North Carolina Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in North Carolina, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No North Carolina opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
When the NC General Assembly later passes a general law about school board vacancies, does it override an older local act that set its own rules for one specific district?
Not unless the later general law plainly manifests legislative intent to repeal the local act. For the Elizabeth City-Pasquotank Board of Education, the 1967 local act remains controlling: vacancies a…
When someone is appointed to fill a vacancy on the Brunswick County (NC) Board of Education, do they serve the rest of the original term or only until the next election?
Only until the next election. The AG traced the legislative history from 1966 through 1981 and concluded that, absent a local act saying otherwise, the General Assembly has always intended appointed s…
Can the NC State Treasurer use money in the Escheats Fund to pay for newspaper ads listing the names of people who may have unclaimed property, beyond the bare-minimum notices the statute specifically requires?
Yes. § 116B-6(h) authorizes the Treasurer to expend Escheats funds for 'costs of notice and publication,' and the statutory language is not limited to the specific publications required by § 116B-62(b…
When the NC legislature moved the DMV Enforcement Section from DOT to the Department of Crime Control and Public Safety in 2002, did it also move the special tax-information exception that let DMV exchange tax data with the Department of Revenue?
Yes. Even though the General Assembly forgot to update G.S. 105-259(b)(7) in the laundry list of statutes it specifically rewrote, the omnibus 'successor in interest' language in Section 1 of Chapter …
Does the grandfather clause in § 58-47-65(c), which exempts pre-1995 group workers' compensation self-insurance funds from the 1997 licensing rewrite, still protect a fund that was organized in 1993, filed dissolution articles in 1998, but never completely wound down before deciding to resume operations?
Yes, on the facts as presented. The fund was organized and approved before July 1, 1995, so it qualifies as a 'pre-1995' fund. Its 1998 dissolution paperwork did not terminate its existence (operation…
Can the NC Department of Transportation fund the proposed Northern Durham Parkway, which includes improvements to existing inner-city roads like Roxboro Road and Duke Street, with Highway Trust Fund 'urban loop' money under § 136-176(b)(2)?
No. The Trust Fund's statutory description of the Durham Northern Loop specifies a 'multilane facility on new location from I-85 west of Durham to U.S. 70 east of Durham.' Improvements to existing inn…
Are draft redistricting plans drawn by a North Carolina legislator personally, using the legislature's computer system but without staff help, public records the public can demand to see?
The statutes do not clearly answer the question. G.S. §§ 120-130, 131, and 133 protect plans drawn by legislative employees but say nothing about plans drawn by legislators themselves. Two competing c…
When a North Carolina insurance corporation files a conversion plan, can the Commissioner of Insurance hire outside experts to review it without going through the state's normal consultant-contract approval process?
Yes. Section 58-65-131(e) of the NC General Statutes specifically exempts the personal professional service contracts the Commissioner uses to review insurance corporation conversion plans from Articl…
When a state agency's incentive bonus program produces budget savings, and the underlying funding source is a 'Special Fund' rather than the General Fund, where do those savings go: back to the Special Fund per its own statute, or to the General Fund under the general incentive-bonus statute?
It depends on what the Special Fund statute says. If the Special Fund statute directs how surplus or unspent money is to be handled, that direction controls. If the Special Fund statute is silent on w…
When does a business in North Carolina need to have an air-pollution permit in hand: when it finishes building a new pollution source, or when it starts construction?
Start of construction. The 2001 NC AG opinion interpreted N.C.G.S. § 143-215.108(a)(2) to require an air-permit before any on-site assembling of materials that will constitute a 'source' of air contam…
When a child reports being abused while held in a county-operated juvenile detention facility, does the local Department of Social Services have the authority to investigate the abuse claim, or is the case outside DSS's jurisdiction because secure detention facilities are licensed by the Office of Juvenile Justice rather than DSS?
Yes, DSS has the authority to investigate. The 2000 NC AG opinion concluded that a county-operated secure juvenile detention facility is a 'residential child care facility' as that term is used in N.C…
What does 'adequate' mean when North Carolina law requires county commissioners to provide 'adequate' funding to a community college?
