New York State Bar Association Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the New York State Bar Association, with full citations and source links on every page.
No New York State Bar Association opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a state agency lawyer work on an enforcement action against a company the lawyer represented in private practice before joining the agency?
Only sometimes. The opinion concludes the agency lawyer has a conflict only if he would normally have acquired confidential information in the prior representation that is material to the enforcement …
Can a part-time county Department of Social Services attorney represent private clients in Family Court matters where DSS is involved?
Not where DSS has an interest or plays a meaningful role; that conflict is non-consentable. Where DSS is involved but has no real interest, the lawyer may proceed only after a Rule 1.7(b) analysis wit…
Can a part-time assistant public defender whose cousin and law partner is a part-time town judge appear in that town court or at arraignments transferred there?
He may not appear in the town court where his cousin/partner or the co-judge presides, but he may handle a defendant's arraignment in a centralized arraignment part (when neither presides) even if the…
Can a part-time town attorney with no prosecutorial duties represent criminal defendants at arraignment in a centralized arraignment part where a justice of his town sometimes presides?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a part-time town attorney who has no prosecutorial responsibilities may, as a part-time public defender, represent criminal defendants at arraignments in a county's cen…
Can a county public defender's office hire the county's former district attorney, and how are conflicts handled?
Yes. The opinion concludes a former DA may work as an assistant public defender in the same county but may not personally handle a matter in which he was personally and substantially involved as DA or…
Does a part-time county lawyer have a conflict of interest if his private practice requires him to subpoena a county department he does not represent?
No. The opinion concludes that separate county departments are treated as separate clients under Rule 1.7(a)(1), so subpoenaing a department the lawyer does not represent and that is separately counse…
Can an assistant public defender appear in a town court where a relative or law partner is the part-time judge, and is the disqualification imputed to the whole office?
The opinion concludes the judge's law-partner cousin cannot represent office clients in that town court, and the judge's son-in-law cannot appear there but may work outside court with party and judici…
Can a town attorney represent a private client on zoning matters before a neighboring town if the client also has property interests in the town the attorney serves?
Yes if there is no personal-interest conflict, or a consentable one with informed consent from both the town board and the client; a positional conflict alone does not bar it, but Rule 1.11(f)(2) forb…
Can a full-time assistant county attorney take private or assigned-counsel Family Court cases where the county is not a party?
Yes, with limits. The opinion concludes such a lawyer may take Family Court matters where the county is not a party if no Rule 1.7(a) conflict exists or, if a waivable conflict exists, both the county…
Can a part-time assistant county attorney whose office handles only civil work take assigned defense of state parole-violation cases?
Generally yes. The opinion concludes that there is no per se bar when the county attorney's office does no criminal prosecution, the lawyer appears before no county officials, and county law is not at…
Can a law firm pay a former lawyer their agreed share of fees on cases they worked on after that lawyer leaves to take public office?
Yes, subject to any governing law. The opinion concludes that paying a departed lawyer a fee share for work performed at the firm is a permitted separation-agreement payment under Rule 1.5(h), not a r…
Can an assistant county attorney moonlight as a paid consultant for the software vendor whose contract with the county the lawyer helped negotiate and implement?
Not unless law expressly allows it. The opinion concludes that Rule 1.11(d)(2) bars the lawyer from negotiating private employment with a vendor party to a matter the lawyer handles, and the arrangeme…
When a county defunds its public defender's office, can the office hand its open and closed client files to the county's assigned counsel program?
No, not without client consent. The opinion concludes that the assigned counsel program is not a lawyer or law firm, so the office may deliver open files only to the client or successor counsel and mu…
Can a public defender appear before a part-time town justice who also works full-time in the county attorney's office that advises the public defender?
Maybe. The opinion concludes the two offices are not a single law firm on these facts, so Rule 8.4(f) does not bar the appearance, but the public defender may have a Rule 1.7(a)(2) personal conflict i…
Can a government lawyer apply for and negotiate a private-sector job with a company that is an adverse party in a matter the lawyer is currently handling for the agency?
