New York Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a New York county require fingerprinting and criminal background checks for nursing home and personal care employees, including those at private nursing homes?
Mixed. The county could require fingerprinting and criminal history checks for its own county-owned nursing home employees and (with state Department of Health approval) for personal care contractors …
Can the same person serve as both a water district commissioner and a fire district commissioner in New York when the two districts contract for hydrants and water service?
Yes, but conditionally. One person could hold both offices if matters affecting both districts came up rarely. He or she had to recuse on the hydrant contract, water sales, and backflow testing. If co…
Must a New York city publish its plumbing regulations as a chapter of the city code, and can a building inspector handle plumbing inspections when the plumbing inspector is unavailable?
The city did not have to keep plumbing rules in the City Code: a separately published pamphlet of rules from the plumbing board satisfied General City Law § 44(3). And a building inspector could perfo…
Does a New York village trustee who owns property in a Business Improvement District have a conflict of interest that requires recusal on the BID budget vote?
It depends on the size of the trustee's stake. The AG laid out a Tuxedo-Parker framework: if the trustee's interest in the BID budget outcome is substantial and direct (large property holding, a propo…
Can a New York village design review board include a practicing architect whose firm occasionally has projects before the board?
Yes. The architect did not have to resign as long as his firm's projects came before the board only rarely (about once a year). On those occasions he had to recuse entirely. If conflicts became freque…
Can a New York city building department typist also serve on the same city's zoning board of appeals?
No. The AG concluded the positions were incompatible because the typist's supervisor (the building inspector and zoning administrator) had determinations subject to review by the zoning board, creatin…
Can a New York city pass a local law letting its city court judge live in the county instead of the city?
No. The AG concluded a city may not adopt a local law inconsistent with Public Officers Law § 3 and Uniform City Court Act § 2104, which require a city court judge to reside in the city. Even if those…
Can a New York taxicab charge a different fare for the same trip at different times of day?
Yes, as long as the different fares and the conditions under which they apply are conspicuously posted inside the cab. The AG concluded that General Business Law § 396-p(1) assumes fare variation is a…
Can a New York city pay back a council member's court filing fees for a personal Open Meetings Law lawsuit against the city that was dismissed?
No. The AG concluded the gift-or-loan clause of N.Y. Const. Art. VIII § 1 bars the reimbursement. Bringing an Open Meetings Law suit is not within a city council member's official duties; the council …
Can the Town of Riverhead, in Suffolk County, eliminate its elected receiver of taxes position?
Yes. The AG concluded Town Law § 36(1) lets a second-class town abolish the receiver of taxes office by resolution and transfer its functions to the town clerk. The Suffolk County Tax Act (L. 1920, ch…
Can a New York town ban using old mobile homes as backyard storage units?
The AG concluded a town has authority to regulate old mobile homes used as fixed-base storage facilities under Town Law § 130(16) and its police power, but cannot adopt a blanket prohibition that skip…
Can a New York county let ATV riders use county reforested lands and give an ATV club exclusive use of trails the club builds there?
Mixed: yes to ATV use and trail construction, no to exclusive use. The AG concluded County Law § 219(1) authorizes recreational use of county reforested lands and VTL § 2405(2) lets a municipality des…
Can a Dutchess County E-911 senior fire alarm dispatcher also serve on the county fire and safety advisory board and as a volunteer firefighter?
Yes. The AG concluded that the senior fire alarm dispatcher position and membership on the county fire and safety advisory board are compatible: neither is subordinate to the other, the board's duties…
Can an agent of a New York animal cruelty society from one county exercise peace officer powers in another county that has its own society?
Mostly no. The AG concluded an agent of an SPCA from an adjacent county cannot issue appearance tickets, summon, or arrest people for Agriculture and Markets Law Article 26 violations within a county …
Did the federal E-SIGN Act force New York county clerks to accept real estate deeds and other recordable instruments bearing only electronic signatures (and not handwritten ones)?
