North Carolina State Bar Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the North Carolina State Bar, with full citations and source links on every page.
No North Carolina State Bar opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a North Carolina lawyer join a commercial barter exchange and accept barter dollars for legal work?
Yes, with conditions. The opinion concludes a lawyer may participate in a barter exchange as long as the exchange exercises no influence over the lawyer's professional judgment, the exchange's listing…
Can a lawyer render a title opinion by tacking to a mortgagee's title policy, and is that an ethics question?
The opinion concludes the standard of care for tacking is outside the Ethics Committee's purview and withdraws the part of RPC 99 that addressed it; whether tacking to an owner's or a mortgagee's poli…
Can a closing lawyer place a client's title insurance with an agency owned by the lawyer's spouse?
No. The opinion concludes that placing a client's title insurance with an agency in which the lawyer's spouse has an ownership interest is a personal conflict of interest under Rule 1.7(a)(2) that is …
Does a North Carolina lawyer have to add a dramatization disclaimer when using stock photographs in legal advertising?
No. The opinion concludes that because stock photographs are static and do not have the same tendency to mislead as video dramatizations of fictional cases, a lawyer may use them in a print or video a…
If a lawyer meets with both spouses as a prospective divorce mediator, can he later represent one spouse in the case?
No, not without the other spouse's consent. The opinion concludes that a lawyer who held himself out as a neutral and had substantive discussions with the wife about the mediation process participated…
Can a law firm post past verdicts, settlements, and selective case lists on its website, and how must self-laudatory memberships be presented?
The opinion concludes a firm may showcase accurate verdicts, settlements, and favorable case lists on its website if a tailored, prominently placed disclaimer accompanies them, and any reference to a …
Can a lawyer who regularly represents a lender represent a debtor in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy where that lender is a creditor?
Only with informed consent confirmed in writing from both clients, and only if the lawyer reasonably believes he can competently and diligently represent the debtor while adequately protecting the len…
In a North Carolina child support enforcement case, does the CSE program lawyer represent the custodial parent or the government agency?
The opinion concludes the lawyer for the child support enforcement (CSE) program represents the government agency bringing the action, not the custodian of the children, so opposing counsel may commun…
Can a lawyer serve a North Carolina subpoena on an out-of-state medical provider knowing the subpoena is unenforceable there?
No. The opinion concludes a lawyer may not use the subpoena process to mislead an out-of-state health care provider into believing it must comply with a North Carolina subpoena that is unenforceable i…
Can an insurance defense lawyer file pleadings and appear in court for an insured who has vanished and never authorized the representation?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may not appear for an insured who has not authorized the representation and with whom no client-lawyer relationship exists; the carrier's contractual authority to select…
Can a paralegal who changes firms write to the old firm's clients to announce the move and solicit their business?
The opinion concludes a lawyer has a professional obligation not to encourage or allow a nonlawyer employee to disclose a former employer's client confidences, including client identities, for solicit…
Must a prosecutor dismiss a DWI charge once a suppression order has eliminated all the evidence of guilt?
The opinion concludes a prosecutor who knows she has no admissible evidence to present must dismiss the charge before calling the case for trial, rather than calling it, offering no evidence, and forc…
Can a lawyer draft documents like a confession of judgment for an unrepresented opposing party to sign?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may prepare and present a settlement document such as a confession of judgment for an unrepresented adverse party to sign, after disclosing the lawyer represents the oth…
Must a North Carolina lawyer scrub metadata before sending electronic documents, and may a lawyer mine an opponent's metadata?
The opinion concludes a lawyer who sends an electronic communication must take reasonable precautions under Rule 1.6 to prevent confidential information in metadata from reaching unintended recipients…
Can a lawyer serve as a foreclosure trustee while the lawyer's firm keeps representing the lender on unrelated matters?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may serve as substitute trustee in a foreclosure and continue representing the beneficiary bank on unrelated matters, because the trustee role is unl…
How many years of conflict-checking data must a law firm migrate when it changes conflicts software?
The opinion concludes a firm must convert at least the last six years of conflict-checking data to its new system as a minimum standard of reasonable care, while the duties of confidentiality and conf…
Can a lawyer give a corporation or a freelance nonlawyer a blanket letter of supervision to represent parties in North Carolina unemployment hearings?
No to a corporation, and not without real supervision for an individual. The opinion concludes a lawyer may not agree to supervise a business corporation or its employees, because a corporation cannot…
Can a North Carolina lawyer copy another lawyer's brief or form language without attribution?
Yes. The opinion concludes it is not dishonest or unethical for a lawyer to incorporate excerpts from another lawyer's brief, form, or brief-bank document without attribution or consent, so long as th…
Can a real estate lawyer let a title insurer audit the lawyer's trust account, and can the lawyer use an outside reconciliation service?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may voluntarily permit a title insurer to audit a trust account used solely for real estate closings, but only for transactions the insurer insured, …
Can a lawyer use a credit card account that splits client payments into trust and operating accounts at deposit?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may use a credit card account that routes unearned fees to the trust account and earned fees to the operating account at deposit, because the funds are separated before …
What must a closing lawyer do when a title company appears to be preparing deeds in the unauthorized practice of law?
