North Carolina State Bar Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the North Carolina State Bar, with full citations and source links on every page.
No North Carolina State Bar opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a North Carolina estate planning lawyer put a clause in the engagement agreement requiring the client's estate to pay the lawyer's fees for responding to subpoenas, discovery, or testimony about the estate plan?
Not as drafted. A broad clause billing the estate for any future testimony is too vague and clearly excessive, but a narrow, capped, clearly disclosed, and consented version is permitted.
Can a North Carolina lawyer use artificial intelligence, including generative AI, to help provide legal services?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may use AI if the lawyer does so competently, protects client confidentiality, supervises the AI's work product, and bills honestly; the lawyer remains fully respon…
Can a North Carolina lawyer who serves several clients at once, like a single calendar call or working for one client while traveling for another, bill each client for the same overlapping time?
The lawyer may serve multiple clients at once but may not bill each full hourly rates for the same overlapping time; the lawyer must prorate the actual time, or use a flat or unit fee, and pass the ef…
In a residential closing where the buyer and seller have separate lawyers, can the buyer's lawyer charge the seller for work, like reviewing the other side's documents or clearing title?
Generally no. Work the buyer's lawyer does for the buyer can be charged to the seller only with the seller's agreement, the buyer's informed consent under Rule 1.8(f), and a fee that is not illegal or…
Can a North Carolina lawyer accept Bitcoin or other virtual currency as a legal fee, and can the lawyer hold a client's virtual currency in trust?
A lawyer may accept virtual currency as an earned flat fee if the fee is not clearly excessive and the lawyer complies with Rule 1.8(a) (treating it as a business transaction with the client), includi…
Can a North Carolina lawyer buy litigation cost protection insurance for a contingency case and charge the premium back to the client out of any recovery?
Yes. A lawyer may buy litigation cost protection insurance for contingency cases if it does not compromise independent judgment or the client's settlement authority, and may shift the premium to the c…
Can a North Carolina lawyer offer clients on-site access to a financial brokerage company that finances legal fees?
Yes, under conditions. A lawyer may offer on-site access to a fee-financing broker as one payment option if the arrangement is legal, the lawyer receives no consideration from the company, and the law…
Can a North Carolina lawyer reveal a client's settlement amount to the client's former lawyer who is claiming a share of the fee?
Only with consent or under the self-defense exception. Settlement details are confidential under Rule 1.6, so absent the client's consent the lawyer may not disclose them to the discharged predecessor…
In a closing for a bank-owned foreclosed property, may the seller's lawyer also represent the buyer, and if the buyer declines, may the firm represent only the seller and still charge the buyer?
The lawyer may jointly represent buyer and seller only if Rule 1.7 is satisfied, including informed consent confirmed in writing and disclosure of the firm's ongoing relationship with the seller. If t…
When a North Carolina lawyer collects money from a client to pay a third-party expense like a court reporter, must the money go into the trust account?
Yes. Money a client gives a lawyer to pay a third party in connection with legal services is entrusted property and must be deposited in the trust account, regardless of who is contractually obligated…
Is a fee-division agreement between a departing lawyer and the firm enforceable under the ethics rules, or is it a forbidden restriction on the right to practice?
The opinion concludes the agreement complied with the rules. Because it was negotiated after the associate announced his departure, was not a condition of continued employment, did not deter him from …
Can a North Carolina lawyer charge interest or finance charges on a client's overdue bill without the client having agreed to it in advance?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may impose finance charges on a delinquent client account under N.C. Gen. Stat. section 24-11 without an advance agreement, so long as the lawyer first gives writte…
Can a North Carolina lawyer keep disputed legal fees in the trust account when the client demands return of entrusted estate funds?
No. The opinion concludes that funds entrusted to a lawyer to be safeguarded or managed, and not designated as payment of a fee, may not be held in trust as 'disputed' funds under Rule 1.15-2(g); the …
Can a personal injury firm charge for home or hospital visits on top of a contingency fee if it advertises free consultations?