Probably not. The Attorney General concluded in 2001 that there was a substantial possibility that E-SIGN did not preempt Article 9 of New York's Real Property Law, because real-property recordation i…
Does the New York county clerk have to index Mortgage Electronic Registration Systems (MERS) as the mortgagee when MERS is just a nominee and has no actual interest in the loan?
No. The AG concluded the Nassau County Clerk has no obligation to record MERS as the mortgagee of record where MERS has no legal interest in the mortgage. Doing so would violate Real Property Law § 31…
Can a New York county ban drivers from using hand-held cell phones on its roads, or does state law preempt the local rule?
There is a substantial possibility the local law would be preempted. The AG concluded that Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1604 expressly prohibits local laws that 'in any other way' restrict motor vehicles…
Does a mortgage banker or broker's bankruptcy filing pause a New York State Banking Department proceeding to suspend or revoke its license for consumer fraud or undercapitalization?
No. The AG concluded that an NYSBD enforcement action under Banking Law § 595 for fraudulent consumer practices or undercapitalization fits the 'police or regulatory power' exception to the bankruptcy…
If a developer sues a New York village board, do the board members automatically have to recuse from later applications by the same developer or a related entity?
No. Pending litigation does not automatically disqualify board members from hearing later applications by the plaintiff. The board must look at the specific facts, including personal liability exposur…
Can a New York village charge for use of its public docks with a parking meter, and run boat parking tickets through a village traffic court?
The village may use meters to collect dock fees but cannot run boat parking tickets through a traffic violations bureau. The AG concluded that Village Law § 4-412(3)(8) lets a village charge for use o…
Can the same person serve as both the village's volunteer fire chief and its fire marshal in New York?
No, on the specific Southampton facts. The AG concluded that because the Southampton Village Code gave the fire marshal authority to investigate whether the fire department and fire chief had responde…
When a New York village votes to move its general election from March to November, how are sitting officers' terms adjusted to avoid gaps in office?
The AG concluded the terms of incumbent and newly elected officers are extended (never truncated) to bridge the gap to the new election date. Election Law § 15-104(2) extends the terms of officers ele…
Can a New York county use its home rule authority to require prior written notice of road defects only to the clerk of the legislative body, rather than to the clerk or the highway superintendent as Highway Law § 139 contemplates?
Yes. The AG concluded that Highway Law § 139(2) was not a 'general law' for home rule purposes because it applied only to counties that elected to adopt it. The Municipal Home Rule Law lets counties e…
Can a New York town contract with a private individual to be its dog control officer?
No. The AG concluded that Agriculture and Markets Law § 114(1) gave municipalities only two options: appoint an officer-employee directly, or contract with another municipality, an incorporated humane…
Can a New York county charge snowmobile users a fee to access county roads or public lands?
No. The AG concluded that the Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Law expressly bars municipalities from imposing fees for snowmobile use of public lands or waters, except the usual admission,…
Can Nassau County, by local law, take zoning power away from the Town of Hempstead and give it to the Village of Atlantic Beach?
Yes. Nassau County may amend its County Charter by local law under N.Y. Const. Art. IX, § 1(h)(1) and Municipal Home Rule Law Article 4 to transfer the zoning function from the Town of Hempstead to th…
In New York, can the same person serve as town assessor and as a member of the school board?
Yes. The AG concluded the two offices are compatible. No statute barred the combination (Town Law § 20(4) covers only elective town offices and the assessor here was appointive; Education Law § 2103 d…
Can a New York district attorney also sit on a BOCES board or a local school board?
No. The AG concluded that the elected part-time district attorney's broad, nondelegable prosecutorial discretion was incompatible with holding policymaking positions on the BOCES and school board with…
Can a New York city ask the state to install a 15 mph school speed limit on a state highway running past a college?
No. The AG concluded that colleges and universities are not 'schools' under Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1620, because the DOT regulation governing school speed limit signs requires the institution to ha…
Can a town in New York appoint its tax certiorari defense attorney to serve as deputy supervisor?