No. The opinion concludes that a lawyer currently serving as a government employee may not negotiate for private employment with a party the lawyer is personally and substantially handling a matter ag…
How must a former government lawyer respond to a subpoena or court order seeking confidential information from a matter they handled in government service?
The opinion concludes a former government lawyer may disclose a former client's confidential information when reasonably believed necessary to comply with a court order, but must first consult the for…
When a municipal corporation counsel learns that municipal employees may have misappropriated public funds, what must the lawyer do, and does having represented those employees in their official capacity change the answer?
The opinion concludes that corporation counsel's client is the municipality alone, so the lawyer should report credible allegations of serious employee wrongdoing up to the highest municipal authority…
Can a New York lawyer who also works as a village police officer represent defendants in traffic court, in the county where the officer serves or in other counties?
No in the same county. The opinion concludes the officer may not represent traffic court defendants in the county where the village police department sits, because that Rule 1.7(a)(2) conflict is not …
Can a part-time village attorney defend private clients on traffic and criminal charges in the same town court where fines from village offenses are shared with the village?
Yes, if the village attorney does not represent the village in those courts and the financial overlap is managed. The opinion holds the fine-sharing formula can create a Rule 1.7 differing-interests r…
Can a lawyer keep a private practice while serving as town supervisor, and represent private clients located in or appearing before the town?
Yes, subject to other law, but the opinion holds the lawyer may not represent any private client in a matter involving the town, may not act officially on matters handled privately, may not negotiate …
Can a government lawyer look for outside work, and later take a job, advocating to change the very laws the lawyer helped administer?
Generally yes. The Rules do not bar a government lawyer from organizing or later joining a law-reform project, subject to protecting confidential information, avoiding personal conflicts under Rule 1.…
Can a county attorney also sit on, and chair, the board of a county-sponsored community college that the county attorney's office represents?
If no law bars the dual roles, the lawyer may serve only after assessing, each time the county's and college's interests overlap, whether the board role creates a significant Rule 1.7 risk; a disquali…
Can a government lawyer who pays union dues as an agency-shop member prosecute discipline cases against employees that union represents?
Yes, unless in a given matter a reasonable lawyer would find a significant risk that agency-shop status would impair the lawyer's judgment for the agency. If such a risk exists, the lawyer may still a…
Can a former county social-services lawyer go into private practice and oppose that same agency, including in support-enforcement cases?
Yes, unless the lawyer was personally and substantially involved in, or holds confidential information about, the same specific matter while in government service. Rule 1.11(a)'s narrow same-matter te…
Can a lawyer represent a private applicant before a town planning board when partners in the same firm serve as the town's attorney?
No. This is a nonconsentable concurrent conflict. When firm lawyers serve as Town Attorney and Deputy Town Attorney advising the planning and zoning boards, no lawyer in the firm may represent an appl…
Does a government agency lawyer satisfy the duty to report another agency lawyer's misconduct by reporting it to the agency's internal ethics office?
Reporting to the internal ethics office is consistent with Rule 8.3, but it does not by itself discharge the duty unless that office is a tribunal or an authority empowered to investigate or act. The …
Can a lawyer in the firm where the newly elected district attorney was once a partner represent criminal defendants the DA's office is prosecuting?
Yes, if the district attorney has fully severed ties with the firm and a reasonable lawyer would not find a significant risk that the prior relationship will adversely affect the lawyer's judgment. If…
Can a public defender appear in the court where another member of the same public defender office serves as a part-time judge?
No. Members of a public defender office are generally one firm, and the part-time judge's own judicial-conduct rules bar the judge from letting office colleagues practice in the judge's court. Under R…
If a firm partner is a part-time public defender, can another lawyer in that firm take assigned cases the public defender's office is conflicted out of?
Not without informed written consent. A part-time public defender's conflicts run to the whole PD office and then are imputed across his private firm, so other firm lawyers are disqualified from cases…
Can a lawyer talk directly to a represented public official who asks for direct contact, without the government lawyer's consent?
No. The opinion concludes that once the municipality's counsel has appeared, the no-contact rule (Rule 4.2(a)) bars the lawyer from communicating with the assessor (an adverse party who can bind the m…
Can a part-time county Department of Social Services lawyer also take assigned-counsel criminal and Family Court cases?
