does not qualify for the long-standing local-transit-vessel refund in Tax Law…
My company runs a warehouse that repackages inventory before shipping it to my own retail stores — are the boxes, tape, and wrap I buy for that internal shipping exempt from sales tax as packaging materials?
No exemption. A pet-supply retail chain must pay New York sales or use tax on the boxes, tape, wrap, and other packaging materials it buys and uses to ship inventory from its own warehouse to its own …
My holding company leases a corporate jet to me, and I use it mostly to fly a paying affiliate's people and cargo -- is the lease exempt from New York sales tax as a 'commercial aircraft,' and will a later merger of my holding company into me trigger sales tax on the plane?
Yes, exempt as a commercial aircraft, and the merger transfer isn't taxed either -- but only if the for-hire use holds up. Where an aviation-holding LLC leases a jet to its corporate parent, and the p…
My company bought a corporate jet out of state and dry-leased it to an affiliate that operates it entirely outside New York — do we owe New York sales or use tax now, and would it change if we later brought the plane to New York and used it to provide 'for hire' air transportation to that same affiliate?
No tax now, exemption available later. A company's purchase and dry-lease of a corporate aircraft to an affiliate is not subject to New York sales or use tax where the aircraft is delivered and used e…
I run a portable-toilet rental and servicing business — do I owe sales tax on the toilets and supplies I buy to run it, or on the insurance I charge customers for the toilets?
Split result. A portable-toilet servicing company owes New York sales and use tax on its purchases of the toilets themselves (and the parts/paint used to build and maintain them), because providing to…
I'm an out-of-state jewelry retailer that sells through satellite and cable TV home-shopping arrangements to New York viewers -- do those broadcast and airtime-purchase relationships give me nexus, requiring me to register and collect New York sales tax?
No nexus from the TV distribution deals alone, but the Department stopped short of a final answer. Gems TV USA Limited, a Delaware corporation with no New York locations, employees, warehouse, or plac…
Are different types of commercial signs — monument signs, pylon signs, channel letters, backlit letters, electronic displays, banners, and window graphics — taxable installations of tangible personal property, or exempt capital improvements to real property?
It depends on the sign: a monument sign set in a concrete foundation can qualify as a tax-exempt capital improvement, but pylon signs bolted to piers, channel letters, backlit letters, electronic disp…
When a company buys a fractional ownership interest in a private jet through a trust, and an aircraft management company keeps control over pilots, maintenance, and scheduling, is that purchase a taxable rental of the aircraft or an exempt transportation service?
It's an exempt transportation service, not a taxable purchase or rental of tangible personal property, because the aircraft management company -- not the fractional owner -- retains dominion and contr…
If a Florida sign manufacturer pays Florida use tax on materials it later installs as a capital improvement in New York, can it get a credit against the New York use tax it owes on the same materials?
Yes, but only for materials installed as an actual New York capital improvement, only if the tax was legally due and actually paid to Florida (not merely assessed), and only up to the amount of New Yo…
If a company leases an aircraft and uses it mostly for charter flights to the public and its owners, with the rest for its own affiliates' business travel, does the lease qualify for New York's commercial aircraft sales-tax exemption?
Yes -- because at least 50% of the aircraft's use is transporting people for compensation at market-reflective rates, it qualifies as a commercial aircraft, so the lease payments, related maintenance …
Does a nonresident investment fund that buys artwork outside New York and loans it, free of charge, to a New York museum owe New York use tax on that artwork?
No use tax is owed, as long as the fund was a nonresident (not doing business in New York) when it bought the artwork — the nonresident-purchaser exemption covers using the art here through a free mus…
Is New York sales or use tax due on an art collector's overseas-delivered artwork, its bequest to his children, transferred company shares, or a nonresident's artwork brought into New York upon relocating?
No New York sales or use tax is due in any of these situations: artwork delivered and titled outside New York escapes sales tax under the destination rule, an estate's no-consideration bequest of artw…
Does a company owe sales tax on a 'shipping and handling' fee it charges for an otherwise free trial-size product, and does it owe use tax on the free product itself?
