Kentucky Bar Association Ethics Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of legal ethics opinions issued by the Kentucky Bar Association, with full citations and source links on every page.
No Kentucky Bar Association opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Can a former government lawyer in Kentucky disclose information, or testify as a fact or expert witness, about a matter they handled in office?
For a matter the lawyer personally and substantially participated in as a government officer or employee, the lawyer may disclose information or serve as a fact or expert witness only with the appropr…
Can an insurance-retained defense lawyer keep representing the insured when the carrier reserves coverage rights and intervenes in the same lawsuit?
It depends on how the coverage fight is structured. The lawyer may defend the insured even under a reservation of rights, but if the carrier intervenes in the same case and the coverage issues are not…
When Kentucky law firms discuss a merger, or a lawyer moves laterally, what client information can be shared for a conflicts check without client consent?
Firms and lateral lawyers may exchange basic client information (names, current/former status, adverse parties, and if needed a brief description of the matter) to check conflicts, but not privileged …
After mediating a divorce for unrepresented parties, can the lawyer-mediator draft the settlement agreement and the other documents needed to finish the case?
The lawyer-mediator may help draft the agreement reached in mediation, but may not prepare the ancillary documents needed to complete the divorce for the unrepresented parties, and cannot avoid that b…
In Kentucky, can a criminal defense lawyer advise a client to accept a plea deal that waives the right to claim ineffective assistance of counsel, and can a prosecutor offer one?
No to both. The opinion concluded that advising a client on a plea waiver of ineffective-assistance claims creates a non-waivable conflict of interest for defense counsel, and that a prosecutor who pr…
Can a Kentucky lawyer help a client obtain pre-settlement litigation funding during a case, charge for the help, and must the lawyer honor the client's promise to repay the lender from any recovery?
A lawyer may help a client identify a third-party lender and facilitate funding (the lawyer may not lend the money personally), may charge for services beyond the original engagement, and must hold di…
In Kentucky, could a part-time Commonwealth Attorney, or a member of the firm, represent a landowner in a condemnation action brought by the state?
No. The opinion concluded the representation is barred by KRPC 1.7 because the Commonwealth Attorney's client is the Commonwealth and the landowner's position is directly adverse to it, with the disqu…
Can a Kentucky lawyer borrow money to cover a client's litigation costs, pass the loan interest on to the client, and pledge the contingent fee as collateral?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may borrow from a lender to fund litigation expenses and may pass the interest on to the client if the business-transaction and fee-agreement safeguards are met, but may…
In Kentucky, is a lawyer imputedly disqualified when an office-mate previously represented a former client whose interests are adverse in the same or a substantially related matter?
The opinion concluded that if the office-sharing arrangement resembles a firm, the lawyer is imputedly disqualified under KRPC 1.9 and 1.10 unless the former client consents after consultation, or the…
Can a Kentucky lawyer share office space with a business or professional that is not engaged in the practice of law?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may share office space with nonlawyers, modifying an older flat ban, but only if the layout and operation safeguard client confidentiality, preserve the lawyer's profess…
In Kentucky, may an insurance-defense lawyer agree to follow an insurer's case-handling guidelines (such as prior approval of discovery or research, billing caps, and reporting deadlines) when representing the insured?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may agree to insurer guidelines only if they do not interfere with the lawyer's independent professional judgment, the lawyer discloses them and obtains the insured's in…
In Kentucky, could a part-time prosecutor represent the respondent in a civil domestic violence order (DVO) proceeding?
The opinion concluded a part-time prosecutor could not represent a DVO respondent, because the proceeding is so intertwined with the criminal system that it materially limited the prosecutor's duties …
In Kentucky, does a lawyer handling Title IV-D child-support enforcement for the state have an attorney-client relationship with the party seeking enforcement, even though a statute says there is none?
The opinion concluded that KRS 205.712(7) is not dispositive; whether an attorney-client relationship exists turns on whether a reasonable person, based on the parties' conduct, would understand one t…
In Kentucky, may the law partner of a prosecutor represent criminal defendants, even in a different county, even without sharing fees, and even if the firm does not advertise the prosecutor connection?
No. The opinion concluded that because a prosecutor cannot represent criminal defendants under KRPC 1.7, the prosecutor's law partner is imputed-disqualified under KRPC 1.10, and the conflict cannot b…
In Kentucky, when an insurer provides an insured's defense under a reservation of rights, may the defense lawyer communicate with the insurer and continue the representation despite the potential coverage conflict?
