New York State Bar Association Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the New York State Bar Association, with full citations and source links on every page.
No New York State Bar Association opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a lawyer who earns a broker's commission in a real estate deal also act as the buyers' attorney, even if the legal work is pro bono and the buyers are long-time clients and friends?
No. A lawyer who takes a commission as broker in a real estate transaction may not also serve as a lawyer to a party in that transaction. The conflict is per se nonconsentable, and offering the legal …
Can an immigration firm work with a nonlawyer foreign migration agent who refers clients and handles communication and translation, charge the client for those nonlegal services, and what must be disclosed?
Yes, if the relationship is not exclusive, the agent does not interfere with the lawyer-client relationship, the client consents to the referral conflict, and the lawyer pays nothing for referrals. Th…
Can a public defender appear in the court where another member of the same public defender office serves as a part-time judge?
No. Members of a public defender office are generally one firm, and the part-time judge's own judicial-conduct rules bar the judge from letting office colleagues practice in the judge's court. Under R…
Can a law firm use electronic or digitized signatures, instead of wet-ink signatures, on checks drawn from its attorney trust or IOLA account, and process them in batches?
Yes. Rule 1.15(e) requires only that an authorized signatory be a New York-admitted lawyer; it does not require a handwritten signature. A firm may use digitized signatures and batch processing as lon…
Can a lawyer use a nonlawyer-owned online service to find and hire per diem lawyers for court appearances, and does the client have to consent?
Yes. A lawyer may use or list in a nonlawyer-owned online per diem directory if the service does not recommend or select the lawyers, is open only to lawyers, and charges a flat fee. Client consent is…
Can a law firm's retainer agreement give the firm 20 days to be paid and then automatically charge the client's credit card for the full unpaid balance?
Yes, a retainer may secure fees by credit card and auto-charge amounts unpaid after 20 days, but only if it expressly tells the client of the right to dispute any invoice and seek fee arbitration befo…
Is a lawyer ethically required to accept every prospective client, and can refusing a case ever be unlawful discrimination?
No, a lawyer is generally free to decline any prospective client, but that freedom is limited by anti-discrimination law: Rule 8.4(g) bars unlawful discrimination in the practice of law. Whether a par…
Can a lawyer host educational seminars and webinars for non-lawyers, publicize them, and discuss representation with attendees afterward?
Yes. The opinion concludes a lawyer may organize and present such programs and follow up about representation, subject to the advertising and solicitation rules: a hiring pitch can turn the program in…
Can a lawyer pay a client's settlement funds on a fully-loaded pre-paid debit card instead of by check?
Yes. A lawyer may give the client that option and use a pre-paid debit card to pay funds the client is owed, provided the lawyer adequately discloses the relative merits and costs of the payment metho…
Can a lawyer refer clients to a third-party lender to finance the lawyer's fees, when the lawyer pays the lender and gets loan-status updates?
Yes, if the lawyer obtains informed consent and complies with Rule 1.8(f), and the fees the lawyer pays the lender do not amount to financial assistance to the client under Rule 1.8(e). The lawyer sho…
Can a private New York law firm call itself 'Jane Doe Legal Services, PLLC'?
No. The opinion concludes that 'legal services' is too 'like' the terms reserved for qualified legal assistance organizations under Rule 7.5(b), and the legal-clinic safe harbor does not extend to it,…
Can a criminal defense lawyer advise a client about drug treatment and a court diversion program, and recommend it even if failing carries harsher penalties?
Yes. Under Rule 2.1 the lawyer may advise on non-legal considerations like treatment and must competently explain the risks and alternatives, but under Rule 1.2(a) must follow the client's decision; d…
If a firm partner is a part-time public defender, can another lawyer in that firm take assigned cases the public defender's office is conflicted out of?
Not without informed written consent. A part-time public defender's conflicts run to the whole PD office and then are imputed across his private firm, so other firm lawyers are disqualified from cases…
Can a lawyer secure unpaid legal fees by having the client sign a promissory note and a mortgage on the client's property?
Yes, but it is a business transaction under Rule 1.8(a): the terms must be fair and reasonable, fully disclosed in writing, the client must give informed written consent, and the client must be advise…
Can a lawyer represent a company against a competitor that is a former client, when the former client benefits if the new client loses?
