North Carolina State Bar Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the North Carolina State Bar, with full citations and source links on every page.
No North Carolina State Bar opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
When a North Carolina lawyer leaves a firm, must affected clients be notified, and can the firm withhold the clients' contact information from the departing lawyer?
Yes, clients affected by the departure must be notified, and the departing lawyer and firm share that duty. The firm may not restrict the departing lawyer's access to affected clients' contact informa…
When a North Carolina lawyer sells or closes a law practice, who must be notified, what happens to old client files and original documents, and when can files be destroyed?
Under Rule 1.17, the seller must notify current clients and former clients whose files transfer, return or safeguard original documents of legal significance regardless of age, may destroy ordinary fi…
Can a North Carolina lawyer be privately retained for a limited role, like just a bond hearing, for an indigent criminal defendant who already has appointed counsel?
Yes. The lawyer may consult with the represented defendant and take a reasonable limited-scope role with the defendant's informed consent, must tell the court of the limited appearance, should notify …
When a North Carolina lawyer is appointed after a criminal defendant files a pro se motion for appropriate relief, must counsel amend it or tell the court the cited authority is no longer good law?
No. Appointed counsel is not obligated to adopt the defendant's pro se MAR or to correct it, because counsel made no false representations to the court. If counsel concludes the MAR is frivolous, coun…
If a former client waits to object to her old lawyer's adverse representation, must the lawyer withdraw under Rule 1.9?
Not necessarily. The opinion concludes that although mere delay is usually not a waiver of a former client's right to object under Rule 1.9(a), a former client's failure to object in time can amount t…
When is a North Carolina lawyer a 'necessary witness' who must withdraw as trial advocate under Rule 3.7, and does the bar reach pretrial work or self-representation?
A lawyer is a 'necessary witness' under Rule 3.7 when the testimony is relevant, material, and unobtainable by other means; the lawyer must keep evaluating this as the case develops and must withdraw …
Can an insurance defense lawyer file pleadings and appear in court for an insured who has vanished and never authorized the representation?
The opinion concludes a lawyer may not appear for an insured who has not authorized the representation and with whom no client-lawyer relationship exists; the carrier's contractual authority to select…
If a lawyer learns a client filed court documents under an alias, must the lawyer correct the record despite confidentiality?
It depends on materiality. The opinion concludes a lawyer has a duty under Rule 3.3 to correct previously filed court documents that contain the client's alias only if the client's name is a material …
Can a lawyer bill a client for the time spent preparing and arguing a motion to withdraw from the case?
Generally no. The opinion concludes that obtaining the court's permission to withdraw is the lawyer's own professional obligation under Rule 1.16(c), so the cost may not be shifted to the client, and …
Can a discharged lawyer hold a client's deposition transcript until the client repays the cost the lawyer advanced for it?
No. The opinion concludes a discharged lawyer must surrender the deposition transcript (and other file materials useful to the client) unconditionally under Rule 1.16(d) and may not condition release …
What must a lawyer do when a guardian ad litem insists on pursuing a claim the lawyer believes is frivolous and against the minor's interests?
The opinion concludes that the lawyer owes confidentiality to both the minor (the real party in interest) and the guardian ad litem in her official capacity, and that if the lawyer believes the claim …
When an appointed client disappears, can the lawyer advocate for the outcome the facts seem to support, or must the lawyer move to withdraw?
No, the lawyer may not substitute his own objectives. The opinion concludes that when an appointed client has disappeared and her objectives are unknown, the lawyer must use reasonable diligence to lo…
When a lawyer represents an estate and the administratrix has a personal interest that conflicts with the estate, must the lawyer withdraw?
The opinion concludes the lawyer represents the estate and the personal representative in her official capacity, not individually. If estate assets are enough to pay creditors, the lawyer need not wit…
What must a North Carolina lawyer do after learning a client concealed income in a consent judgment about to be presented to the court?
The opinion concluded the lawyer may not present a consent judgment based on false income information; the lawyer must try to persuade the client to disclose the truth, must withdraw if the client ref…
In North Carolina, what can an insurance defense lawyer do when the insured will not cooperate and wants the plaintiffs to win?
The opinion concluded the lawyer represents both the insurer and the insured; where the insured has contractually surrendered control of the defense, the lawyer generally follows the insurer's instruc…
Can a North Carolina lawyer represent several accident victims with claims against the same limited insurance fund?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may represent multiple claimants in a common accident, even when limited insurance funds put them in competition, if there are no crossclaims among them and each gives i…
Can a North Carolina closing lawyer represent the buyer, seller, and lender together in a residential real estate closing, and what must the lawyer do if a conflict develops?
Yes, common representation is permitted once the parties have agreed to the basic terms and their interests are generally aligned, if the lawyer can act impartially and gets each party's consent after…
What must a North Carolina lawyer do when a client disappears and cannot be located before the statute of limitations runs, and can the lawyer file suit to protect the claim?
After reasonable efforts to locate the client fail, the disappearance is a constructive discharge, so the lawyer must withdraw. The opinion concluded the lawyer may not file a complaint for the missin…
If a client admits he lied under oath in a verified complaint and deposition, is dismissing the case enough, or must the lawyer do more after the client perjured himself?
