New York Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a NY village set a fixed term of office for a police chief whose position is in the competitive class of civil service?
No. The AG concluded that a municipality may not establish a term of office for any position in the competitive class of the civil service, including a police chief who serves as the executive head of…
Can a NY county enter a mutual aid agreement with a county in another state for fire and emergency services?
Yes. The AG concluded Cattaraugus County could enter a mutual aid agreement with Potter County, Pennsylvania, using General Municipal Law Article 14-G (interlocal agreements with public agencies of ot…
Can a NY town pass a 'pay to play' law banning contracts with people who donated to town officials?
No. The AG concluded that Southampton's proposed law (no town contracts over $1,500 to persons who had donated more than $100 to town officials or candidates) was both inconsistent with and preempted …
Can a NY county clerk accept a DBA certificate when the assumed name looks like a person's name, and can the clerk fix obvious filing errors?
Yes on both. The AG concluded a county clerk may accept a General Business Law § 130 assumed-name certificate at face value when it explains the secondary or historic meaning of the name, may not insi…
Does the NY tropical hardwood purchase ban cover every tropical species, or only the species the statute lists by name?
The AG concluded that State Finance Law § 165 prohibits the state and its agencies from purchasing only the roughly forty tropical-hardwood species listed by name in the statute. The general definitio…
Can a NY town agree to provide police protection only to a village inside the town and skip the rest of the town?
No. The AG concluded that if a town establishes a police department under Town Law § 150, it must serve the entire town including any village without its own police force. A town cannot lawfully provi…
Can the NY Commissioner of Agriculture send a deputy in his place to ex officio board meetings of a public benefit corporation?
Yes. The AG concluded that Agriculture and Markets Law § 17(a) and (c) authorizes the Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets to delegate his ex officio responsibilities on the board of directors of t…
Can a NY landowner pull their property out of the village if they get some but not all village services?
No. The AG concluded that Village Law § 18-1804 lets a property owner seek exclusion from the village only if the property receives none of the listed improvements (sidewalk, electric lights, sewers, …
Can a NY county legislator also serve on the county health department's review committees and as the farm bureau representative to the soil and water conservation district?
No. The AG concluded county legislative service is incompatible with sitting on the Utilization Review Committee or Professional Advisory Committee because those committees make professional evaluatio…
Does a NY village building inspector have to live in the village, or can the village let him live anywhere in the county?
The default is village residency, but the village can broaden it to the county. The AG concluded the Depew building inspector is a public officer (he enforces sovereign regulatory powers over housing,…
Can a NY town appoint harbor masters with peace officer powers to patrol an inland lake?
Yes, if the lake is 'navigable waters' under Navigation Law § 2(4). The AG concluded Criminal Procedure Law § 2.10(19) gives peace officer status to harbor masters appointed by counties, cities, towns…
Can a NY city's public bus system sell advertising space on the buses to generate revenue?
Yes. The AG concluded that a city operating a public bus system has authority to sell advertising space on the buses, especially when the city uses competitive bidding and applies the revenue to bus o…
Can a NY county and one of its officials sign a contract that gives the official a longer or shorter term than the county charter sets?
No. The AG concluded that when a county charter fixes the term of an office, neither the county nor the officeholder, individually or together, can establish a different term by agreement. Charter law…
Can a NY village mayor appoint one of the trustees to run the village police department as the single police commissioner?
Yes. The AG concluded that Village Law § 3-300(3) authorizes board members to serve as 'single commissioners' in charge of village departments, and § 3-301(3) lets the mayor make that designation. Vil…
Can a NY county legislator also hold a paid civil-service job in the county's social services department?
No. The AG concluded the two positions are incompatible. Even though the legislator is in a collective bargaining unit (so his immediate salary is fixed) and the social services commissioner runs day-…
Can a NY village board reappoint one of its own members as the village's building and bingo inspector?
No. The AG concluded the building inspector's actions (proposing permits and condemnation recommendations) are reviewed by the village board, so the offices are inevitably and recurrently conflicting;…
Can a NY county coroner also serve as a village trustee at the same time?
Yes. The AG concluded no statute bars the combination (County Law § 411 prohibits an elective county officer from holding another county or town elective office or a city supervisor seat, but pointedl…
Do NY state agencies and law enforcement employers have to follow the ban on asking job applicants about their workers' comp claim history?
Yes. The AG concluded that Workers' Compensation Law § 125 applies to state agencies and municipal law enforcement entities. The statute makes it unlawful for any employer to inquire into or consider,…
Can a NY teacher who supervises a college student teacher accept a tuition waiver or cash stipend from the college?