Yes, if the new matter is not the same as or substantially related to the former representation. The opinion concludes that purely economic competition does not make a former client's interests 'mater…
What ethics rules govern the office of an insurance company's in-house legal department that defends the company's policyholders?
The in-house lawyers must protect the insureds' confidential information, avoid conflicts, and comply with the other Rules. That means physically and electronically separating the department's work an…
Can a New York lawyer who is also a real estate broker link from the law firm website to a page about the brokerage?
Yes. A lawyer may link from the firm site to a real estate brokerage profile if both the site and the linked page comply with the advertising rules; the lawyer must also heed Rule 5.7 on ancillary non…
Can a New York lawyer use the 'Accredited Estate Planner' (AEP) designation on a website or business cards?
No. Because the National Association of Estate Planners & Councils' AEP program has not been approved by the ABA, the opinion concludes that putting 'Accredited Estate Planner' on a website or busines…
Must a New York lawyer report a judge's violation of the Rules of Judicial Conduct to the Commission on Judicial Conduct?
No. The opinion concludes a lawyer has no disciplinary duty to report a judge's violation of the Rules of Judicial Conduct, because Rule 8.3(a)'s reporting duty covers 'another lawyer,' not judges; th…
May a prosecutor make waiving ineffective-assistance-of-counsel claims a routine condition of a plea bargain?
No. The opinion concludes that routinely conditioning a plea bargain on a defendant's waiver of ineffective assistance of counsel claims is prejudicial to the administration of justice under Rule 8.4(…
If a lawyer works as a commercial debt collector, not as a lawyer, must they tell debtors they are an attorney?
No. The opinion concludes a lawyer hired only as a debt collector need not disclose their lawyer status, but if a debtor asks and the lawyer answers, the answer must be truthful and not misleading und…
Can a lawyer let a non-lawyer civil rights client keep some or all of the statutory attorney fees a court awarded to the client?
Yes. The opinion concludes that because statutory civil rights fees are awarded to the prevailing party (the client), not to the lawyer, letting the client keep some or all of them is not the kind of …
Can a lawyer admitted in both New York and the UK who runs a UK firm with non-lawyer owners also become a partner in a separate New York law firm?
Yes, conditionally. The opinion concludes the lawyer may join a separate New York firm without violating Rule 5.4 as long as the lawyer principally practices in the foreign jurisdiction (or the predom…
Does a lawyer have to tell the client when co-counsel on the same matter appears to have committed malpractice?
Yes. The opinion concludes that a lawyer must disclose to the client information the lawyer reasonably believes shows that co-counsel, still representing the client, committed a significant error or o…
When a law firm changes its name, must it immediately update all of its advertising, signs, and website domain to the new name?
No. The opinion concludes a firm that adds a partner's name has a reasonable time to update existing advertising, judged by whether the old ads are misleading and the cost and ease of changing them; w…
Can a lawyer give a client's file to the client's former lawyer so that lawyer can defend against the client's ethics complaint, when the client objects?
No, absent an exception. The opinion concludes the file is the client's confidential information, and nothing in the Rules permits or requires the lawyer to hand it to former counsel over the client's…
Must a New York lawyer report an out-of-state lawyer who appeared in New York courts without being admitted or authorized here?
Yes, if the lawyer actually knows of the violation. The opinion concludes Rule 8.3 reaches a non-New York lawyer who practices in New York without authorization, and such unauthorized appearance ordin…
Can a law firm bill a client for work done by an unpaid law-student intern who works for academic credit?
Yes. The opinion concludes a firm may bill for a student-intern's work even though the firm pays the intern nothing, as long as the internship complies with applicable law, the school does not object …
Can a lawyer who has taken retired status in New York still use 'Esq.' on business cards and letterhead for a non-legal business?
Yes. The opinion concludes a retired lawyer remains a lawyer and may use 'Esq.', but where there is a risk that clients or the public will be confused about the lawyer's role, the lawyer must indicate…
Can a New York lawyer give a prospective client the names of other clients the lawyer has represented as references?