'Adequate' meant 'sufficient to meet specific requirements,' a standard imported from a 1951 NC Supreme Court decision and consistent with both Black's Law Dictionary and the American Heritage College…
Could a North Carolina home-schooled teenager who used a hunting rifle on family property under a parent's supervision lose their learner's permit or driver's license under the 'Lose Control, Lose Your License' law?
No. The AG read the statute literally and concluded that 'enumerated student conduct' triggering license revocation required the conduct to actually 'result in disciplinary action.' Disciplinary actio…
Can the NC State Education Assistance Authority advance state student loan funds to colleges so the colleges can directly make federal student loans to their graduate students?
Yes. The AG concluded that the State Education Assistance Authority had statutory authority under G.S. §§ 116-201, 116-204(8), and 116-209.3 to advance funds from the NC Student Loan Fund to NC colleg…
When NC police seize a car under the DWI-while-license-revoked statute and tow it through the local rotation instead of the school board's tow contractor, who pays the towing bill?
The county board of education paid the bill, and had only 10 days to retrieve the vehicle. The AG read G.S. § 20-28.3(d) as putting the retrieval and payment duty on the local school board whenever th…
When calculating an NC Supreme Court Justice's longevity pay, does service as Administrative Office of the Courts director or assistant director count? What about service as an assistant district attorney?
The AG concluded that AOC director and assistant director service counts toward longevity for a NC Supreme Court Justice, because those positions were already explicitly equated with superior-court-ju…
If a North Carolina statute (G.S. § 7B-3400) says minors are subject to their parents' supervision and control 'notwithstanding any other provision of law,' does that wipe out the separate minor-consent statute (G.S. § 90-21.5) and let parents stop a county health department from giving birth control to a teenager without their consent?
No. AG Mike Easley's office concluded that the two statutes address different subjects and do not actually conflict. G.S. § 7B-3400 sits in Article 34 of the Juvenile Code and is about getting runaway…
Can the NC Principal Fellows Commission approve school administrator programs at private colleges in NC, and award scholarship loans to students enrolled in those private programs, or is the Commission limited to UNC system institutions?
Yes to both. The Principal Fellows Commission may approve programs at private NC institutions and award scholarship loans to qualifying students there. The statute (G.S. 116-74.42) authorizes the Comm…
Can a North Carolina charter school satisfy the state's 180-day instructional requirement by running a five-month residential program with extended daily hours that adds up to 1000 instructional hours, instead of operating across the traditional nine-month school year?
No. AG Mike Easley's office concluded that G.S. § 115C-238.29F(d)(1) requires charter schools to offer instruction for at least 180 days, and the requirement cannot be satisfied by compressing those d…
When the 1998 budget bill restored the cost-of-living raise for state employees with poor performance ratings, did that fix reach backward to give them the 1997 COLA they missed too, or only the 1998 COLA?
Only the 1998 COLA. The NC AG concluded that Session Law 1998-212 restored COLA eligibility going forward for employees who had been excluded under § 126-7(c)(4b) because of documented poor performanc…
If a NC county votes in 1998 to expand its board of commissioners from three to five, when does the expansion actually take effect, the next county election in 2000 or 2002 as the resolution said?
The next election for county offices, which was the year 2000. The Madison County Board of Commissioners had passed a resolution scheduling the November 1998 referendum that, if approved, would seat a…
If a group is applying to start a North Carolina charter school, can it run an enrollment period and admission lottery for the next school year before the State Board of Education grants final charter approval?
No. Under the Charter School Act, only an approved 'charter school' may enroll students or conduct an admission lottery. Up until final approval by the State Board of Education, the entity is an 'appl…
In North Carolina, can a school principal leave a school district to work at a charter school and use the same protected leave-of-absence statute that classroom teachers use, so they can come back later with their old career status?
No. N.C.G.S. § 115C-238.29F(e)(3) requires a local school administrative unit to grant an extended leave of absence to a teacher who wants to teach at a charter school. The AG concluded the term 'teac…
If a registered Professional Engineer is also a state employee or state official doing engineering work as part of their job, does the NC engineering licensing board still have disciplinary jurisdiction over them?
Yes. The Engineering Board has jurisdiction over every registered Professional Engineer in the state and can enforce rules of professional conduct against them. It does not matter whether the engineer…
If a homeowner has been partially paid by the general contractor who botched the job, can the homeowner still recover any of the remaining loss from North Carolina's Homeowners Recovery Fund?
