New York State Tax Rulings
Free plain-English summaries of state tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued in New York, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No New York rulings match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Does an out-of-state company owe New York corporate franchise tax just because its employees taught four five-day training courses in New York, even though another state's tax rules would attribute the income to that other state instead?
Yes. Sending employees into New York to teach paid courses is sufficient presence to constitute "doing business" in New York and triggers Article 9-A franchise tax, regardless of whether another state…
Does producing office furniture — cutting and welding steel parts, powder-coat painting, and upholstering chairs and panels — count as "manufacturing" for New York's investment tax credit and economic development zone tax credit?
Yes. Gathering raw materials and cutting, welding, painting, and upholstering them into finished office chairs and modular panels is "manufacturing" under the statutory definition, qualifying the acti…
A demolition and excavation contractor that also hauls debris and leases trucks/machinery wants to switch from filing as an Article 9 transportation corporation to Article 9-A — which of its many revenue streams count toward the 50%-of-receipts "principally engaged" test, and can the Department just decide the classification in an advisory opinion?
Carting/hauling of others' debris and soil is Article 9 transportation revenue; hauling the company's own property is neither Article 9 nor Article 9-A revenue; material sales, disposal service, machi…
If a business believed for 11 years that it was a validly incorporated New York corporation — filing corporate tax returns and paying corporate taxes the whole time — but later discovers the incorporation paperwork was never actually completed, was it a corporation subject to franchise tax all along?
Yes. Because the organization held itself out as a corporation and conducted business as one since 1977 — filing corporate returns and paying corporate taxes — it is treated as a corporation subject t…
A small company provides both a telephone answering service and a telex/fax relay service — does owning no transmission equipment of its own keep it out of New York's Article 9 telegraph/telephone tax, or does the telex/fax activity still count as a taxable transmission business?
A telex/fax service is taxable under Article 9 as a telegraph/telephone business regardless of whether the company owns any transmission equipment or lines, while a telephone answering service is an A…
When a securities broker-dealer invests customer funds in repurchase agreements (repos) with banks, is that investment "investment capital" under New York's franchise tax, or something else — and does it matter whether the repo is really a purchase of securities versus a secured loan?
It depends on whether the repo is, in substance, a purchase of the underlying government securities (in which case it can be investment capital if it meets the other statutory requirements) or in subs…
When a manufacturer computes whether a building is 'principally used' more than 50% for production and storage (to qualify for the investment tax credit), does unfinished, unused excess-capacity floor space count in the calculation?
Yes. Unfinished excess-capacity space that can only support storage must be included in the denominator of the usable-business-floor-space fraction (total floor space, excluding only bathrooms/cafeter…
Does New York's new 1989 corporate-acquisitions tax (the "M&A Act") apply to the Kohlberg Kravis Roberts leveraged buyout of RJR Nabisco, which closed just before the law took effect, or to the internal merger and any later restructuring that followed?
No. Because the M&A Act took effect April 19, 1989 and RJR Acquisition Corporation's purchase of 74.3% of RJR Nabisco's stock closed February 9, 1989 — before the effective date — that acquisition fal…
Is a foreign nonprofit agricultural cooperative, authorized to do business in New York under the Not-For-Profit Corporation Law, automatically exempt from New York corporate franchise tax?
Not automatically. Being a nonprofit cooperative or being authorized under the Not-For-Profit Corporation Law doesn't by itself exempt a cooperative from Article 9-A tax — but if the cooperative actua…
If a U.S. company's export-sales subsidiary is a Foreign Sales Corporation (FSC) that properly uses the IRS's safe-harbor administrative pricing rules to set its commissions, does that automatically mean New York can't require a combined franchise tax report between the parent and the FSC?
No. Using the IRC's administrative pricing safe harbor for FSC commissions doesn't by itself prevent the Commissioner from requiring a combined report — the administrative pricing rules only cover the…
If a beverage distributor gets IRS approval to switch its accounting method for container-deposit income (from a reserve method to the cash method required by Rev. Rul. 78-273), must it use that same new method for New York franchise tax purposes?
Yes. New York's Article 9-A entire net income must always be computed using the same accounting method approved for federal income tax purposes — so once the IRS approves the switch to the cash method…
A mail-order company distributes catalogs through an airline's on-board program (paying the airline a sales commission) and ships merchandise to New York customers who order from those catalogs — does the company owe New York franchise tax, and does it have to collect New York sales tax?
The company is exempt from Article 9-A franchise tax under federal Public Law 86-272 because its only New York activity is order solicitation followed by shipment from outside the state. But it must s…
Does a corporate insurance general agency owe New York franchise tax merely because it's licensed by the New York Insurance Department, licenses independent agents in New York, reviews insurance applications from New York residents, or has its issuing insurers accept and sell policies in New York?
