New Jersey Supreme Court Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the New Jersey Supreme Court Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics, with full citations and source links on every page.
No New Jersey Supreme Court Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can the same lawyer serve as municipal prosecutor and as planning board attorney in the same municipality?
Yes. The Committee held there is no per se bar; a municipal prosecutor is limited-scope (not plenary) counsel, so the lawyer may also serve as planning board attorney, subject to case-by-case conflict…
Can a prosecutor publicly display drugs, weapons, or other contraband seized in a criminal investigation?
No. The Committee held that public displays of seized drugs, weapons, or other contraband are extrajudicial statements that violate RPC 3.6 and 3.8, and that the 2004 rule amendments did not change th…
Can a prosecutor condition a plea deal or pretrial intervention on the defendant releasing civil claims and agreeing to hold harmless the police or government?
No. The Committee concludes RPC 3.4(g) prohibits a prosecutor from conditioning a plea or entry into pretrial intervention on the defendant's release of civil liability and a hold-harmless agreement, …
In New Jersey, what makes a law firm's direct-mail solicitation letter to people charged with municipal offenses cross from permissible advertising into an ethics violation?
A joint opinion of the ACPE and the Committee on Attorney Advertising holds that solicitation letters which cast baseless aspersions on prosecutors and police, or misstate the prosecutor's role as sim…
Can a full-time municipal police officer who is a licensed lawyer also serve as the municipal prosecutor in the same town?
The Committee concluded that a full-time municipal police officer may not simultaneously serve as municipal prosecutor in the same municipality, because the appearance of impropriety, judged by the in…
Can the same lawyer be both the municipal attorney and the municipal prosecutor for the same town?
The Committee held that a municipal attorney may not also serve the same municipality as municipal prosecutor, because the municipal attorney advises the town on matters that may become relevant to mu…
Can a former prosecutor bring a civil case against a defendant he caused to be indicted on the same facts?
The Committee concluded the representation is impermissible: under RPC 1.11, a former prosecutor with prior knowledge and substantial responsibility in a criminal matter may not participate in a later…
Is it a conflict for a municipal prosecutor to serve in a court where the judge is his second cousin?
The Committee concluded there is no conflict requiring disqualification: New Jersey's recusal rule disqualifies a judge only where the related attorney is a first cousin or closer, so a second-cousin …
Can a Deputy Attorney General prosecuting a licensee before a professional board contact the board's head ex parte about settlement?
No. The Committee held that the agency head who sits in judgment on the matter is the equivalent of a judicial officer, so ex parte settlement communications by the prosecuting DAG, or by another DAG …
If a lawyer becomes 'of counsel' to a firm in the same county where his son is the full-time county prosecutor, is the firm barred from criminal practice in that county?
Yes. The opinion concluded that because the father is precluded from criminal practice in the county where his son is the prosecutor, the firm to which he becomes 'of counsel' is likewise barred, sinc…
May a municipal prosecutor also prosecute complaints in the same municipal court on behalf of a paying private client (the complaining witness)?
Yes. The opinion concluded there was no impropriety in a municipal prosecutor prosecuting a matter in his own municipal court on behalf of a private client, because in both roles he appears on behalf …
Can a lawyer both defend a client on a municipal-court charge and prosecute the cross-complaint that client filed against the same complaining witness?
Yes. The opinion concluded there is no conflict because the lawyer represents only his own client, both as defendant on the charge against him and as prosecutor of the client's own complaint, and a on…
Can a criminal defense lawyer privately represent an assistant prosecutor, county investigator, or county detective in personal matters while practicing criminal defense in the same county?
No. The opinion concluded that members of the local criminal defense bar should not undertake private representation of a prosecutor's staff (assistant prosecutors, county investigators, county detect…
Can an assistant county counsel have a partner who serves as a municipality's counsel in the same county, and can the assistant county counsel also be a municipal prosecutor there?
No to the first, yes to the second. The opinion concluded an assistant county counsel's partner may not be counsel to a municipality in the same county, but the assistant county counsel may also serve…
Can the associate of an assistant county counsel handle a criminal defendant's appeal from a conviction that arose in the same county?
No. The opinion concluded that an assistant county counsel may not defend against prosecution of offenses in his county, that disqualification extends to his associates and to every judicial level, so…
Can a New Jersey law firm that regularly prosecutes disorderly-persons cases for a private party in a municipal court also defend other defendants in that same court?
No. A firm that frequently and regularly prosecutes disorderly-persons offenses for and on behalf of the state or municipality under the court rules may not represent criminal defendants in that same …
Can a New Jersey municipal prosecutor (or another lawyer in the city law department) prosecute city employees, including police, at departmental disciplinary hearings and appeals?
No. Because the public sees the municipal prosecutor and city employees as on the same team, the appearance of conflict bars the prosecutor, and every other member of the municipal law department, fro…
Can a municipal prosecutor represent the police department at a departmental disciplinary hearing of charges against a municipal police officer?
No. The opinion held it is a conflict of interest, and unethical, for a municipal prosecutor to prosecute departmental charges against a municipal police officer, because the prosecutor works with the…
Can a township's municipal solicitor serve as defense counsel for people charged with motor vehicle offenses that occurred in his township, if the cases were transferred to a neighboring town's municipal court?
No. The opinion concluded there is a conflict of interest: it is unethical for a municipal solicitor, as the municipality's chief legal officer, to defend those accused of offenses that occurred withi…
Is there a conflict of interest if an assistant county prosecutor appears before a juvenile and domestic relations court where his mother is the chief clerk?
No. The opinion concluded that because the prosecutor handled only adult matters (child-support cases against absconding fathers) and not juvenile proceedings, his appearances before the court where h…
Can an attorney serve as municipal prosecutor in a town where his law partner is the attorney for the zoning board of adjustment?