Sometimes. The opinion applies a facts-and-circumstances test: the lawyer may accept criminal or Family Court assignments only where the Department, and the law-enforcement officials the lawyer works …
Can a criminal defense lawyer serve on a District Attorney's conviction integrity committee and still represent criminal defendants?
Yes. The opinion concludes that reviewing wrongful-conviction claims is not a prosecutorial function, and an unpaid volunteer reviewer who is not controlled by and shares no general case access with t…
Can a lawyer who works for a police-misconduct review board engage in partisan political activity?
No. The opinion concludes that an attorney for a municipal agency that investigates police misconduct, with subpoena power and authority to refer misconduct for administrative prosecution or criminal …
Can a part-time town prosecutor's firm sue a neighboring village over its zoning or planning board's actions?
Yes, under stated conditions. The opinion concludes the firm may bring an Article 78 proceeding against the Village's zoning or planning board where the Town and Village are separate entities with sep…
Can an elected county clerk keep a private law practice, and what limits do the conduct rules place on it?
Yes, subject to any law governing the office. Under Rule 1.11(d) and (f), the clerk may not participate in any matter before the clerk's office in which the clerk was personally and substantially invo…
Can a city attorney buy property the city took in tax foreclosure and is reselling, and what conflict rules apply?
Yes, if the purchase complies with government-ethics law, the lawyer does not advise the city (or supervise those who do) on property sales, and the lawyer holds no confidential city information beari…
Can a government lawyer investigating a private lawyer for fraud interview that lawyer's clients without the private lawyer's consent under the no-contact rule?
The government lawyer is subject to Rule 4.2. Whether the clients may be interviewed without the private lawyer's consent depends on whether the investigation is a separate matter and, if so, whether …
Can government lawyers submit a position paper instead of appearing in person at routine immigration status hearings where nothing substantive will be addressed?
Yes, if both the court and the client consent. Government lawyers may submit a position paper in lieu of attending immigration status hearings at which no substantive or procedural issues will be addr…
Can a government agency lawyer work on matters involving litigation she earlier handled against the agency for a private client?
Not on the same matter. A lawyer who participated personally and substantially in the prior litigation may not advise the agency on that same matter (such as compliance with its settlement), and conse…
Is a county public defender's office a single firm for conflict imputation when its assistant public defenders work independently from separate private offices?
Yes. The opinion concludes a statutory public defender office is one firm under Rule 1.10(a), so one assistant's Rule 1.7, 1.8, or 1.9 conflict is imputed to the others, including part-timers acting a…
Can a government lawyer challenge his own furlough and also defend the agency against other employees' furlough appeals?
The lawyer may file his own furlough appeal if it does not impermissibly affect representing the agency, but if he files it he generally cannot also defend the agency against similar appeals. If he do…
Can a lawyer who works as a town court clerk represent a private client who has a matter pending in the clerk's own court?
Yes, subject to limits. No ethics rule categorically bars it. If the clerk has no role or only ministerial duties in the client's matter before the clerk's court, the clerk may represent the client el…
Can a town attorney who advised the building inspector then represent the zoning board of appeals in a related Article 78 case?
Yes, ordinarily. The opinion holds the town attorney represents the Town as an entity, so advising the building inspector and later appearing for the zoning board are both service to one client, not d…
Can a lawyer serve as attorney for a child when the lawyer's spouse, a public defender, represents another party in the case?
Yes, unless the circumstances create a Rule 1.7(a)(2) personal-interest or Rule 1.10(h) spousal conflict and the child has no representative who can consent to it. A child cannot consent to the confli…
Can a public defender or assistant public defender keep a separate private practice in the same Criminal Court where they appear for the office?
Yes. A public defender or assistant public defender may represent private clients in a separate practice in the same Criminal Court where they appear in their public capacity, provided conflict-of-int…
Can a criminal defense lawyer keep representing a client when her law partner is in business with a part-time assistant DA in the prosecuting office?