No. None of those activities — insurance licensing, licensing/appointing independent agents in New York, reviewing applications generated by those agents outside New York, or the issuing insurer selli…
When a mortgage banking company packages New York mortgage loans into FNMA/GNMA certificates and sells them, how much of its origination fees, servicing fees, sale gains, and interest income counts as New York business receipts for the corporate franchise tax?
Only the gain -- not the full sale price -- on FNMA and GNMA certificate sales counts as a business receipt, and it (along with origination fees, servicing fees, and interest) is New York-sourced only…
If a New York corporation dissolves but keeps holding title to real property purely as a nominee for other people's benefit, does it still owe corporation franchise tax and stay subject to a franchise-tax lien?
No -- a dissolved corporation that does nothing but hold record title to real property as nominee for the beneficial owners, with no business activity of its own, is not "conducting business" under se…
Does an out-of-state shell corporation that only holds title to New York land, as a nominee to hide the real buyers' identity from neighbors, owe New York corporate franchise tax?
Yes, but only for the years it existed while holding title -- an inactive foreign corporation that is a New York record title holder for others' benefit is doing business under section 209.1 and Regul…
If a corporation's only shareholders personally own the building it leases and pay for improvements to it, can either the corporation or the shareholders claim New York's economic development zone investment tax credit for those improvements?
No -- the credit is denied to both sides: the tenant corporation didn't purchase the property (its shareholders did, as separate legal owners), and the shareholder-landlords, though they did purchase …
If a company spins off a manufacturing division (including its New York plant) into a new wholly-owned subsidiary tax-free under IRC section 351, does it have to pay back the New York investment tax credit it already claimed on that plant?
No recapture is required -- because the spin-off qualifies as a tax-free reorganization under IRC section 351 and meets the federal mere-change-in-form conditions (same trade or business, transferor r…
Does a foreign corporation that isn't otherwise subject to New York franchise tax become taxable merely because it privately purchased a limited partnership interest in a partnership that does business in New York?
No -- the Department abandoned a 1954 Attorney General opinion that had treated limited partners as automatically doing business wherever their partnership does, and held that a genuinely passive fore…
Does a New Jersey corporation holding a small (6-8%), non-controlling limited partnership interest in a New York investment fund become subject to New York franchise tax just because the fund does business here?
No -- following the same reasoning as its companion opinion issued the same day (TSB-A-88(11)C), the Department held that a foreign corporation's passive, non-controlling limited partnership interest …
Is an unincorporated cattle-breeders' club that runs a commission cattle auction, but issues no stock or ownership certificates, subject to New York's corporate franchise tax?
No -- because the club is an unincorporated association that issues no stock, certificates, or other written instruments evidencing ownership interests, it doesn't meet the regulatory definition of a …
When an insurance holding company's Subpart F income is deemed a dividend, is the 50% of that deemed dividend included in New York entire net income treated as investment income (from investment capital) or as business income?
It depends on direct ownership: the taxable 50% of a Subpart F deemed dividend is investment income only to the extent the taxpayer has a direct investment (not exceeding 50% ownership) in the stock o…
Are participating loans a real-estate lender made to out-of-state partnerships 'investment capital' (favorably allocated) or 'business capital,' and does a tax-free reorganization change how the resulting interest income is sourced to New York?
The loans are business capital, not investment capital -- because investment capital is limited to securities issued by corporations or governments, and a loan to a partnership doesn't qualify -- so t…
As a general matter (not tied to one company's specific facts), does a foreign corporation become subject to New York's corporate franchise tax merely by becoming a limited partner in a limited partnership that does business in New York?
No -- addressing this as a general hypothetical rather than one company's specific facts, the Department held that a foreign corporation which is otherwise not subject to Article 9-A does not become d…
Does an in-store 'eye examination unit' used by a retail optical chain to test customers' vision before filling eyeglass prescriptions qualify for New York's investment tax credit as manufacturing/processing equipment?
No -- the investment tax credit requires property principally used in manufacturing or processing (a substantial or significant change to the shape, form, or nature of tangible personal property), and…
Under three different levels of New York contact -- no NY presence at all, an agency-like arrangement with an unrelated NY bank, and an actual NY office -- when does a mortgage banking company that packages and sells loans as FNMA/GNMA certificates become subject to New York corporate franchise tax, and how is its income sourced?