The opinion concludes a firm may charge the actual travel expense of an out-of-office consultation in addition to a contingent fee, but may not charge a flat amount untethered to actual cost, and must…
Can a lawyer use a credit card account that splits client payments into trust and operating accounts at deposit?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may use a credit card account that routes unearned fees to the trust account and earned fees to the operating account at deposit, because the funds are separated before …
Can a lawyer foreclose on a current client's property to collect an unpaid fee while still representing the client?
No. The opinion concludes that enforcing a security interest by foreclosing on a current client's property to collect a legal fee, even in a matter unrelated to the representation, creates a conflict …
Can a law firm's employment agreement require a departing lawyer to pay the firm part of fees earned from clients who follow her?
Yes, but only if the formula is fair. The opinion concludes a firm may include a departure fee-division provision as long as it is reasonably calculated to compensate the firm for resources it investe…
In North Carolina, which advance legal fees must go into the trust account, and which can a lawyer treat as earned on payment?
The opinion gathers and reconciles the prior fee opinions and sorts advance fees into types: an advance payment (billed against, usually hourly) remains the client's property and must stay in the trus…
Can a lawyer bill a client for both the time spent writing an intra-office email and the time a colleague spends reading and answering it?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may bill for intra-office communications about a client's matter, including charging for both the sender's and the recipient's time, just as participants in a neces…
Can a lawyer bill a client for the time spent preparing and arguing a motion to withdraw from the case?
Generally no. The opinion concludes that obtaining the court's permission to withdraw is the lawyer's own professional obligation under Rule 1.16(c), so the cost may not be shifted to the client, and …
If a person pays a charged consultation fee, are they a prospective client or a former client of the lawyer?
A former client, not merely a prospective client. The opinion concludes that when a lawyer charges a fee for a service, however limited, and the client pays it, a client-lawyer relationship is unequiv…
Can a discharged lawyer hold a client's deposition transcript until the client repays the cost the lawyer advanced for it?
No. The opinion concludes a discharged lawyer must surrender the deposition transcript (and other file materials useful to the client) unconditionally under Rule 1.16(d) and may not condition release …
When can a lawyer move disputed fees out of the trust account if the client objects but takes no legal action?
The opinion concludes a lawyer holding disputed fees in trust may transfer them to the operating account once a fee-dispute petition is dismissed (or the program closes for impasse) and the lawyer has…
Can a lawyer charge a dormancy fee against a client's unclaimed funds left in the trust account?
Yes, with conditions. The opinion concludes a lawyer may charge a dormancy fee against unclaimed trust funds if the client received prior notice of the fee and gave written consent, the amount is appr…
Can a lawyer borrow from a litigation funding company to cover the costs of a contingency case, and pass the financing cost to the client?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may finance litigation costs through a litigation funding company if the company's practices are lawful and the loan does not tie repayment to a perc…
When a North Carolina lawyer charges a 'minimum fee' billed against an hourly rate and then leaves the firm, must the firm refund the unearned portion to the clients?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a minimum fee billed against the lawyer's hourly rate is client money that belongs in the trust account until earned, not a true retainer or flat fee that may be deposi…
When a third party pays a North Carolina lawyer's fee for a client, who owns the unearned funds and what must the lawyer do if the payor demands them back?
It depends on the source and the fee type. The opinion concludes a lawyer generally follows the client's directive for funds belonging to the client and owes no duty to a stranger merely claiming an i…
Can a North Carolina real estate firm hold recording and courier costs in a separate non-trust account and keep the markup if actual costs come in lower?
Only with safeguards. The opinion concludes that funds collected at a closing to pay recording and courier costs remain client funds until disbursed, so a 'Recording Account' holding them must be a tr…
Can a North Carolina bankruptcy lawyer let clients complete the required credit-counseling course in the lawyer's office using a third-party provider, and collect the provider's fee?
Yes, with disclosure and no markup. The opinion concludes a bankruptcy lawyer may offer prospective clients the chance to complete the federally required pre-filing credit-counseling course in the off…
Can a North Carolina lawyer reveal a client's confidential information in a suit to collect an unpaid fee, including to support a claim to pierce the corporate veil?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes that Rule 1.6(b)(6)'s self-defense exception lets the lawyer disclose confidential information learned in the representation to establish a corporate-veil-pie…
Can a North Carolina lawyer collect both a contingent fee and a separate court-awarded attorney fee from the same personal injury case?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may collect both the contingent fee and a court-awarded fee, or some portion, so long as the total is consistent with the fee agreement and not clearly excessive under R…
When a client got a discounted rate through a legal services plan, can the lawyer's fee petition recite the lawyer's full rate instead of the discounted rate actually charged?