The opinion concludes the lawyer must raise the concern with the supervising attorney, and report that attorney to the State Bar only if the lawyer reasonably believes the attorney is knowingly assist…
Can a lawyer foreclose on a current client's property to collect an unpaid fee while still representing the client?
No. The opinion concludes that enforcing a security interest by foreclosing on a current client's property to collect a legal fee, even in a matter unrelated to the representation, creates a conflict …
Can a lawyer draft pleadings and advise a pro se litigant without telling the court about the help?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may give a pro se litigant behind-the-scenes assistance, including drafting pleadings and advising on courtroom strategy, without disclosing that help or ensuring t…
Can an appointed trial lawyer sign a notice of appeal for an indigent parent in a juvenile case even if the lawyer doubts the appeal has merit?
Yes. The opinion concludes it is not unethical under Rule 3.1 for an appointed trial lawyer to sign a notice of appeal to preserve an indigent parent's right to appeal in an abuse, neglect, dependency…
Can a lawyer negotiate a civil settlement that includes the plaintiff's promise not to report the defendant's conduct to law enforcement?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may participate in a civil settlement that includes a non-reporting condition, provided the condition does not amount to the crime of compounding (th…
Can the lawyer who handled a foreclosure also represent both the buyer and the bank when the bank resells the property?
Sometimes. The opinion concludes the foreclosure lawyer may represent both the buyer and the seller/bank at the resale closing only with full disclosure of the risks (including the lawyer's own prior …
Can a lawyer report an opposing party's immigration status to ICE to gain an advantage in a civil case?
No, unless the law requires it. The opinion concludes a lawyer may seek discovery of a party's citizenship status for a proper, relevant purpose, but may not report that party to ICE to gain an advant…
Can a law firm's employment agreement require a departing lawyer to pay the firm part of fees earned from clients who follow her?
Yes, but only if the formula is fair. The opinion concludes a firm may include a departure fee-division provision as long as it is reasonably calculated to compensate the firm for resources it investe…
In North Carolina, which advance legal fees must go into the trust account, and which can a lawyer treat as earned on payment?
The opinion gathers and reconciles the prior fee opinions and sorts advance fees into types: an advance payment (billed against, usually hourly) remains the client's property and must stay in the trus…
Can a lawyer hire a nonlawyer to organize and speak at estate-planning seminars, and what can the nonlawyer say or do?
Yes, a lawyer may hire a nonlawyer to give estate-planning seminars presenting general information, but the nonlawyer may not exercise independent legal judgment, give legal advice, or meet individual…
Can a lawyer deliver or manage client files through a password-protected website instead of on paper?
Yes. A lawyer may upload closing documents to a secure website and email the client a password to download them, and may use a web-based management system that gives clients online access to their own…
Can a lawyer subpoena documents from a non-party without scheduling a hearing, deposition, or trial?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may issue a subpoena to a third party to produce records without a pending hearing, deposition, or trial, so long as the subpoena complies with the current North Ca…
Can one lawyer in a firm present the administration's case to a school board while another lawyer in the same firm advises the board?
Yes, there is no conflict of interest, because both lawyers represent the school board and owe no duty of loyalty to the student or employee appearing before it; but the opinion strongly urges lawyers…
If a lawyer learns a client filed court documents under an alias, must the lawyer correct the record despite confidentiality?
It depends on materiality. The opinion concludes a lawyer has a duty under Rule 3.3 to correct previously filed court documents that contain the client's alias only if the client's name is a material …
Can a lawyer collect contact forms at a seminar, give gifts for referrals, and hand out business cards for others to distribute?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may conduct and advertise educational seminars and collect attendee feedback forms, but may not follow up by in-person or telephone solicitation and must wait for the at…
Where must the 'advertisement for legal services' notice go on a targeted direct-mail letter and envelope, and what else can appear?
The opinion concludes the required advertising notice satisfies the 'beginning of the body of the letter' requirement if it appears anywhere from the top of the page down to immediately below the salu…
Can a lawyer outsource legal support work to nonlawyers or foreign-licensed lawyers abroad?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may outsource legal support services to nonlawyers or foreign-licensed lawyers, and the assistant's location is irrelevant, so long as the lawyer satisfies the same…
Can a criminal defense lawyer who is an elected city councilor or county commissioner cross-examine police officers in the same district?
Yes, where the lawyer holds office in a council-manager or county-manager form of government in which the governing board has no direct control over a law enforcement officer's salary or employment. T…
Can a lawyer bill a client for both the time spent writing an intra-office email and the time a colleague spends reading and answering it?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may bill for intra-office communications about a client's matter, including charging for both the sender's and the recipient's time, just as participants in a neces…
Can a school board's in-house lawyer also serve as the hearing officer in student suspension and expulsion hearings?
Yes, with the board's informed consent. The opinion concludes a lawyer employed by a school board may serve as the administrative hearing officer in student discipline hearings if she reasonably belie…
Can a criminal defense lawyer take possession of a client's hidden contraband to destroy it or turn it over to authorities?