Under Alternative #1 (no NY office, no NY-originated loans, only a New York bank delivering certificates and collecting payment as agent) there is NO New York nexus; under Alternative #2 (using an unr…
Must a corporation add back 90% of the interest it pays on a loan from a 'nephew' corporation -- a second-tier subsidiary of its ultimate parent, not a direct shareholder or a shareholder's own subsidiary -- when computing New York entire net income?
No -- section 208.9(b)(5)'s 90% interest addback only reaches interest paid to a shareholder owning more than 5% of the taxpayer's stock, or to a subsidiary of such a shareholder; a 'nephew' corporati…
Is a nuclear plant decommissioning trust fund subject to New York's corporate franchise tax or personal income tax, and can the Department rule on New York City's General Corporation Tax?
No to both state taxes -- the trust isn't a stock-issuing 'corporation,' so Article 9-A doesn't apply, and because it has no federal taxable income (it would otherwise qualify as a grantor trust), it …
After a shell corporation acquires a target company's assets by merger and inherits its investment tax credit, can it claim the follow-on employment incentive tax credit using its own pre-merger employment level (zero employees) as the statutory baseline?
Yes -- the successor corporation qualifies for the employment incentive tax credit for the two years after the merger, because its own employment level in those years exceeded 101% of its own (pre-mer…
Is a homeowners association that maintains a private beach for its members subject to New York's corporate franchise tax, even if it elects federal homeowners-association tax treatment under IRC § 528?
Yes -- maintaining the beach for members' benefit is an 'inurement' of net earnings to members, so the association doesn't qualify for the not-for-profit exemption from Article 9-A, regardless of whet…
Does a recording studio that rents studio time and equipment to record-company producers qualify for New York's investment tax credit and sales tax manufacturing exemptions, or is it treated as a rental/service business?
No investment tax credit or employment incentive credit -- because more than half the actual mixing work is done by producers and engineers who aren't Sigma's own employees, Sigma is treated as rentin…
Does a record-mastering company -- which cuts master phonograph records and creates master tapes using its own employees -- qualify for New York's investment tax credit and sales tax production exemptions on its mastering equipment?
Yes -- because Frankford/Wayne's own employees (not outside producers) perform the actual mastering/manufacturing work, its mastering equipment, related environmental/gas systems, and mastering suppli…
Is a U.S. corporation's Subpart F income from its foreign subsidiaries treated as a 'dividend' for New York's Article 9-A and Article 33 franchise taxes, and if so, how much of it can be excluded from entire net income?
Yes -- Subpart F income is treated as a deemed dividend for both Article 9-A and Article 33 purposes, following the Department's own 1966 policy and analogous state-court rulings; if the taxpayer owns…
For New York's business allocation percentage property factor, does the exclusion for 'real property and related equipment' under construction reach only buildings and building-integrated equipment, or also separate personal property like standalone machinery being installed at the same time?
The exclusion is broader than the taxpayer argued -- it also reaches personal property under construction that is functionally tied to the real property construction, such as an assembly line built to…
Is a nonprofit patent-holding corporation exempt from New York's corporate franchise tax if it's a STOCK corporation whose only shareholder is a tax-exempt university?
No -- New York's not-for-profit corporate franchise tax exemption is available only to corporations that have NO stock or shares at all; because Cornell Research Foundation is a STOCK corporation (eve…
Does equipment used to design and develop computer hardware and software products qualify for New York's investment tax credit and research and development credit, and can an unprofitable startup get the investment credit refunded rather than carried forward?
Yes to both credits -- equipment used to design and develop computer software (following the federal treatment of software costs as research expenditures under Revenue Procedure 69-21) and computer ha…
If a taxpayer doesn't contest an erroneous notice of deficiency disallowing part of an investment tax credit, and that year later becomes a closed period under the statute of limitations, can the taxpayer still claim the full investment tax credit carryforward from that closed year when a later, open year is audited?
Yes -- even though the taxpayer can no longer directly contest the closed year's deficiency (both the 90-day protest window and the statute of limitations have run), the Tax Commission can still redet…
Is an out-of-state fuel distributor subject to New York's corporate franchise tax merely because its New York-based parent company keeps its books and provides a shared officer, when the subsidiary itself has no New York office or employees -- but does take title to petroleum within New York before shipping it out of state?
Having a parent-company officer maintain a New York office, and having the parent's own employees keep the subsidiary's books in New York, are NOT by themselves enough to create nexus -- but the subsi…
Does manufacturing equipment used to physically produce and reproduce computer hardware and software products (as opposed to just designing/developing them) qualify for New York's investment tax credit, and does a general-purpose office computer used for project management also qualify?