Yes. The AG concluded that General Municipal Law § 805-a does not bar a school district employee from accepting a tuition waiver or cash stipend from a college in return for supervising the college's …
How wide is a NY town road that became a highway just by public use over time?
The width of a town highway established by use under Highway Law § 189 is determined by the actual extent of public use, not the statute's three-rod default. The Court of Appeals in People v Sutherlan…
If the NY Employment Relations Board chairman takes an unpaid leave from his law firm partnership during his term, does he satisfy the 'devote his entire time' rule?
Yes. The AG concluded that a person appointed Chairman of the Employment Relations Board could take an unpaid leave of absence from the law firm of which he was a partner, without dissolving the partn…
Can the NY DEC run a no-purchase-necessary sweepstakes to boost subscriptions to The Conservationist magazine?
No. The AG concluded that the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation could not undertake a promotional sweepstakes (even one with no purchase required) to promote subscriptions to The…
When a NY district attorney resigns and someone is elected to fill the vacancy, does that person serve the full four-year term or just out the predecessor's unexpired term?
Full four-year term. The AG concluded that the person elected in November 1995 to fill the Rockland County DA vacancy serves for a full four-year term, not the balance of the predecessor's term. Const…
Can a teacher chaperoning a school trip accept a free trip or perks from the tour company?
Generally no. The AG concluded that when a school chaperone has discretion to choose the ski area or tour operator and receives free trips, lift tickets, or shop discounts from the chosen vendor, the …
Can a NY county pass a term limits law for elected officials without a public referendum?
Yes. The AG confirmed Informal Opinion No. 83-10 and the Court of Appeals' Roth v Cuevas decision: a county may use its home-rule authority to limit the number of consecutive terms an elected officer …
Can a NY police department post the results of internal discipline on a bulletin board that only officers can see?
Yes. The AG concluded that Civil Rights Law § 50-a was enacted to stop disclosure of officer personnel records to litigants who would use them to harass or impeach officers, not to bar internal depart…
In New York, can a village mayor fill a mid-term vacancy in an appointed office without board of trustees approval?
Yes. Under New York Village Law § 3-312(3), the mayor appoints to fill the unexpired term without board approval. When the term expires, the next appointment requires board confirmation under § 3-301(…
Can the NY Pilots Board suspend a Hudson River pilot's license for negligent acts he did while working as a docking master, not under his license?
Yes. The AG concluded that the Board of Commissioners of Pilots could proceed against the license of a State-licensed Hudson River pilot for actions taken while he was working as a docking master and …
Can a NY EMT install red lights and a siren on her personal car to respond to ambulance calls?
Yes, when properly equipped and operating as an agent of an ambulance service. The AG concluded the phrase 'owned or operated by' in Vehicle and Traffic Law § 115-c is disjunctive: a private vehicle i…
In a NY eviction, does the sheriff have to physically remove the tenant's furniture and possessions?
Yes, by default. The AG concluded that a sheriff executing a RPAPL § 749(1) warrant must effect the removal of the evicted person's personal property unless the petitioner-landlord relieves the sherif…
Does a fire district commissioner have a conflict if he's a paid firefighter in another city and belongs to the same national union as the firefighters he must negotiate with?
No. The AG concluded membership in the same national union, through different locals, creates only a remote and indirect incentive. Fire commissioners are unpaid volunteers; the commissioner had no co…
Can a NY county create a fire marshal position by resolution, or does it need a local law?
By local law, not by resolution. The AG concluded that home-rule authority allows a county to create the fire marshal position and define its duties through a local law (or charter law for a charter c…
Can a planning board member also work as a full-time computer services employee for the same town?
Yes. The AG concluded no statute prohibits the combination, and the two positions are compatible at common law: the computer services job is not subordinate to the planning board and the duties do not…
Can the same person serve as a New York village's code enforcement officer and also sit on the village planning board?
Yes. The two positions are compatible. They are not subordinate to one another, their duties do not conflict, and any case-specific conflicts can be handled by recusal.
Can a New York city keep a seven-member zoning board of appeals even after a state amendment said boards must have three or five members?
Yes. The AG concluded that General City Law § 81 (the ZBA-membership rule) excludes cities with populations over 1 million, so it is not a 'general law' under the home rule definition. A city may ther…
Does the NY Crime Victims Board waive its lien on later recoveries when it compromises a lien on an earlier one?
It depends. The AG concluded that the Crime Victims Board's compromise or settlement of a § 634(2) lien on a particular recovery may or may not waive the lien attaching to a later recovery or the Stat…
Can a Troy Housing Authority member move outside the city of Troy but stay on the board?
No. The AG concluded that members of the Troy Municipal Housing Authority are local public officers under Public Officers Law § 3 and must reside in the City of Troy at appointment and throughout thei…
In a NY city with a city-manager form of government, does the manager or the mayor appoint members of the city housing authority?