The opinion concluded the lawyer represents only the insured; the lawyer may have customary communications with the insurer with the insured's consent but must withhold information harmful to the insu…
In Kentucky, may an insurance-defense lawyer let the insurer forward the lawyer's detailed legal bills to an outside auditing company without the insured client's consent?
The opinion concluded the lawyer must obtain the insured client's fully informed consent before providing the insurer with detailed billing information when the lawyer knows the insurer sends that inf…
In Kentucky, can a lawyer who is also a real estate sales agent represent a client in the same transaction where the lawyer earns a sales commission?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may not serve as both lawyer and real estate sales agent in the same transaction, or where another agent in the lawyer's brokerage handles it, because the conflict is no…
In Kentucky, may a Department of Public Advocacy lawyer negotiate for future employment with a prosecutor's office?
The opinion concluded a public advocate may not negotiate employment with any office that is a party or counsel in a matter the lawyer is handling personally and substantially (an absolute bar under K…
In Kentucky, may two firms or office-sharing lawyers who often represent adverse clients share the same legal secretary?
The opinion concluded that firms or office-sharers who often represent adverse interests generally may not share a legal secretary (qualified no), because under KRPC 5.3 the lawyers cannot realistical…
In Kentucky, may a law firm send its detailed insurance-defense bills to the insurer's outside auditing company without the insured client's informed consent?
No. The opinion concluded a firm may submit detailed defense bills to a third-party auditor only with the informed consent of both the insured and the insurer, and may not release other clients' billi…
In Kentucky, when a lawyer represents the fiduciary of a decedent's estate or trust, does the lawyer also represent or owe special duties to the beneficiaries, and may the lawyer represent both?
The opinion concluded a lawyer for a fiduciary represents the fiduciary, not the estate, trust, or beneficiaries, and owes beneficiaries no duties beyond those owed to other third parties; confidentia…
In Kentucky, may a lawyer negotiate for a job with the firm representing the adverse party in a matter, and must the negotiations be disclosed to the lawyer's client?
The opinion concluded that a lawyer actually working on the matter, or who has protected client information under KRPC 1.9/1.10, may not negotiate with the opposing firm without the client's consent; …
In Kentucky, may a lawyer who serves as a part-time hearing examiner for a city Human Rights Commission still represent clients before that Commission in unrelated cases?
Yes. The opinion concluded the lawyer may continue to represent clients before the Commission in matters unrelated to those in which the lawyer participated as hearing examiner, by analogy to a part-t…
In Kentucky, will the KBA Ethics Committee decide motions to disqualify counsel that are referred to it by the courts?
No. The opinion concluded the Committee has no authority to hold hearings or resolve disputed facts and that no rule provides for referring disqualification motions to it; judges decide those motions …
In Kentucky, may a lawyer arrange with a charity to provide estate-planning services to donors, and may a charity pay or recommend the lawyer?
The opinion concluded a lawyer may not offer reduced or conditioned estate-planning services tied to a bequest, because that gives the charity something of value for recommending the lawyer, but may p…
In Kentucky, may a lawyer take a percentage of an investment advisor's recurring management fee for referring a client to that advisor, even with the client's consent?
No. The opinion concluded that a continuing referral fee tied to the client's assets under management creates a serious conflict that materially limits the lawyer's independent judgment, implicates th…
In Kentucky, may a former in-house lawyer represent a client against the former corporate employer in a matter substantially related to the lawyer's in-house work?
No. The opinion concluded that an in-house lawyer represents the entity as a client, so the former in-house lawyer owes the same former-client duties as any lawyer and may not, under Rules 1.9 and 1.1…
In Kentucky, may the spouse of a prosecutor practice criminal defense in the same jurisdiction if the spouses never appear in the same case and the client consents?
Yes. The opinion concluded that under Rule 1.8(i) a lawyer related to another lawyer may handle a matter adverse to the related lawyer's client with the client's consent after consultation, and that a…
In Kentucky, can a lawyer the insurer hires to defend an insured also represent the insurer on bad-faith (UCSPA) claims brought in the same action?
No. The opinion concluded that defense counsel represents the insured, not the insurer, and that dual representation of both on the insured's underlying tort and the insurer's UCSPA exposure presents …
In Kentucky, may a lawyer sell insurance to clients and take a commission, prospect for insurance customers, or accept referral fees from other insurance agents?