No. The opinion concluded it is improper for a municipal prosecutor to be the law partner of the zoning board of adjustment's attorney, because a municipal prosecutor is a municipal attorney, a statut…
Can a law firm represent defendants who were investigated or indicted while one of the firm's associates was working on the county prosecutor's staff?
No. The opinion concluded a firm may not represent defendants who were investigated or under indictment during the time an associate of the firm served on the county prosecutor's staff, even if that a…
May a municipal prosecutor represent a private client in a driver's license revocation hearing before the Director of the Division of Motor Vehicles?
Yes. The opinion concluded there is no impropriety, provided the offense did not occur in the prosecutor's own municipality, applying R. 1:15-3(b) rather than the general conflict rule DR 5-105.
May a municipal prosecutor be politically active in a neighboring municipality and elsewhere in the county where he serves?
Yes. The opinion concluded there was nothing unethical in the proposed political activity, since the rules barring political activity reach the judicial branch rather than municipal prosecutors, and t…
May a former assistant prosecutor defend an accused in a criminal matter that was under investigation, by a state commission, within his old office's jurisdiction during his tenure, even if he never touched the file?
No. The opinion concluded the representation was improper, because the public would see a matter investigated within his former office's jurisdiction during his tenure, and his lack of personal involv…
Does a conflict that bars a firm from practicing criminal law in a county also bar a solo lawyer who tries the firm's cases in its name under a fee arrangement?
Yes. The opinion concluded the same disabilities that barred the firm extend to the inquirer, because he practices under the firm's name and can do so only as its associate, so he may not take cases t…
May a lawyer who represents a county prosecutor in an ethics matter also defend people accused of crime in that same county?
No. The opinion concluded that counsel to a prosecutor should refrain from representing the accused in that county while he represents the prosecutor, because the close personal relationship invites a…
Can a former assistant prosecutor later represent a man he convicted, in a civil-service appeal where that conviction is the reason the man lost his retirement benefits?
No. The opinion concluded the representation is improper under DR 5-105 and DR 4-101, because the conviction he obtained is the very basis of the benefits denial, raising both a confidential-informati…
Can a municipal prosecutor also take public-defender assignments to defend criminal cases in county court?
Sometimes. The opinion concluded a municipal prosecutor may not defend an accused in county court where the offense arose in, or the accused lived in, his own municipality, but may do so where both th…
Can a lawyer defend criminal cases in the same county where his spouse serves as an assistant prosecutor?
No. The opinion concluded that defending criminal matters in a county where one's wife is an assistant prosecutor would be improper, because the marital relationship places an undue, perhaps impossibl…
Can a former assistant county prosecutor defend someone indicted from an investigation his old office ran, if he played no part in it and had already resigned?
No. The opinion concluded it would be improper for a former assistant prosecutor to defend a person indicted as a result of an investigation by his former office, even though he took no part in it and…
If a lawyer's son becomes a full-time assistant prosecutor and they dissolve their partnership, can the father keep practicing criminal law in that county?
No. The opinion concluded that the father and former partner of a full-time assistant prosecutor should not continue to practice criminal law in the county, even though the son is only one of fourteen…
If a lawyer becomes municipal prosecutor, are his partners barred from appearing before the town's boards, and from other towns' courts?
Partly. The opinion concluded that if a partner becomes municipal prosecutor, all firm members are barred from appearing before that borough's council and boards; they are barred from other municipal …
Can an assistant county prosecutor represent private plaintiffs in a civil rights suit against a police department in the same county?
No. The opinion concluded it is improper for an assistant county prosecutor to represent private plaintiffs suing a municipality, its police department, and officers in the same county, because of the…
Can a member of a city's law department who prosecutes in municipal court also defend a police officer charged in that same court?
No. The opinion concluded that any member of the city's law department who prosecutes cases in the municipal court should not defend a police officer in the same court; the municipality may instead re…
May a county attorney or county prosecutor (or their partners) represent private clients before county boards or in criminal matters in that county?
The opinion concluded that neither the county attorney nor the county prosecutor, nor their assistants, partners, and associates, may represent private clients before county boards or in criminal matt…
May a municipal prosecutor, in one consolidated trial, prosecute a civilian and at the same time defend a police officer charged by that civilian?
The opinion concluded it would be improper for a municipal prosecutor to serve in that dual capacity in the same consolidated trial; while a court rule expressly let a municipal attorney defend a poli…
Can a municipal prosecutor represent his own client on appeal to the county court, challenging a conviction from the same municipal court he serves?
The Committee concluded it would be improper. A municipal prosecutor is in effect the municipality's attorney, so appearing on a county-court appeal that challenges the municipal court's determination…
Can a municipal prosecutor who was excused from a disorderly-persons case involving a client and the client's wife later prepare a separation agreement for that client?
Yes. The Committee concluded the later representation was not a violation, because the prosecutor had no personal connection with the investigation or prosecution of the disorderly-persons case and ha…
In New Jersey, can a lawyer who is a State Police officer also serve as a municipal prosecutor?
No. The Committee concluded that serving simultaneously as a New Jersey State Police officer and as a municipal prosecutor created an appearance of impropriety under the then-existing RPC 1.7(c)(2) an…
Can a municipal court judge share a law practice with a municipal prosecutor from another town, and may the judge's firm handle a criminal appeal arising from his own court's county?
The supplement concluded a municipal court judge may associate with a municipal prosecutor of another municipality only if the other lawyers refrain from all criminal-defense work within the county wh…
Browse New Jersey Supreme Court Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the New Jersey Supreme Court Advisory Committee on Professional Ethics interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.