A shipping-and-handling charge for a free trial product isn't a taxable sale as long as the fee genuinely reflects actual shipping and handling costs, but the company owes sales or use tax on the tria…
Is an aircraft owned by a single-purpose affiliate that flies its parent companies' employees and guests for a fee an exempt commercial aircraft?
Yes -- because the aircraft-owning affiliate is a genuine separate legal entity, retains full operational control, and uses the aircraft at least 50% of the time to provide transportation for hire (bi…
Does an out-of-state data backup company owe New York sales or use tax on its subscription service and the connector software it installs on subscribers' computers?
The subscription fee for an off-site data backup and recovery service isn't subject to New York sales tax because it's not an enumerated taxable service (and the data being stored isn't taxable tangib…
How does a New York resident compute the use tax owed when bringing a custom-built vessel, constructed and outfitted out of state, into New York for use?
The use tax is based on the full cost of the vessel and everything used to build and outfit it -- purchase price of the vessel, all incorporated materials, plus the cost of any taxable fabrication/ins…
Is a movie theater company's purchase of armored courier service to transport cash receipts subject to New York sales or use tax?
Yes -- armored car and bonded courier services are taxable 'protective and detective services' under New York law, and because the cash bags the theater's bank picks up are ultimately delivered to the…
In a multi-tier supply chain for prepaid telephone calling cards, who owes New York sales tax on sales made from 1998-2000, and what happens when resale certificates were never issued between the companies?
It depends on the date of sale and whether a resale certificate was properly obtained. Before March 1, 2000, New York didn't tax the sale of a prepaid calling card itself — tax applied only when the e…
Is a Web site development company's charge for consulting on, designing, and building a client's Web site subject to New York sales tax, and does the developer owe tax on the software it buys or writes in-house to do that work?
Web site development services — consulting, design, and building the site, plus any future hosting fees passed through from an ISP — are not a taxable service in New York and stay untaxed no matter wh…
When a securities broker-dealer spins off its software-development operations into a separate subsidiary and licenses its trading software back, does that reorganization trigger New York sales or use tax on the software?
Generally no, as long as the software stays custom-built for one purchaser's own specifications and isn't resold to third parties. A joint venture's custom-built trading algorithm licensed to the brok…
Are materials and supplies a federal government contractor purchases in its own name, for use in performing a cost-reimbursement services contract, excluded from sales tax as purchases for resale even though the government takes title to them?
No, they're not resale-exempt. Even though the U.S. government eventually takes title to the materials and reimburses the contractor for their cost, the contractor is buying them to use in performing …
When a company buys a 25% 'interest' in a private jet through a fractional-ownership program -- where a separate management company controls scheduling, pilots, maintenance, and can substitute other aircraft -- is that purchase a taxable acquisition of an aircraft, or a nontaxable transportation service?
It's a nontaxable transportation service, not a taxable purchase of an aircraft. Because the fractional-ownership program's independent Manager -- not the purchasing company -- retains real dominion a…
Can an HVAC ductwork fabricator get a sales or use tax refund or credit for the sheet steel that becomes scrap or gets returned to inventory during the cutting process?
No. There is no statutory or regulatory provision allowing a refund or credit for the portion of sheet steel that ends up as scrap or is returned to inventory during the duct-cutting process. The fabr…
Does a Canadian manufacturer owe New York sales or use tax on custom window-washing equipment sold to a contractor and permanently installed on a New York high-rise?
Yes. Selling custom window-washing and maintenance equipment to a general contractor who permanently installs it on a New York high-rise is a taxable retail sale (or a taxable use if bought out of sta…
Is an out-of-state electronic health-claims clearinghouse subject to New York franchise tax when it installs equipment and trains customers here, and which of its fees and equipment are subject to sales or use tax?
On franchise tax: once the company acquires New York customers and sends employees in to install computer hardware/software and train customer staff, it is doing business and has property in New York,…
Does a radioactive-waste disposal company owe use tax on out-of-state-purchased containers it gives customers, and is its entire disposal charge taxable even though the waste and containers are ultimately buried or processed outside New York?
No use tax applies to the containers themselves, since they're actually transferred to the customer as part of a taxable disposal service rather than purchased at retail by the company. But the compan…
Browse New York rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by New York's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.