No. The AG concluded the conflict was structural, not waivable. As deputy supervisor, the attorney would negotiate his own contract renewal with colleagues on the board and advise the town board on li…
In New York, can the county legislature let social services department attorneys handle their own litigation without going through the county attorney?
Yes. The AG concluded that under Social Services Law § 66(1), a county legislative body may directly authorize attorneys appointed by the social services commissioner to represent the department in li…
In New York, can a part-time assistant county attorney also serve as mayor of a city in that county?
Yes, under the facts presented. The AG concluded the positions are compatible: County Law § 411 does not bar the combination, the two positions are in separate governmental units (no subordination), a…
Does a New York public library need voter approval to be dissolved and to transfer its property to a free association library?
Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Abolition under Education Law § 268 requires voter approval. But the Board of Regents can dissolve a public library under §§ 219 and 220 without voter approval, and a libr…
Which acknowledgment form do New York county clerks use for real property deeds, corporate documents, and out-of-state filings?
Three rules. Real property conveyances (including by corporations) and non-real-property filings by non-corporations use § 309-a. Non-real-property corporate filings use § 309. Out-of-State acknowledg…
Does a New York municipality have to pass a local law to adopt Public Officers Law § 18 defense and indemnification for its employees, or can a resolution do it?
A simple resolution works. The AG concluded Public Officers Law § 18(2)(a) explicitly lists 'local law, bylaw, resolution, rule or regulation' as ways to adopt the statutory scheme. A municipality can…
Can a New York town extend its supervisor's term from two years to four when that supervisor also sits on the county board of supervisors?
Yes, but only by board resolution subject to a mandatory voter referendum, not by local law. The AG concluded that Town Law § 24-a (added in 1981) permits towns to lengthen the supervisor's term to fo…
Can a small New York town let its highway superintendent live outside the town?
Yes. The AG concluded a town may enact a local law broadening the residency requirement for highway superintendent and deputy. Because the Legislature has already given the Towns of New Castle and Pou…
Can a New York fire district require volunteer firefighters to have a high school diploma?
Yes. The AG concluded a board of fire commissioners may set membership qualifications including a high school diploma or equivalency requirement under Town Law § 176(11). Alternative path: requiring S…
Do New York charter school construction, renovation, and repair projects have to pay prevailing wages under Labor Law § 220?
Generally yes. Charter schools are public schools serving an essential public purpose, so projects to build, renovate, or repair their facilities are usually 'public works' subject to Labor Law § 220'…
Can a New York town cut timber on town park land to maintain the park and improve it with the proceeds?
Yes, for limited, selective cutting that preserves the park and enhances public use, with proceeds spent on park improvements. The AG concluded this is consistent with State law. Full commercial timbe…
Can a New York city pass a local law making it illegal for a council member to leak what happened in an executive session?
Yes. The AG concluded a municipality may prohibit executive-session disclosure through its code of ethics under General Municipal Law § 806 or by local law under Municipal Home Rule Law § 10. The rest…
Can New York police arrest someone without a warrant for being in the country illegally?
Only if the person is suspected of criminally violating the Immigration and Nationality Act, not just being civilly out of status. The AG concluded New York officers can make warrantless arrests for c…
When a New York environmental conservation officer makes an arrest for a Fish and Wildlife Law offense, does the Penal Law's general firearm seizure rule apply, or only the narrower ECL rule limited to illegal deer-taking?
The ECL rule controls. The AG concluded ECL § 71-0907(4)(f)(3) authorizes firearm seizure only for misdemeanors involving the illegal taking or attempted taking of wild deer; the broader Penal Law § 4…
Are New York volunteer attorneys who help pro se litigants in Housing Court eligible for State defense and indemnification under Public Officers Law § 17?
Yes. The AG concluded that the Office of Court Administration's Volunteer Lawyers Project is a 'state-sponsored volunteer program' within the meaning of Public Officers Law § 17, so participating volu…
Does a New York village need town consent to condemn property in another town for an electric utility project?