No. The Homeowners Recovery Fund definition of 'reimbursable loss' in N.C.G.S. § 87-15.5(6) requires that the loss 'is not paid, in whole or in part, by or on behalf of the general contractor whose co…
When a member of the Edgecombe County Board of Education (merged school system) resigns mid-term, does the board's appointee serve the remainder of the four-year term, or must voters elect a replacement at the next general election to serve out the remainder?
The appointee serves the remainder of the unexpired term, with no intervening election. The AG concluded that Chapter 809 of the 1991 Session Laws, the local act establishing the merged Edgecombe boar…
Does the Butner Planning Council have to submit three new candidate names for Town Manager to the Secretary of Health and Human Services while the position is already filled?
No. Under N.C.G.S. § 122C-403(9), the Planning Council must submit three names to the Secretary only when there is a vacancy in the Town Manager position. While the current Town Manager is in office, …
Can a North Carolina magistrate be removed from office mid-term if they move out of the county for which they were appointed?
No. Under N.C.G.S. § 7A-171.2(a), county residency is a qualification only 'for nomination or renomination,' not for continuing in office. Once a magistrate is appointed to a two-year term by the seni…
Can a State Board of Education member keep his seat if his spouse works for a local public school system, and what happens if a board member's spouse takes a public school job after the member is confirmed?
The two questions get different answers. A public school employee appointed to the single dedicated public-school-employee seat under the 1989 amendment to NCGS 115C-10 keeps his seat even if his spou…
Can North Carolina's Parks and Recreation Trust Fund give grants to towns and counties for park master plans, site plans, comprehensive system plans, or citizen surveys, or only for actually buying land and building park facilities?
Only for buying land and building park facilities. The AG concluded that § 113-44.15(b)(2)'s 30% local-government allocation must be spent under criteria patterned after the federal Land and Water Con…
In North Carolina's vehicle safety and emissions inspection program, who decides whether a station's violation is Type I, II, or III, and can the DMV Commissioner delegate that decision to staff?
The DMV Commissioner has direct statutory responsibility to determine emissions-program violation designations and penalties, but can delegate that authority to other Division employees as a matter of…
After the General Assembly cut the NC Enterprise Corporation tax credit cap in mid-1996 and then repealed the credit altogether effective January 1, 1997, did the savings clause in the repealer let an existing enterprise corporation keep offering investors the old, higher credit for the remainder of 1996?
No. The AG concluded that Piedmont Venture Management's argument failed at multiple steps. An enterprise corporation never had a 'right' to offer tax credits to investors; tax credits are creations of…
When the NC Utilities Commission collects refund money from a regulated utility through a stipulated settlement (not a formal Commission order requiring the refund), and the utility cannot find some of the overcharged customers, does that unclaimed money escheat to the State Treasurer like other unclaimed property, or does it stay with the Commission?
It escheats. The funds the Utilities Commission holds for unlocated customers under a stipulated settlement count as 'property held for the owner by a public corporation or authority' under N.C.G.S. §…
If a North Carolina statute tells the Natural Heritage Trust Fund Board to set aside 'not to exceed 20%' of newly acquired land's value for a stewardship account, does the Board have to actually fund the account, or can it leave the account at zero?
The Board does not have to fund the account. The AG concluded that § 113-77.7(c)'s 'not to exceed twenty percent (20%)' language sets a ceiling, not a floor. Reading the statute to require a mandatory…
If a North Carolina town like Chapel Hill passes an open-container ordinance under § 18B-300(c) but does not include statutory definitions of 'malt beverage' or 'unfortified wine' inside the ordinance, is the ordinance void for vagueness, or do the Chapter 18B definitions automatically apply?
Not vague. The General Assembly has preempted alcohol regulation in North Carolina, and any local ordinance under Chapter 18B is bound by the chapter's definitions whether the ordinance restates them …
When the General Assembly tells a state agency it can't spend money on a federal-court-mandated program except from specifically appropriated funds, can the agency still move lapsed salary money over to cover a shortfall?