No. The opinion concluded the fee petition must recite the discounted hourly rate actually charged; under Rule 3.3(a)(2) the lawyer cannot present the full rate, though he may explain the discount and…
Can a North Carolina lawyer charge a flat fee in advance and call it nonrefundable, keeping it even if the representation ends early?
No fee is truly nonrefundable. The opinion concluded a lawyer may take a flat fee into the operating account if the client agrees it is earned when paid, but must refund any portion that is clearly ex…
Can a North Carolina lawyer bill the client for the time spent responding to a fee dispute petition filed with the State Bar?
No. The opinion concluded that participating in the State Bar's fee dispute resolution program is not a legal service and is a mandatory professional responsibility, so a lawyer may not charge the cli…
Can a North Carolina insurance defense lawyer send the insured's bills to the insurer's outside audit company based on a consent form the insurer collected?
The opinion concluded the lawyer may not rely on a consent form the insurer obtained from the insured unless the lawyer consults with the insured to confirm the consent is informed; the lawyer must ev…
Must a North Carolina closing lawyer keep chasing a lender to cancel a paid-off deed of trust, and does charging a fee change that duty?
The opinion concluded the duty to obtain cancellation of a paid deed of trust turns on the lawyer's agreement with the client and lender; the lawyer may limit the scope of representation but must clea…
Can a North Carolina insurance defense lawyer follow the insurer's billing guidelines that cap research and bar certain tasks?
Not without the insured's consent. The opinion concluded that the insured is the lawyer's primary client, so billing requirements that would restrain the lawyer's independent professional judgment in …
Can a North Carolina lawyer help a client raise money from the public to pay the client's legal fees?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may participate in soliciting third-party funds to defray a client's legal expenses if Rule 1.8(f) is satisfied; the lawyer must administer the funds honestly, hold any …
Can a lawyer charge a former client for the cost of pulling a closed file out of storage?
Yes, with conditions. The opinion concluded a lawyer could charge the actual cost of retrieving a closed file only after timely notifying the client of the storage and retrieval-charge arrangement, an…
Can a North Carolina insurance defense lawyer send detailed bills to the insurer's outside audit company?
The opinion concluded that legal bills are confidential and an insurance defense lawyer may submit detailed bills to the insurer's outside audit company only with the insured's informed consent after …
Can a North Carolina lawyer charge a fee labeled 'nonrefundable,' and where must advance fees and flat fees be deposited?
The opinion concluded a lawyer should not label any fee 'nonrefundable' because any clearly excessive portion must always be refunded; flat fees and true general retainers may go directly to the opera…
Can a North Carolina lawyer accept credit card payments into a trust account when the bank's merchant agreement lets it charge back the account without notice?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may accept credit card payments subject to a chargeback only if other clients' trust funds are protected (by debiting a non-trust account or a dedicated trust account), …
Can a North Carolina law firm add finance charges or interest to clients' past-due bills, and what notice or agreement is required?
The opinion concluded a firm may add finance charges to past-due accounts only as allowed by usury and consumer-credit law: legal-rate interest is available under the statute without prior notice, but…
How should a North Carolina lawyer handle fee payments received by electronic transfer or credit card when the bank can deposit them into only one account?
Because the bank cannot split a transfer between earned and unearned fees, all electronic-transfer payments should go into the trust account, with earned fees withdrawn promptly. The lawyer may pass t…
Can a North Carolina lawyer charge a hybrid fee, a minimum hourly or flat fee plus a contingent fee on any recovery?
Yes, a combined minimum (hourly or flat) plus contingent fee is permitted as long as the total fee actually charged is not clearly excessive. The lawyer should explain how the fee is calculated, give …
Can a North Carolina lawyer collect a one-third contingent fee on the gross recovery and an additional contingent fee for recovering the medical insurer's reimbursement claim?