Only with care. The opinion concludes a lawyer may name clients in advertising with their prior written consent, and absent consent may disclose a client's identity only if it is not confidential info…
Can a New York law firm charge a prospective client a fee for cancelling an initial consultation without notice, and does the policy have to be in writing?
Yes, within limits. The opinion concludes a lawyer may charge a nominal late-cancellation fee for an initial consultation if the lawyer discloses what triggers it and the charge either reflects the la…
Can a New York lawyer refer a client to an investment firm and accept a commission from that firm for managing the client's settlement money?
No. The opinion concludes that taking a fee or commission from an investment firm for referring a client whose funds came from the lawyer's representation creates a non-consentable conflict, because t…
When a law firm only knows an adverse party by a street name, does its conflict check have to go beyond its written engagement records?
It can. The opinion concludes that when a firm has reason to believe it may have represented a materially adverse party it knows only by street name, an effective conflict check may require consulting…
Can a defense lawyer reveal a deceased client's statement that might exonerate a co-defendant who is trying to vacate her plea?
Sometimes. The opinion concludes the statement is confidential information protected even after the client's death, but the lawyer may disclose it if the client gave informed consent (including a stan…
Can a firm that represents nursing homes form a nonprofit to serve as guardian for the homes' residents, and then represent that nonprofit?
It may form the nonprofit, but representing it can create conflicts. The opinion concludes property-guardianship work may be consentable depending on the facts, but if the matter involves the guardian…
Can an in-house lawyer at a nonlawyer-owned company provide legal services to the public through the company, and does ghost-writing the pleadings cure the problem?
No. The opinion concludes a lawyer may not provide legal services to individuals through a for-profit company in which a nonlawyer has an ownership or controlling interest, because it aids the company…
Can lawyers employed by a debt management company provide legal services to the company's customers?
No. If the company's services to customers are legal services, the opinion concludes the employed lawyers may be aiding a nonlawyer's unauthorized practice, sharing fees with a nonlawyer, ceding their…
Can a lawyer talk directly to a represented public official who asks for direct contact, without the government lawyer's consent?
No. The opinion concludes that once the municipality's counsel has appeared, the no-contact rule (Rule 4.2(a)) bars the lawyer from communicating with the assessor (an adverse party who can bind the m…
Can a lawyer bill clients for 'paralegal' time when the paralegal is not certified or program-trained?
Yes. The opinion concludes that because New York does not require paralegals to be certified, the title 'paralegal' does not imply certification, so it is not deceptive to use it for an uncertified le…
Can a lawyer tell a deceased former client's son that the lawyer never drafted a will for the father and has no original will?
Yes. The opinion concludes that the fact a lawyer did not draft a will and did not refer the client to other counsel is not 'confidential information' under Rule 1.6(a), and even if it were, disclosur…
Can a law firm scan signed retainer agreements and destroy the paper originals?
Yes. The opinion concludes that retainer agreements are records for which Rule 1.15(d) requires only 'copies,' so a firm may scan the signed originals into its computer system and destroy the paper, p…
Can a lawyer blind-copy a client on emails to opposing counsel after opposing counsel objects?
Yes. The opinion concludes that because a lawyer is the client's agent, bcc'ing the client on correspondence with opposing counsel is not deceptive under Rule 8.4(c), even over opposing counsel's obje…
Can a retired judge use a trade name for a business that helps lawyers prepare their court arguments?
No. The opinion concludes that advising lawyers on how to prepare specific arguments for court is the practice of law, so Rule 7.5(b)'s ban on trade names applies and the business may not operate unde…
Can a part-time county Department of Social Services lawyer also take assigned-counsel criminal and Family Court cases?
Sometimes. The opinion applies a facts-and-circumstances test: the lawyer may accept criminal or Family Court assignments only where the Department, and the law-enforcement officials the lawyer works …
Can a criminal defense lawyer serve on a District Attorney's conviction integrity committee and still represent criminal defendants?
Yes. The opinion concludes that reviewing wrongful-conviction claims is not a prosecutorial function, and an unpaid volunteer reviewer who is not controlled by and shares no general case access with t…
Can a New York lawyer form a partnership with a foreign patent professional such as a Japanese benrishi?