Yes. The AG read § 143-23(a1)(3) and the conflicting 1995 budget provisions in pari materia and concluded that transferring lapsed salaries to cover the Thomas S. shortfall was lawful because the over…
When the 1993 General Assembly transferred 'the legal counsel and support staff' of the Banking Commission to the Department of Justice, did that mean one Commission attorney or two?
One. The 1993 Session Laws used singular language ('the' attorney, 'an' attorney) in three different provisions, so the legislature intended to transfer only one attorney (plus support staff) from the…
Can the Commissioner of Banks construe the phrase 'trust assets' in N.C.G.S. § 53-122(1) (which sets bank-examination assessment fees) to include all fiduciary assets except real estate held by a bank's trust department, including guardianships, managing agencies, and safekeeping accounts? And does the agency have to refund trust-assessment fees previously collected on that broader basis, as a prior Commissioner's January 1995 letters suggested?
Yes, the AG concluded the Commissioner may construe 'trust assets' to include all fiduciary assets (except real estate) held by the bank's trust department, not just narrow express trusts. The Office …
Can the NC House of Representatives adopt a rule that limits how many bills each individual member may introduce, or does that violate some constitutional right of legislators to introduce as many bills as they want?
The House can adopt such a rule. Members of the NC House do not have a constitutional or inherent right to introduce unlimited bills. Historically, in both the U.S. Congress and the NC House, introduc…
If a NC Coastal Resources Commission member moves outside the coastal area (or even outside North Carolina), does that change of residence automatically vacate their seat, or can they finish their existing term? And could a non-NC resident be reappointed?
The member can finish the existing term even if the residency mix on the Commission becomes inconsistent with § 113A-104(e). The statute's residency caps restrict the Governor's appointment power at t…
Does North Carolina's 1993 'safe and sane' pyrotechnics law override an older Forsyth County local act that defined pyrotechnics differently?
Yes, by implied repeal. When a later statewide statute and an older local act define the same thing in irreconcilable ways, the later statewide law controls if the legislature's intent to apply it eve…
When a person who put up bail for a traffic ticket fails to appear and the court orders the bail forfeited, does the clerk of court have to report the forfeiture to DMV as a conviction, and does the answer depend on what kind of bond was posted?
It depends. The AG concluded that only a forfeiture of a defendant's cash bond, posted in the full amount of bail with the court, qualifies as a conviction under NCGS 20-4.01(4a) and must be reported …
Can the State Board of Education adopt a rule that lets a local school board reduce the 180-day school term for just one school (when an emergency closes that one school) on different terms than the rule that applies when emergency closures affect a whole school district?
No. G.S. 115C-84(c) sets a single statutory method for reducing the 180-day term: build in make-up days, exhaust them, then petition the State Board for relief. That method governs whether the closure…
Could a North Carolina state-chartered savings bank become a regular commercial bank in the mid-1990s and then merge with another commercial bank?
Yes. The AG concluded that while no statute authorized a savings bank to merge directly with a commercial bank, a two-step path worked: a Chapter 54C state savings bank could convert into a Chapter 53…
Once the General Assembly fixed the Carteret-Craven county boundary in a statute, can the NC Geodetic Survey Section adjust the line on the ground to accommodate landowners whose property would otherwise be split between counties?
No. Article VII, Section 1 of the NC Constitution gives the General Assembly the power to fix county boundaries, and the 1993 statute used coordinates with a defined plus-or-minus tolerance. The Geode…
Can the NC Air Cargo Airport Authority make grants to the Global TransPark Development Commission, or does it have to use a different legal mechanism to send money over?
Not grants, but yes, payments under a contract. The Authority has no explicit grant-making power. It does have express statutory authority to contract with state and local governments and other author…
Does North Carolina's school-involvement leave statute (four hours per year) apply to public school employees, and is the 'year' a calendar year, a fiscal year, or something the employer can pick?
The NC AG concluded that N.C.G.S. § 95-28.3 applies to public school employees and other state and local government workers, that the four hours is a minimum the employer must allow (not a maximum), a…
If two doctors who owned a clinic before April 1, 1993 transfer the clinic's assets to a new corporation they also own, do they keep the grandfathered 'grace period' that lets them refer patients to that clinic until July 1, 1995?