The city manager. The AG concluded that under Plan C of the Optional City Government Law (Watertown's plan), the city manager is the chief executive officer of the city. Public Housing Law § 30(2) giv…
Can a NY county refuse to enforce the building code on industrial development agency property while still enforcing it everywhere else?
No. The AG concluded that Executive Law § 381 and 19 NYCRR §§ 441.2 and 441.3 allow a county to opt out of code enforcement entirely (in which case the Secretary of State takes over), or to allocate e…
Do private industry council members in New York have to file annual financial disclosure forms with the county?
No, except for governmental representatives. The AG concluded that private industry council members are not officers or employees of the county. The council is a separate federal-law entity formed to …
Can a charter county design its own indigent defense plan instead of using one of the County Law options?
No. The AG concluded that even a charter county cannot use home rule to design an indigent defense plan that differs from the options in County Law § 722. The right to counsel is a matter of state con…
Can a town planning board member do paid soil-boring work that ends up in subdivision maps the board reviews?
No. The AG concluded that General Municipal Law § 805-a(1)(c) flatly prohibits a planning board member from being paid for services in a matter that will come before the board. Even at $100 per boring…
Can a NY city require its city council to confirm the mayor's appointments to the planning commission?
Yes. The AG concluded that mayoral appointment subject to city council confirmation does not conflict with General Municipal Law § 234 or General City Law § 27. When an executive appoints and the legi…
Can someone serve on the city council if they also work as a city firefighter?
No. The AG concluded the offices are incompatible. The city council controls the fire department's budget, including firefighters' salaries and benefits, so a council member who is also a firefighter …
Can a New York non-charter county create a county administrator position without a public vote?
Yes. The AG concluded that a non-charter county board of supervisors may use Municipal Home Rule Law § 10 to create the position by local law. As long as the local law does not abolish, transfer, or c…
Can the same person sit on both a town's zoning board of appeals and its board of assessment review?
Yes. No statute prohibits the combination, and the offices are compatible under the common-law Ryan v Green test: neither is subordinate to the other, and their duties (hearing zoning-enforcement appe…
Does changing how the mayor is chosen in a small commission-run city require voter approval?
Yes. The AG concluded the Sherrill charter amendment, which would transfer the power to serve as commission chair and mayor from the top vote-getting commissioner to the commissioner with the most sen…
Can a town assessor privately represent a property owner who also owns property in his own town?
No, not without resolving the overlap. The AG concluded the situation creates at least an appearance of impropriety because the public would reasonably question whether the assessor can value the clie…
Does a NY town have to pay for a town board member's defense in a defamation suit by the police chief?
Generally yes. The AG concluded that under Public Officers Law § 18, a town must provide a defense whenever the complaint itself alleges acts within the scope of employment. If the complaint does not,…
Can a New York town let appointed officials live anywhere in the state instead of inside the town?
Yes, by local law. The AG concluded that the Public Officers Law residency rule no longer applies uniformly to all towns (a Greenburgh-only exception made it a 'special' law), so a town may use its ho…
Do members of a town conservation board have to live in the town?
No, when the board is strictly advisory. The AG concluded that because the Town of Mendon's conservation board had no decision-making power and only made recommendations to the planning board, its mem…
Can a town stop plowing a road for the winter if one family living on it depends on it for access?
No. Highway Law § 205-a forbids designating a town road as a 'seasonal limited use highway' (which lets the town drop snow removal from December through March) if even one occupied residence or commer…
If a planning board member declares a conflict of interest, do they have to leave the room during deliberations?
Yes. The AG concluded that once a planning board member has declared a conflict of interest, recusal must mean physically absenting themselves from the board's proceedings on the matter, not just abst…
Can a New York county transfer jurisdiction of a bridge back to the town where it sits?
Yes. After amending the county road system map to include the bridge, the county may follow Highway Law §§ 115-b and 115-c to transfer it back to the town. The process requires a written agreement wit…
What does New York AG Opinion 2007-08 say about Ethics code may prohibit county officer from holding a political party office;Ethics code may prohibit county officer from holding a political party office?
A county is authorized to adopt an amendment to its code of ethics prohibiting its officers from simultaneously serving as county political party officers. Such amendment may be applied to county comm…
What does New York AG Opinion 2000-F4 say about Display of red or white flashing lights (CUNY)?
Vehicles owned by CUNY and operated by special patrolmen on its Security and Public Safety force are 'police vehicles' as defined in Vehicle and Traffic Law § 132-a. Therefore, these vehicles may disp…
Browse New York opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in New York are written by the New York Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.