Yes for the manufacturing/reproduction equipment -- taking a blank tape or disk and imprinting a software program onto it, and manufacturing the physical hardware connector products, both constitute '…
For a printing company's New York receipts factor, should printed materials shipped in bulk to a customer's New York locations be sourced to New York even if the CUSTOMER isn't itself based in New York, and how should mailings to third-party consumers (not the direct customer) be sourced?
Yes -- receipts from books, magazines, and catalogs are sourced to New York whenever the printed goods are actually shipped (via common carrier, company truck, or mail) to a point in New York, regardl…
Does reincorporating from Delaware to New York State (without formally electing federal F-reorganization treatment) terminate a company's existing New York S corporation election?
It depends entirely on whether the federal S election survived the reincorporation -- if the change qualifies for tax-free federal F-reorganization treatment (per Revenue Ruling 64-250) and the FEDERA…
Can a corporate partner in a partnership claim its allocable share of the partnership's investment tax credit on production equipment the PARTNERSHIP purchased, even though the partnership has no Article 9-A tax liability of its own and a partner's interest is technically just intangible personal property rather than a direct share of partnership assets?
Yes -- even though a partnership has no Article 9-A tax liability to apply a credit against, and a partner's interest is technically intangible personalty rather than a direct share of partnership ass…
Does an out-of-state manufacturer that sells only through independent (non-employee) commissioned sales representatives lose the protection of federal P.L. 86-272 -- which shields mere order-solicitation from state income tax -- because it rented a New York showroom for those representatives' convenience for part of the year?
Yes -- P.L. 86-272 protects a company whose ONLY in-state activity is soliciting orders that are approved and filled from outside the state, but renting even a small showroom in New York (here, at the…
Can a corporation subtract from its New York entire net income the amount of stock it contributes to a federal tax-credit employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), which isn't deductible for federal income tax purposes?
No -- New York's Article 9-A only allows a specific subtraction for wages disallowed under IRC § 280C (the targeted jobs credit provision), and the ESOP stock contribution here is disallowed under a D…
Does equipment used solely to install connecting pipeline linking a newly drilled gas well to the existing pipeline system qualify for New York's investment tax credit as equipment used in natural gas 'extraction'?
No -- installing pipeline to connect a newly drilled well to an existing pipeline system is a transportation-related service, not part of the extraction operation itself, and since the pipeline isn't …
Can forward foreign-currency sale contracts, entered into purely to hedge currency-fluctuation risk on equity investments in foreign subsidiaries, themselves be counted as part of 'subsidiary capital' (investments in subsidiary stock) for New York franchise tax purposes?
No -- forward currency contracts, even when purchased specifically and exclusively to protect the value of an existing stock investment in a foreign subsidiary, are not themselves 'investments in the …
If a subsidiary pays its parent corporation a 'management fee' that reimburses the parent's own officers' salaries and overhead, does the subsidiary have to count part of that fee as compensation to a 5%-plus stockholder when computing New York's entire-net-income-plus-compensation franchise tax -- even though the fee is technically paid to a corporation, not an individual?
Yes -- the portion of a management fee that a subsidiary pays to its parent (a 5%-plus stockholder) that exceeds genuine reimbursement of the parent's out-of-pocket expenses on the subsidiary's behalf…
When a film distributor licenses films to TV networks and also sells its right to collect future syndication payments to a bank, how should it source those two kinds of receipts to New York State in its franchise-tax receipts factor?
Whether a film distributor's network-licensing receipts source to New York depends on whether the distributor is acting as the film producer's AGENT (in which case its commissions are 'services perfor…
Which pieces of lab and manufacturing equipment used by a biotech diagnostics company qualify for New York's 10% research-and-development credit versus the 6% investment tax credit -- and can the same equipment ever qualify for both, or must the company pick one?
All of Petitioner's laboratory equipment used directly to perform, monitor, or store materials for its disease-diagnostic research (centrifuges, incubators, spectrophotometers, gene sequencers, freeze…
A Texas securities firm has no New York office, only floor brokers ('$2 brokers') executing orders on the NYSE/AMEX. How much of its commission income -- from unrelated firms' orders, and from its OWN customers' orders -- gets allocated to New York for franchise-tax purposes?
Commissions Petitioner's New York floor brokers earn executing OTHER (unrelated) firms' orders are 100% allocated to New York, since those are services performed entirely in New York by Petitioner's o…
Does a newly formed co-op corporation qualify for New York's reduced 0.04% franchise-tax capital rate for 'cooperative housing corporations,' if its units are currently zoned/certified for commercial use but the co-op plans to convert them to residential dwelling use?