Qualified yes on selling insurance with full written disclosure and consent under Rules 1.7 and 1.8(a); no on accepting referral fees from other agents; the lawyer should not run an insurance agency f…
In Kentucky, may a lawyer lend a client money for financial assistance other than the expenses of litigation?
No. The opinion concluded that Rule 1.8(e) bars a lawyer from giving a client financial assistance beyond the expenses of litigation, so lending money for living or medical expenses is prohibited.
In Kentucky, may a criminal-defense firm pay a salary supplement to subsidize a new lawyer's two-year term with the prosecutor's office before the lawyer joins the firm?
No to the subsidy. The opinion concluded that a defense firm's $10,000 salary supplement subsidizing the prosecutor's office raised ethical problems, though the firm could conditionally hire the lawye…
In Kentucky, if a lawyer is a city alderman, may other members of the lawyer's firm represent clients before the local planning commission?
Yes, with safeguards. The opinion concluded firm members are not disqualified if the alderman is not on the relevant zoning committee, recuses from related votes and appointments, and the firm uses ap…
In Kentucky, may a defense lawyer contract with an insurer to handle all its defense work for a set fee, or agree to absorb all litigation expenses without reimbursement?
No to both. The opinion concluded that a blanket set-fee defense contract with an insurer, and an agreement to advance litigation expenses with no right to repayment, create conflicts with the insured…
In Kentucky, may a lawyer or firm that does civil contract work for a city department defend criminal cases arising in that city?
Yes. The opinion concluded that occasional civil contract work for a city, unlike serving as the city attorney, does not by itself disqualify a lawyer or firm from criminal defense in that city, unles…
In Kentucky, may a lawyer who practices domestic-relations law serve as a mediator in voluntary or court-annexed divorce mediation?
Yes. The opinion concluded there is no per se disqualification, but the lawyer-mediator must remain impartial and should not mediate where a present or past client relationship undermines that imparti…
In Kentucky, may a law firm that includes a part-time lawyer who is also a full-time police officer defend criminal cases in the jurisdiction where that officer serves?
No. The opinion reaffirmed KBA E-137 that a firm with a lawyer who is also a full-time police officer may not defend criminal cases arising in the jurisdiction where that officer exercises police powe…
In Kentucky, if a lawyer is defending a client against an opposing party, may that lawyer also be retained to represent the opposing party's lawyer in an unrelated malpractice or business matter?
There may be a conflict under Rule 1.7(b), but it is not automatic; depending on the facts, the lawyer's reasonable belief that representation will not be materially limited, plus client consent after…
In Kentucky, may a private lawyer who represents a state agency under contract take a case against that same agency, or against a different state agency?
No against the agency the lawyer represents (and the disqualification is imputed to the firm), but yes against a different state agency with the consent of both the client agency and the private clien…
In Kentucky, did adopting the Rules of Professional Conduct overturn the rule that a prosecutor and the prosecutor's firm cannot try defendants the prosecutor is suing in civil litigation?
No. The opinion concluded the 1990 Rules did not overturn the prior opinions and decisions; a prosecutor still should not try a defendant the prosecutor is embroiled with in civil litigation, and the …
In Kentucky, may a city attorney who has no prosecutorial duties and does not advise the police defend criminal cases involving the city's police?
No. The opinion maintained a bright-line bar: a city attorney may not defend criminal cases involving the city police, even without prosecutorial duties or a special contractual waiver.
In Kentucky, if a lawyer sits on a zoning board or planning commission, may the lawyer's partners or associates represent clients before that board?
No. The opinion concluded that a lawyer who sits on a zoning board may not appear before it, and that the lawyer's partners and associates are likewise disqualified, even if the member-lawyer recuses.
Can a lawyer form a title insurance company, sell an interest to someone tied to a mortgage company, and share title-policy profits in exchange for the mortgage company channeling closings to the lawyer?
No. The opinion concluded the arrangement is little more than a lawyer buying legal work, which the rules forbid (giving anything of value for recommending the lawyer's services); only the requirement…
When an insurer hires a lawyer to defend its insured, may the lawyer let the insurer's claims personnel sit in on the attorney-client interview?
Qualified no. The opinion treats the insured as the client; counsel must keep independent judgment and guard client confidences, and must resist an insurer's demand to attend interviews. Insurer repre…
May a Kentucky lawyer serve as a divorce mediator or as independent counsel for a party in mediation, and may a mediation service hand out a list of interested lawyers?
Yes. The opinion concluded a lawyer may serve as mediator under Model Rule 2.2 (not as advocate for both spouses), independent counsel must exercise independent judgment, and a service may share a law…
Can a liability insurer's instructions limiting how defense counsel conducts the defense create an ethical problem for the lawyer?