No. The AG concluded the Eminent Domain Procedure Law and General Municipal Law Article 14-A govern, not Village Law § 4-412(3)(1) (which requires town consent for floodwater drainage acquisitions). T…
Can a New York town pass a local law that regulates land excavation and charges applicants a fee to fund the inspection program?
Yes. The AG concluded a town may regulate excavation and reclamation under its home rule police power, and may charge fees that approximate the cost of the regulatory program. A fee that exceeds progr…
Does a New York town board of assessment review member have to recuse from voting on their own property's tax assessment?
Yes, as a matter of common-law obligation, the AG concluded. State law (Real Property Tax Law § 523) requires disclosure but does not require recusal, so a member cannot be disciplined under State law…
Can a volunteer firefighter from one New York company help fight fires in another company's territory where he lives or works?
Yes, on a recurring basis if structured under the statute. General Municipal Law § 209-i(1-a) allows a volunteer firefighter to offer his services to a different fire company in an area where he lives…
Can a New York town clerk also serve as a fire district commissioner for a fire district inside that town?
Yes. The AG concluded the two offices are compatible. A fire district is a separate political subdivision from the town, so neither office supervises the other. The oath-of-office filing requirement u…
Can a New York town supervisor also serve as the town librarian?
No. The AG concluded the offices are incompatible. The supervisor sits on the town board, which appoints the library board, which selects the librarian and sets the librarian's salary. The supervisor …
Can a New York county legislature appoint one of its own members to the county planning commission?
No. The AG concluded a governing body may not appoint one of its own members to another public position. The Schuyler County Legislature could not appoint a legislator to the County Planning Commissio…
Does a village justice lose his office if he temporarily moves outside the village while his new house is built?
No. The AG concluded a village justice may retain office during a temporary residence outside the village. Public Officers Law residency requirements use 'domicile' as the standard, and domicile depen…
Can a New York town adopt a local law that expands when alternate ZBA members can fill in for regulars, beyond what Town Law § 267(11) allows?
Yes. The AG concluded a town may supersede Town Law § 267(11), which only allows alternates when regular members have conflicts of interest. Under Municipal Home Rule Law § 10(1)(ii)(d)(3), the town c…
What political activity can a New York city police officer take part in: running for office, joining party caucuses, donating to campaigns?
Most yes, one no. A police officer may run for and hold the office of county legislator, sit in a county legislative caucus, attend party committee meetings, and make political donations. Police offic…
If a New York cemetery decides to provide all annual lot care services itself, does that void existing contracts between lot owners and outside landscapers?
No. The AG concluded the Annual Care Law applies only prospectively. Lot owners with existing third-party care contracts keep them, and current lot owners can still hire outside contractors. The exclu…
Can a town police officer also serve as a village trustee in a village within that town, when the police department is run by an intermunicipal board?
Yes. The AG concluded the positions are compatible. The Manlius police department is governed by a Police Committee with town and village representatives, but the village board itself has no direct su…
Can a New York village agree to defend and pay any judgment against outside lawyers it hired, even for punitive damages in a civil rights lawsuit?
Mostly no. The AG concluded the Village can defend and indemnify its own employees by adopting Public Officers Law § 18, but generally cannot extend that to independent contractors. The Village may al…
Can voters in a New York village or fire district force a referendum on whether the fire district contracts with the village for fire protection?
No. The AG concluded only the Legislature can authorize a local referendum, and Town Law § 176(22) (which lets fire commissioners contract for outside fire protection) is not subject to one. Petition …
Can a New York village stop providing water to customers who live outside the village limits?
Yes. Under Village Law § 11-1120, supplying water to outside customers is optional, and the village can terminate the arrangement on reasonable notice that gives customers time to arrange another sour…
Can the county officer who runs the county's workers' compensation self-insurance program also serve as supervisor of a town that participates in that program?
No. The AG concluded the two positions are incompatible. The Sullivan County Director of Risk Management decides workers' compensation claims for participating towns, including Liberty. Liberty's supe…
Browse New York opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in New York are written by the New York Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.