The opinion did not decide whether a fee for collecting the insurer's claim is allowed by law, but cautioned that adding it to the one-third contingent fee may make the total clearly excessive. The la…
Can a North Carolina lawyer require a client to sign a confession of judgment to secure the fee before doing any legal work?
No. The opinion concluded a lawyer may not obtain a confession of judgment from a client before rendering services, because it lets the lawyer collect a possibly excessive fee and bypass the mandatory…
Can a North Carolina lawyer charge another lawyer a referral fee, set it as a percentage or flat amount, and how much must the client be told?
Yes, if the fee-division rule is met: the client is advised of and does not object to all lawyers' participation, each lawyer assumes joint responsibility (or the split is proportional), and the total…
In a domestic case, can a lawyer secure an unpaid fee with a deed of trust on the client's real property, including property that is the subject of the litigation?
Yes, if the transaction is fair to the client. The opinion concluded a deed of trust securing fees is not the kind of proprietary interest in the litigation the conflict rule forbids, even on the prop…
Can a firm agree to stop billing its association client on uncollected collection cases and make up the loss by charging higher fees to the debtors from whom fees are recovered?
No. The opinion concluded that inflating the fee charged to recovered-from debtors to offset losses on uncollected cases produces a clearly excessive fee, and misrepresenting the actual fee to a court…
Can a lawyer's fee agreement direct the clerk of court to send a domestic client's alimony or child support payments to the lawyer to cover unpaid fees?
No. The opinion concluded that directing support payments to the lawyer gives the lawyer a prohibited proprietary interest in the subject of the litigation under Rule 5.3(a); the advance-fee provision…
When a client gets new counsel and asks for the file but refuses to pay copying costs, who bears the expense of copying, and how is the file divided when the lawyer represented several clients in the same matter?
The opinion concluded the file belongs to the client and a withdrawing lawyer must deliver it, bearing the copy cost only for the one set she keeps for her own records; original documents that relate …
When a firm bills by the hour, may it charge a new client for legal research it already did and billed to an earlier, unrelated client?
No. The opinion concluded that under an hourly fee agreement, billing a client for reused work product the lawyer did not spend time on is dishonest conduct; the lawyer may bill for time tailoring old…
Can a lawyer charge a sliding fee, scaled to the size of the claim, to collect a client's medical-payments benefits under the client's own auto insurance policy?
No. The opinion concluded that a fee for collecting med-pay scaled to the amount of the claim rather than the cost of the work is unreasonable under Rule 2.6(a), because most med-pay claims carry no r…
Can a lawyer treat an advance fee as immediately earned and spend it right away, and is a fixed traffic-case fee that covers fines and costs an improper contingent fee?
The opinion concluded that an advance fee is a deposit that must stay in trust and be refunded if unearned unless the lawyer clearly tells the client it is earned immediately and the client agrees; a …
Can the lawyer appointed to represent a minor in a friendly suit to approve an injury settlement be paid directly by the defendant's liability insurer?
Yes. The opinion concluded that Rule 5.6 lets a lawyer be paid by a third party such as the liability insurer if the client consents after full disclosure, the lawyer's independent judgment is not imp…
Can a firm with an hourly-rate fee contract raise its rates during the engagement without getting the client's consent to the increase?
The opinion declined to construe the fee contract as a question of law, but held that a lawyer may renegotiate a fee for changed circumstances or good cause without abandoning or threatening to abando…
Can a lawyer pay another lawyer outside the firm a share of the fee just for a referral, when that lawyer did no work and the client never agreed?
The opinion concluded that lawyers not in the same firm may divide a fee only if the split is proportional to the work each did, or the client agrees in writing, each lawyer assumes joint responsibili…
Can a law firm pay a paralegal a monthly bonus calculated as a percentage of the fees from the closings the paralegal worked on?
The opinion concluded that the firm may not pay the paralegal a bonus calculated as a percentage of the legal fees the firm receives from matters the paralegal worked on, because that is sharing legal…
Can a lawyer put a clause in a contingency fee agreement requiring the lawyer's consent before the client settles the case?
The opinion concluded that a lawyer cannot divest a client of the exclusive authority to settle, because Rule 7.1(c)(1) requires the lawyer to abide by the client's decision whether to accept a settle…
Browse North Carolina State Bar opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the North Carolina State Bar interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.