Dismissal is not enough. The opinion concluded the lawyer must call on the client to rectify the fraud by letting the lawyer disclose the false statements to opposing counsel, and must withdraw if the…
If a lawyer appointed to a capital case believes in good faith he is not competent to handle it, can he challenge the appointment or refuse to serve, and does his malpractice insurer's concern create a conflict?
The opinion concluded the lawyer must first advise the court, may challenge the appointment by lawful means if he still believes he is incompetent, and may refuse and accept sanction after exhausting …
If stand-by counsel in a capital trial are suddenly told to take over the defense without time to prepare, can they decline to present a defense, and may they create grounds for an ineffective-assistance claim?
The opinion concluded that after seeking a continuance, moving to withdraw, and exhausting legal remedies, stand-by counsel who in good faith conclude they cannot present a competent defense may decli…
When a client gets new counsel and asks for the file but refuses to pay copying costs, who bears the expense of copying, and how is the file divided when the lawyer represented several clients in the same matter?
The opinion concluded the file belongs to the client and a withdrawing lawyer must deliver it, bearing the copy cost only for the one set she keeps for her own records; original documents that relate …
When a former client asks for the file, does the lawyer have to hand over the lawyer's own title notes, and can the lawyer charge for copies of documents the client already received?
The opinion concluded that a lawyer's personal title notes are work product the lawyer need not release, and that the lawyer may charge a former client for additional copies of documents already deliv…
When an insurer has paid its full limits and is released from the duty to defend, what must the lawyer it retained tell the insureds about whether they are still represented?
The opinion concluded that once the insurer has paid its full limits and is statutorily released from the duty to defend, the lawyer it retained must promptly inform the insureds in writing that he wi…
Must a lawyer withdraw from defending an estate when the lawyer will likely be called to testify about assurances he allegedly gave a claimant?
The opinion concluded that the lawyer is disqualified and may not continue defending the estate, because his testimony will be necessary on disputed facts, especially whether he assured the claimant t…
Can one attorney represent both an injured child and the parents, who have their own emotional-distress claim, against the same physician?
The opinion concluded that, although the interests of parents and child are potentially in conflict, the same attorney may represent the parents and through them the child in pre-suit negotiation, and…
Can one firm represent parents on their own injury claims and also the injured child whose claim shares the same settlement fund?
The opinion concluded that a firm cannot represent both the parents on their individual claims and the child, through the parents as guardians ad litem, when a single insurer's settlement fund must be…
If a criminal case ends early, must a lawyer refund part of a flat fee even though the fee was described as nonrefundable?
The opinion concluded that, because a lawyer may never charge or collect a clearly excessive fee, the lawyer must look back at all the circumstances to decide whether the flat fee was reasonable; to t…
If an insured revokes his earlier consent to dismiss his counterclaim so the insurer can settle, can the defense lawyer dismiss it anyway?
The opinion concluded that the lawyer may not voluntarily dismiss the insured's counterclaim with prejudice once the insured has revoked authority to do so, even though the insured signed an advance a…
When a firm declines a case after reviewing medical records it paid for, can it withhold those records until the client repays the cost?
The opinion concluded that a firm that declines a case after evaluating it must turn over unconditionally to the client any material, such as medical records or expert opinions obtained on the client'…
When a law firm dissolves, what duties do the principals owe to clients and to each other?
The opinion concluded that dissolving lawyers must continue serving clients until matters conclude or withdrawal is permitted, notify clients in a way that preserves their free choice of counsel, deal…
When a criminal client is charged under an alias hiding a prior record, must defense counsel disclose it, and what happens if the client testifies falsely?
The opinion concluded that before trial counsel has no duty to disclose the client's true name or record and must keep it confidential; at trial counsel may not present perjured testimony or defraud t…
Can one firm represent the estates of both the pilot and the passenger killed in the same plane crash when the defendant will likely join the pilot's estate?
The opinion concluded that a firm may represent both estates if it obtains informed consent from both and reasonably judges that neither representation will be adversely affected, but it must keep eva…
Can insurer-appointed defense counsel for uninsured motorists withdraw once the insurer settles with its own insured and wants to pursue subrogation against those same motorists?
The opinion concluded that the lawyer may not simply withdraw from the uninsured motorists he represents; he must comply with the tribunal's rules, take reasonable steps to avoid foreseeable prejudice…
When a lawyer's deeds for a client turn out to be the wrong instruments and harm the original owners' title, what may the lawyer disclose and what must he do about the client's inaction?
The opinion concluded that the client's statements are confidential, but the lawyer is impliedly authorized to disclose the problem to the original owners and suggest corrective action unless the clie…
In an uncontested divorce, what may the plaintiff's lawyer send the unrepresented defendant, and can the defendant help pay the plaintiff's fee?
The opinion concluded that the plaintiff's lawyer may send the defendant the summons and complaint for acceptance of service, but may not send a form answer, a draft answer admitting the allegations, …
When a client fires a lawyer and hires a new one, must the discharged lawyer turn over the entire file, including his own work product?
The opinion concluded that a discharged or withdrawing lawyer must deliver the papers and property to which the client is entitled, and generally anything helpful to the new lawyer, but need not turn …
Browse North Carolina State Bar opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the North Carolina State Bar interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.