New York Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a New York BOCES board member work as an occasional per diem substitute teacher in one of the school districts the BOCES serves?
No. Education Law § 1950(9) makes a BOCES member's role and any school-district employment in the same supervisory district incompatible. The statute prohibits not only electing a current district emp…
Does a New York village trustee who owns property in a Business Improvement District have a conflict of interest that requires recusal on the BID budget vote?
It depends on the size of the trustee's stake. The AG laid out a Tuxedo-Parker framework: if the trustee's interest in the BID budget outcome is substantial and direct (large property holding, a propo…
Can a New York village design review board include a practicing architect whose firm occasionally has projects before the board?
Yes. The architect did not have to resign as long as his firm's projects came before the board only rarely (about once a year). On those occasions he had to recuse entirely. If conflicts became freque…
If a developer sues a New York village board, do the board members automatically have to recuse from later applications by the same developer or a related entity?
No. Pending litigation does not automatically disqualify board members from hearing later applications by the plaintiff. The board must look at the specific facts, including personal liability exposur…
Can a town in New York appoint its tax certiorari defense attorney to serve as deputy supervisor?
No. The AG concluded the conflict was structural, not waivable. As deputy supervisor, the attorney would negotiate his own contract renewal with colleagues on the board and advise the town board on li…
Does a New York town board of assessment review member have to recuse from voting on their own property's tax assessment?
Yes, as a matter of common-law obligation, the AG concluded. State law (Real Property Tax Law § 523) requires disclosure but does not require recusal, so a member cannot be disciplined under State law…
Does a village clerk-treasurer have a conflict of interest when his own tenant applies for federal rent assistance through a village-administered HUD program?
No, when a county agency, not the village itself, decides eligibility and pays the subsidy. The AG found no Article 18 conflict because the village clerk-treasurer had no role in selecting applicants,…
Can a village put a part-time police officer's towing business on the official rotation list the police use to call towers?
Yes, if the village uses an automatic rotation system and takes steps to keep the officer from being involved in calls that benefit his own business. The AG warned that the officer's own business shou…
Should a village mayor and trustee who also serve as joint fire district treasurer and volunteer firefighters recuse from voting on the sale of village property to the fire district?
Probably yes. The AG concluded that if the mayor and trustee have divided interests that could affect their impartiality or create an appearance of impropriety, they should not participate in delibera…
Can a town highway superintendent privately moonlight for the town's water district, operating heavy equipment to repair water pipes located under town roads?
No. The AG concluded that a town highway superintendent's operation of heavy equipment for the town water district to repair water pipes under a road, whether in his official or private capacity, crea…
Does a village attorney have a conflict of interest if they also represent a private client in a matter pending before a town planning board on which the village's mayor sits?
No. The AG concluded the village attorney did not have a disqualifying conflict, because the mayor's role on the town planning board is independent of the village attorney's representation of private …
Can a New York town's deputy building inspector inspect the building inspector's own home and issue permits, given that the deputy reports to the inspector?
Yes, under the rule of necessity. The AG concluded the deputy may inspect and issue any required permits because the deputy and the inspector were the only individuals authorized to do so. Ideally a d…
Can a New York village trustee also be vice president of an incorporated fire department fundraising entity and a volunteer firefighter, and vote on the fire department budget?
Yes, with one recusal. A New York village trustee can also serve as a volunteer member of the village volunteer fire department and as vice president of a separately incorporated fire department fundr…
If a New York town supervisor has a son in the town police department, can she vote on the police contract or the police budget?
Partly. A New York town supervisor whose son is a sergeant in the town police department must recuse from actions affecting the terms and conditions of her son's employment, including negotiations on …
If a county supervisor in New York is suing his own county, does he have to step aside from all budget votes?
No, not from all budget votes. A New York county board of supervisors member who has filed a lawsuit against the county and one of its officials must recuse from votes on that lawsuit and similar liti…
Can a teacher chaperoning a school trip accept a free trip or perks from the tour company?
Generally no. The AG concluded that when a school chaperone has discretion to choose the ski area or tour operator and receives free trips, lift tickets, or shop discounts from the chosen vendor, the …
Does a fire district commissioner have a conflict if he's a paid firefighter in another city and belongs to the same national union as the firefighters he must negotiate with?
No. The AG concluded membership in the same national union, through different locals, creates only a remote and indirect incentive. Fire commissioners are unpaid volunteers; the commissioner had no co…
Can a town planning board member do paid soil-boring work that ends up in subdivision maps the board reviews?
No. The AG concluded that General Municipal Law § 805-a(1)(c) flatly prohibits a planning board member from being paid for services in a matter that will come before the board. Even at $100 per boring…
Can someone serve on the city council if they also work as a city firefighter?
No. The AG concluded the offices are incompatible. The city council controls the fire department's budget, including firefighters' salaries and benefits, so a council member who is also a firefighter …
Can a town assessor privately represent a property owner who also owns property in his own town?
No, not without resolving the overlap. The AG concluded the situation creates at least an appearance of impropriety because the public would reasonably question whether the assessor can value the clie…
If a planning board member declares a conflict of interest, do they have to leave the room during deliberations?
Yes. The AG concluded that once a planning board member has declared a conflict of interest, recusal must mean physically absenting themselves from the board's proceedings on the matter, not just abst…
Browse New York opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in New York are written by the New York Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.