Yes, on these facts. The opinion treats the partner's business relationship as a personal-interest conflict imputed to the firm under Rule 1.10(a), finds no significant risk to the partner's judgment …
When a lawyer serves on a town board that controls the town court's budget, can other lawyers in the firm still appear in that court?
Generally yes. A board member's bar on appearing in the town Justice Court is not automatically imputed to the rest of the firm, except where the facts make public suspicion of undue influence likely …
Can an Assistant County Attorney serve as a mediator in a case where another lawyer from the same office represents the agency, and what conflicts arise?
Yes, with disclosure. An ACA may mediate a Child Permanency Mediation in which another ACA represents the county DSS, but must disclose his office connection; the ACA representing DSS has a personal c…
Can a full-time prosecutor accept appointment to a court referee panel and oversee foreclosure proceedings?
Yes. No per se rule bars a full-time Assistant District Attorney from serving as a foreclosure referee, but Rule 1.7(a)(2) conflicts must be avoided case by case, and Rule 1.12 restrictions may apply …
Can a lawyer who defends criminal cases in town court also take a part-time job prosecuting traffic offenses in the same county?
No. A lawyer who prosecutes traffic and other offenses for a locality represents the people of the state, which is inherently incompatible with defending criminal cases anywhere in New York. The resul…
Can a part-time assistant public defender take an assigned-counsel case that another lawyer in the same public defender office is conflicted out of?
No, not without a valid waiver. A public defender office is a 'firm,' so one assistant public defender's Rule 1.7 or 1.9 conflict is imputed to every lawyer in the office, including part-timers in a d…
Can a part-time government social services lawyer defend, in private practice, a client the agency is prosecuting for child neglect?
No. A part-time Social Services lawyer who prosecutes neglect cases cannot also defend that client in an unrelated criminal matter; the role conflict is non-consentable and is imputed to the whole leg…
Can a part-time county legislator accept Family Court appointments as attorney for the child when the legislature funds the county attorney and social services offices?
No. The opinion concludes that a county legislator may not accept Family Court appointments as attorney for the child in delinquency, PINS, neglect, or abuse cases, because of the legislator's budget …
Is an administrative agency's rule-making or rate-making proceeding a 'tribunal' under the ethics rules, and does Rule 3.5 bar ex parte communications in it?
It is a question of fact: the agency is a 'tribunal' only when a neutral official renders a judgment directly affecting specific parties. Even then, Rule 3.5's ex parte restrictions apply only if the …
Are a state agency's staff attorneys responsible for a non-lawyer investigator's contact with a represented licensee when the investigators are not supervised by the lawyers?
No, not on these facts. The committee concludes a non-lawyer investigator's conduct is not imputed to agency staff attorneys unless the lawyers have supervisory authority over the investigators; absen…
Can a prosecutor tell someone that criminal charges will be deferred if they settle a civil claim, like repaying alleged welfare overpayments?
Only with probable cause. The committee concludes a prosecutor may propose a civil resolution as an alternative to prosecution only if, after due investigation, the prosecutor has formed an opinion th…
Can a developer's lawyer talk privately with individual town planning board members about a pending application when the board's counsel objects?
Only within narrow limits. The committee concludes the no-contact rule permits such communications about pending determinations only if they concern policy issues alone and the lawyer gives the board'…
Can a county public defender review the billing vouchers of assigned counsel who took over a case because the public defender had a conflict of interest?
No, ordinarily. The committee concludes that a public defender's office barred by a conflict from representing a party is equally barred from reviewing the billing vouchers of the assigned conflict co…
When can a lawyer who works as a contract attorney for a county agency represent in private practice a client the lawyer encountered through that government work?
Only in limited circumstances. The committee concludes the lawyer may not privately represent the client in a matter the lawyer handled as a government attorney while the client remains eligible for t…
If lawyers in a small legal services corporation also keep private practices, can one of them privately represent a party opposing someone the corporation represents in the same case?
No. The committee treats the staff of a small legal services corporation as a law firm, so a conflict that would disqualify one lawyer is imputed to all, and consent cannot cure two same-'firm' lawyer…
Browse New York State Bar Association opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the New York State Bar Association interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.