New York's reduced capital-base rate for cooperative housing corporations under section 210.1(a)(2) applies automatically to any corporation that qualifies as a 'cooperative housing corporation' under…
Within a multi-tier corporate family, does New York's 90%-interest-add-back rule reach interest paid to a 'grandparent' corporation (a shareholder's own parent) or to a 'nephew' corporation (a sibling subsidiary's own subsidiary) -- or does it only reach interest paid to a DIRECT 5%-plus stockholder or that stockholder's OWN subsidiary?
No to both -- section 208.9(b)(5)'s 90% interest add-back only reaches interest paid to an entity that is itself a 5%-plus STOCKHOLDER of the paying corporation, or a SUBSIDIARY of such a stockholder.…
During a franchise-tax audit, is the Department required to actually consider evidence a company offers showing it was NOT 'principally engaged' in a transportation-type business (so it should be taxed under Article 9-A rather than Article 9's sections 183/184) -- or can auditors classify a company's tax status without weighing that evidence?
Yes -- whether a corporation is taxable under Article 9's sections 183/184 (transportation/transmission franchise tax) or under Article 9-A depends entirely on what activity the corporation is 'princi…
If a company builds an entire dedicated research-and-development building -- including labs, offices for researchers and managers, flexible 'shell space' for future expansion, and support/mechanical space -- does the WHOLE building qualify for New York's 10% research and development credit, or only the portions used directly for lab work?
Yes -- for a purpose-built facility genuinely dedicated to research and development, the ENTIRE building can qualify for the 10% research and development credit under section 210.18, not just the labo…
An out-of-state company leases trucks WITHOUT drivers and merely drives them through New York on the highways (paying highway use tax) -- does that make it a 'transportation business' subject to New York's Article 9 franchise tax on trucking companies, or could it instead owe Article 9-A tax if it also leases trucks TO New York customers?
No -- a company principally engaged in leasing trucks WITHOUT drivers (as opposed to leasing vehicles WITH drivers, which does count as a transportation business under prior case law) is NOT 'principa…
A non-stock, non-profit corporation exists solely to hold title to real property for a labor union local, and is federally exempt under IRC section 501(c)(2) as a title-holding company -- is it exempt from New York's Article 9-A corporate franchise tax?
Yes -- a non-stock corporation organized other than for profit, with no net earnings inuring to any officer, director, or member, that is exempt from federal income tax under IRC section 501(a) (here,…
A New York condominium association (organized under Real Property Law Article 9-B) doesn't issue stock certificates to unit owners, but earns income from garage/parking/laundry rentals, commercial space leases, and interest -- is it a 'corporation' required to file a New York Article 9-A franchise tax return, regardless of how it elects to file its federal return?
Yes -- even though the condominium association doesn't issue stock certificates, each unit owner's proportionate 'common interest' is itself evidenced by a written instrument (the deed/declaration) un…
A not-for-profit homeowners association elects federal 'homeowners association' tax treatment under IRC section 528 and its only income is member assessments (for maintaining roads and recreational facilities) plus bank interest -- is it exempt from New York's Article 9-A corporate franchise tax, or at least is its NY taxable income limited to just the interest income?
No to both questions -- the association is NOT exempt from Article 9-A, and its New York taxable income is NOT limited to just its interest income. Even though the association is a not-for-profit corp…
Do municipal industrial development bonds -- held by an investment company as its sole asset, generating interest income -- count as 'investment capital' (rather than ordinary business capital) for New York's Article 9-A franchise tax, and if a company didn't originally classify them that way on its return, can it go back and reclassify them later to claim a refund?
Yes to both questions -- (1) municipal industrial development bonds meet the regulatory definition of 'other securities' under 20 NYCRR 3-4.2(c) (issued by a governmental body, customarily sold on the…
A not-for-profit corporation that merely holds title to real property for an exempt labor union local -- but HAS issued stock to the union's trustees -- has no net earnings and wants its New York corporate tax capped at the flat $250 minimum. Does issuing stock disqualify it from the non-profit exemption, and can a company simply elect the $250 minimum regardless of what the other computation methods produce?
No on both counts. Because Petitioner has issued STOCK (to the trustees of Local 1049 I.B.E.W.), it does not fall within the 20 NYCRR 1-3.4(b)(6) exemption for non-STOCK, non-profit corporations, even…
Browse New York rulings by topic
These are official tax letter rulings and advisory opinions issued by New York's revenue authority in response to questions from specific taxpayers about how the tax law applies to their facts. A ruling is binding on the department only for the taxpayer who requested it and cannot be relied on by anyone else, but it is strong evidence of how the state reads the law. Every ruling above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original source.