Only conditionally. The opinion concludes the New York lawyer must first independently confirm that the foreign professional's education is essentially equivalent to a New York lawyer's and that the f…
Can a lawyer who works for a police-misconduct review board engage in partisan political activity?
No. The opinion concludes that an attorney for a municipal agency that investigates police misconduct, with subpoena power and authority to refer misconduct for administrative prosecution or criminal …
In a joint representation, can a lawyer give one co-client the file and keep that request secret from the other co-clients?
It depends. The opinion concludes co-clients are presumed to share information and to have full file access, but where one co-client asks the lawyer to keep the file request secret from the others and…
Can a lawyer represent both an immigrant child in removal proceedings and the proposed guardian in the related Family Court guardianship case, and can the child consent to the conflict?
Yes, if the lawyer reasonably believes the lawyer can competently and diligently represent both and obtains each client's informed consent confirmed in writing. The child may consent if the lawyer bel…
Can a lawyer team up with a nonlawyer claims recovery firm that signs up clients, hires the lawyer to bring their antitrust claims, takes a one-third contingent commission, and pays the lawyer out of that commission?
Not on a systematic, continuing basis, because a claims recovery firm is not on the Appellate Division list of approved nonlegal professionals under Rule 5.8. Even a non-exclusive reciprocal referral …
What does a firm owe a prospective client who turns out to be the adversary of an existing client, and must it tell the existing client about the consultation?
The firm owes the prospective client confidentiality under Rule 1.18(b) for information learned in the consultation. Whether the consultation must be disclosed to the existing client, or bars continue…
Can a lawyer guarantee a bank loan that a client takes out to pay the lawyer's retainer?
No. The opinion concludes that Rule 1.8(e) bars a lawyer from advancing or guaranteeing financial assistance to a client in litigation, and none of the rule's three exceptions covers guaranteeing a lo…
Can a part-time town prosecutor's firm sue a neighboring village over its zoning or planning board's actions?
Yes, under stated conditions. The opinion concludes the firm may bring an Article 78 proceeding against the Village's zoning or planning board where the Town and Village are separate entities with sep…
Can a lawyer who used to be a Family Court judge later represent, in private practice, a party who appeared before them, and can the lawyer's firm take the case if the former judge is screened?
No. Under Rule 1.12(a) a former judge may not privately represent a client in a matter on the merits of which the judge acted, and that conflict cannot be waived even with everyone's consent. The conf…
If a lawyer's fee for representing a client was paid by the client's parent, can the lawyer later take a case against that parent?
Yes. A third party who pays a client's fee is not the lawyer's client just by paying. As long as the lawyer did not give the parent reason to believe he was a client, representing the other parent aga…
Can new lawyers raise start-up money for their law firm through online crowdfunding, and which crowdfunding models are allowed?
Some models, not others. Donation and reward crowdfunding are permissible, but equity and royalty models are barred because giving a funder an ownership interest or a share of revenue violates Rule 5.…
Can a lawyer report a client's bill-payment history to a credit-bureau-style database that other law firms can see?
Yes, but only with the client's informed, uncoerced consent. A client's payment status is confidential information, and the fee-collection exception does not cover this reporting, so the lawyer needs …
Can a law firm let a nonlawyer staff member open escrow sub-accounts and move money between them and the master escrow account?
Yes, within limits. A firm may authorize a nonlawyer to direct the bank to open escrow sub-accounts and to transfer funds from a sub-account to the master escrow account, under close supervision, as l…
Can legal-aid lawyers for unaccompanied immigrant children report client names and case details to a grant funder's database, and can a child consent to that disclosure?
They may disclose if the information is not privileged and disclosure would not be embarrassing or detrimental, or if the client (or a parent or guardian) gives voluntary informed consent. A young chi…
If a lawyer is admitted only in New York but lives and practices immigration law solely in another state, must they keep their client trust account at a New York bank?
No, unless the other state's rules require it. Under New York's choice-of-law rule (Rule 8.5(b)), a lawyer who is federally authorized to practice immigration law and works only in another state is tr…
Browse New York State Bar Association opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the New York State Bar Association interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.