Yes, but only for themselves. The doctors never relinquished their investment interest in the underlying clinic when they transferred its assets to a new corporation in which they also held stock. The…
When a district court seat opens, which county bar associations get to vote on the nomination list submitted to the Governor — the bars in the judicial district as it exists today, or the bars in the district as it existed on January 1, 1987?
January 1, 1987 controls. The NC AG concluded that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 7A-142 (read together with § 84-19) freezes the membership of each judicial district bar for nomination purposes to the judicial di…
Can the North Carolina ferry system sell souvenirs like T-shirts, jackets, hats, coffee cups, and post cards at its onboard concessions?
No. The AG concluded that G.S. 136-82 limited the Department of Transportation's ferry concessions to 'food, drink, other refreshments, and personal comfort items.' Reading 'personal comfort items' ag…
Are pay-to-ride go-carts on a track an amusement device that the North Carolina Department of Labor can inspect and regulate?
Yes. The NC AG concluded that a go-cart operated by a patron for a fee on a fixed or restricted track meets the statutory definition of 'amusement device' in N.C.G.S. § 95-111.3(a) because it conveys …
In NC, do the size and content rules in G.S. 47-30 (the plat mapping statute) apply to every plat a surveyor draws, or only to plats that are going to be recorded at the Register of Deeds?
Only to plats presented for recording. G.S. 47-30 sets requirements for recordable plats, not for surveys done for other purposes. Whether a surveyor must comply depends on whether the plat will be fi…
If a North Carolina will excuses a testamentary trustee from filing inventories and annual accounts, does the trustee still have to qualify before the clerk of superior court?
Yes. The 1984 AG concluded that for wills executed after January 1, 1978, a testamentary trustee must qualify before the clerk under G.S. 36A-107, even if the will waives the duty to file inventories …
When North Carolina's 1984 redistricting bill ended up with contradictory language placing all of Vance County in Senatorial District 11 in one part of the bill but parts of Vance County in District 2 in another part, which version actually controls?
District 11. AG Rufus L. Edmisten concluded that the legislative history of Chapter 5 of the Extra Session of 1984 (the Senate floor amendment expressly placed all of Vance County in District 11) made…
If a Scotland County commissioner dies during the first two years of a four-year term after the filing deadline for the upcoming primary, but before the general election, how does the county select party nominees for the November ballot to fill the seat?
The county should look to N.C. Gen. Stat. § 163-115, even though that statute by its terms addresses clerk-of-superior-court vacancies and state/district offices, not county commissioner vacancies. Th…
Can a North Carolina life care center receive a certificate of need to add nursing home beds, even though the 1983 session law has a cross-reference to a subsection that doesn't quite fit, suggesting the legislature may not have meant to include life care centers?
Yes. The 1983 AG concluded that the reference in section 1 of Chapter 920 to 'section 31(f)' was a clerical mistake. The reference should be read as a reference to section 31 (which does authorize lif…
Does a Superior Court or Appellate Court judge who took the bench before January 1, 1974 but retired after that date get later increases to keep his retirement at two-thirds of the current salary paid to the office he left?
No. The 1983 AG concluded that the Uniform Judicial Retirement System protected the initial retirement allowance for pre-1974 judges by using the higher of the old (Chapter 7A) or new (Chapter 135) ca…
When North Carolina paused new rest-home licensing in 1982 to slow the growth of institutional elder care, did that moratorium also block existing rest homes from getting relicensed when they changed owners or administrators?
No. The AG concluded that the moratorium's 'initial licensure' restriction applied only to new facilities or new beds, not to changes of ownership or administrator at an already-licensed facility. The…
Did the 1981 amendment to North Carolina's interest-on-judgments statute, G.S. 24-5, allow clerks to assess interest on costs?
No. The AG concluded the 1981 amendment to G.S. 24-5 (Session Laws 1981, c. 327) was aimed at changing the accrual period for interest on compensatory damages in tort actions covered by liability insu…
If a retired North Carolina district or superior court judge bought back his military service time within the Uniform Judicial Retirement System, does that purchased military service count toward the 15 years of creditable service required to be commissioned as an emergency judge?
Yes. The AG concluded that purchased military service in the Uniform Judicial Retirement System is creditable service for purposes of the 15-year requirement to serve as an emergency judge under G.S. …
Browse North Carolina opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in North Carolina are written by the North Carolina Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.