Yes. The opinion concluded that, although an insurer may legitimately control costs, carrier-imposed restrictions can reach a point where they threaten the lawyer's ability to give the insured (the cl…
Can a defense lawyer offer to settle a class action on the condition that the plaintiffs waive their statutory attorney fees?
Qualified yes. The opinion concluded that, after Evans v. Jeff D., a good-faith settlement offer conditioned on a fee waiver is not unethical per se; whether a particular offer was made for an imprope…
Must a Kentucky firm tell a client that one of its lawyers is married to a lawyer at the opposing firm?
The opinion concluded disclosure is required when both spouses are working on the matter, and also when only one spouse is working on it; when neither spouse works on the matter, disclosure is not man…
Can a criminal defense lawyer share office space with, or rent space in the same building as, a part-time or full-time prosecutor?
The opinion concluded a defense lawyer may not share office space with a full or part-time prosecutor; sharing with a special-function part-time prosecutor is allowed if the sharers avoid cases advers…
Can a criminal defense lawyer argue on appeal that his own representation amounted to ineffective assistance of counsel?
Qualified no. The opinion concluded the lawyer should ordinarily inform the client and move to withdraw rather than argue his own ineffectiveness, given the conflict with his reputation and the lawyer…
Can Kentucky lawyers form a legal-research service that does research for other lawyers, and what duties do they owe the hiring lawyer's clients?
Yes. The opinion concluded lawyers may form a research service that works for the inquiring attorney rather than the client; the service must protect the clients' confidences and secrets, so it cannot…
Can a Kentucky lawyer who was approached by, but never retained by, a prospective plaintiff later represent the defendant in the same matter?
Yes. The opinion concluded the lawyer may take the adverse representation if no lawyer-client relationship ever formed and the lawyer obtained no confidences or secrets from the prospective client tha…
Can a lawyer who was abruptly discharged by a client he believes is incompetent initiate a conservatorship or other protective proceeding for that client?
Qualified yes, but only in extreme cases. Where there is substantial evidence of incompetency, undue influence, or prejudice to the client's interests, the discharged lawyer may initiate a conservator…
Can two separate law firms describe themselves as affiliated or associated on their letterhead without misleading the public?
Yes. Refining KBA E-299, the opinion adopted ABA Formal Opinion 84-351 and concluded that firms may communicate an affiliation or association so long as the relationship is close and regular (not mere…
When a paralegal leaves one firm and joins the opposing firm in pending cases, is the hiring firm disqualified by a conflict of interest?
A paralegal's prior work is not automatically imputed to the hiring firm, but the former firm may make a series of confidentiality requests, and because of the appearance of impropriety the hiring fir…
Can a lawyer who chairs the board of a counseling agency represent one spouse in a divorce after the couple was counseled at that agency and referred to him?
No. Because the lawyer-board member had access to the couple's confidential counseling file and financial information, representing one spouse against the other would let him do indirectly what he cou…
Can a lawyer paid by an insurer prepare the guardianship and settlement-approval petition for an unrepresented minor and parents and appear in court with them?
Qualified yes. The lawyer may do so only on strict conditions: full disclosure to the family and the court that the lawyer's only client is the insurer and does not vouch the settlement is fair, submi…
Can the law partner of an assistant county attorney defend a criminal case in another court, or represent in a civil matter someone being prosecuted by that office?
No to both. The opinion concluded that partners and associates of an assistant county attorney may not act as criminal defense counsel anywhere in the state, and may not take a civil matter for a pers…
Can client consent or screening let a former judge's law firm work on a matter in which the judge ruled on the merits while on the bench?
Qualified yes. The former judge personally still cannot represent a party in a matter he ruled on, but his firm may participate where all parties consent or the court approves, and the firm screens th…
Can a Commonwealth Attorney represent a party in a contested custody case, and must he withdraw if the other side seeks a criminal complaint?
Yes, he may take the custody case where no criminal warrant has issued; if the opposing party later seeks but is refused a criminal complaint, continued representation is a qualified yes, and automati…
Browse Kentucky Bar Association opinions by topic
Legal ethics opinions from the Kentucky Bar Association interpret the rules of professional conduct for working lawyers, in response to inquiries from members and committees. They are not binding like court discipline decisions, but courts and discipline boards treat formal opinions as substantial guidance on how the rules apply. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the original source on the bar's site.