No. The opinion concludes a lawyer may not take possession of an item that is contraband (because possession is itself a crime) or facilitate its transfer in furtherance of a crime; doing so would ass…
When a lawyer files a wrongful death action for an estate, are the heirs the lawyer's clients, and what duties are owed to them?
The opinion concludes the lawyer for an estate represents the personal representative in his or her official capacity and the estate as an entity, not the heirs; the heirs are interested parties but n…
Can a lawyer bill a client for the time spent preparing and arguing a motion to withdraw from the case?
Generally no. The opinion concludes that obtaining the court's permission to withdraw is the lawyer's own professional obligation under Rule 1.16(c), so the cost may not be shifted to the client, and …
Can a lawyer keep jointly representing a husband and wife in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy after they divorce?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may continue the joint Chapter 13 representation of a now-divorced couple if the conditions of Rule 1.7(b) are met: the lawyer reasonably believes he can provide co…
If one client revokes a conflict waiver after a falling out, must the lawyer drop the other client too?
Not necessarily. The opinion concludes that under comment [21] to Rule 1.7 a client may revoke consent to a conflict at any time, but whether the lawyer must also stop representing the other client de…
Can a law firm license and keep using a lawyer's surname and likeness after that lawyer leaves the firm to practice elsewhere?
Only in part. The opinion concludes a lawyer may license his name and likeness to his professional corporation while he practices there, and the firm may keep using a lawyer's surname after his retire…
Can a law firm's stock-repurchase agreement reduce a departing lawyer's buyout based on the clients he keeps?
No. The opinion concludes that a shareholder agreement that cuts the firm's repurchase obligation to a departing lawyer in proportion to the work generated by former firm clients the lawyer continues …
Can a North Carolina lawyer who teaches at a college use the title 'doctor' based on a Juris Doctor degree?
Yes, but only within an academic setting. The opinion concludes that because unexplained use of 'doctor' for a Juris Doctor degree could be misleading, it is generally inappropriate, but in post-secon…
What must a city attorney or a lawyer serving as an elected official do when a nonlawyer appears in a representative capacity at a zoning variance hearing?
A lawyer who advises a city council must inform the council of the ruling in Authorized Practice Advisory Opinion 2006-1 (that representing a party at a quasi-judicial zoning hearing is the practice o…
If a person pays a charged consultation fee, are they a prospective client or a former client of the lawyer?
A former client, not merely a prospective client. The opinion concludes that when a lawyer charges a fee for a service, however limited, and the client pays it, a client-lawyer relationship is unequiv…
Does a guardian ad litem need the consent of a represented person's lawyer before interviewing that person?
No. The opinion concludes Rule 4.2's bar on contacting a represented person applies only during a lawyer's representation of a client, so it does not reach a nonlawyer guardian ad litem, who may inter…
Can a discharged lawyer hold a client's deposition transcript until the client repays the cost the lawyer advanced for it?
No. The opinion concludes a discharged lawyer must surrender the deposition transcript (and other file materials useful to the client) unconditionally under Rule 1.16(d) and may not condition release …
Can a lawyer autodial potential clients with a recorded message and let them press a button to be connected to the firm?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may autodial potential clients and play a recorded advertising message that is truthful and not misleading, but may not include a means for the recipient to be immediate…
When can a lawyer move disputed fees out of the trust account if the client objects but takes no legal action?
The opinion concludes a lawyer holding disputed fees in trust may transfer them to the operating account once a fee-dispute petition is dismissed (or the program closes for impasse) and the lawyer has…
Can a lawyer charge a dormancy fee against a client's unclaimed funds left in the trust account?
Yes, with conditions. The opinion concludes a lawyer may charge a dormancy fee against unclaimed trust funds if the client received prior notice of the fee and gave written consent, the amount is appr…
Can a nonlawyer, such as an architect or land-use planner, represent a party at a quasi-judicial zoning or variance hearing?
No, not in a representative advocacy role. The committee concludes that appearing on behalf of another person, firm, or corporation at a quasi-judicial proceeding (a hearing on a special-use permit or…
Can a lawyer join a for-profit networking and referral organization that encourages members to trade business referrals?
Yes, but only on conditions. The opinion concludes a lawyer may belong to a for-profit networking organization only if making referrals to other members is not a condition of membership and the lawyer…
Can a lawyer have a paralegal sign the lawyer's name to a court pleading when the lawyer is unavailable?
Only in limited circumstances. The opinion concludes a lawyer should ordinarily sign court documents herself and may delegate signing her name to a nonlawyer only when she and any other firm lawyer ar…
Can a lawyer borrow from a litigation funding company to cover the costs of a contingency case, and pass the financing cost to the client?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may finance litigation costs through a litigation funding company if the company's practices are lawful and the loan does not tie repayment to a perc…
What must a lawyer do when a guardian ad litem insists on pursuing a claim the lawyer believes is frivolous and against the minor's interests?
The opinion concludes that the lawyer owes confidentiality to both the minor (the real party in interest) and the guardian ad litem in her official capacity, and that if the lawyer believes the claim …
Browse North Carolina State Bar opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the North Carolina State Bar interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.