North Carolina Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in North Carolina, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No North Carolina opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
After the General Assembly failed to pass HB 207 (which would have appropriated Highway Fund money to raise Highway Patrol telecommunicator salaries), is the Office of State Personnel barred from reclassifying telecommunicator positions statewide?
No. The AG concluded the failed bill did not strip OSP of its statutory market-survey authority under G.S. 126-1 and 126-4. HB 207's purpose was to appropriate new money from the Highway Fund for High…
If a North Carolina county wants to buy office space for its public hospital and the seller is a corporation in which one of the hospital's trustees (not a county commissioner) holds a one-third interest, does G.S. § 14-234 make that purchase illegal?
No. G.S. § 14-234 is a criminal statute that targets commissioners and directors who personally benefit from contracts they help approve in their capacity as the public-trust decisionmaker. The county…
Are jailers and 911 communicators (telecommunicators / dispatchers) employed by a North Carolina sheriff's office automatically considered 'law enforcement officers' under the state retirement statutes just because they are sworn officers with the power of arrest?
No. Being a sworn officer with arrest powers is necessary but not sufficient. To qualify as a 'law enforcement officer' under the Local Governmental Employees' Retirement System and the State 401(k) s…
When can a North Carolina substance abuse treatment facility release information about a patient to police, a court, or to anyone else, and how do federal rules and state rules interact?
It depends on whether the facility is 'federally assisted.' Most are, because federal funding, Medicare participation, controlled-substance registration, or tax-exempt status all trigger federal cover…
When the North Carolina Commissioner of Banks decides a matter and the loser appeals to the State Banking Commission, may the Commissioner talk to Commission members off-the-record about the case, and if not, what happens to people who do that anyway?
No, ex parte communications are prohibited. G.S. § 150B-40(d) bars Commission members from discussing the facts or law of a pending contested case with anyone except on notice to all parties, starting…
Is the State of NC protected from large medical malpractice judgments, and if so, why does NC still buy liability insurance for some agencies?
Yes. NC's sovereign immunity is absolute except where waived, and the only relevant waiver for medical malpractice runs through the State Tort Claims Act, which caps state liability at $100,000 per cl…
After a federal court called part of a 1991 NC AG opinion 'incomprehensible' and let consumer finance licensees collect insurance commissions on loan-related sales, do consumer finance companies still have to apply for 'other business' authority from the Commissioner of Banks before selling unrelated products on the same premises?
Yes. The AG concluded the federal decision in Herndon v. ITT Consumer Financial Corp. did not change the case-by-case 'other business' authorization requirement under G.S. 53-172. The federal court's …
Within the NC Department of Commerce, which Type II agencies have hire-and-fire authority over their own staff under their own organic statutes, rather than answering to the Secretary of Commerce?
The AG identified fourteen Type II commissions, divisions, and agencies inside the Department of Commerce whose own statutes specifically vest hire-and-fire authority over staff in the agency rather t…
Does someone who has a federal firearms dealer's license automatically owe the NC state firearms dealer's license tax?
Not automatically. The NC privilege tax under G.S. § 105-80 closely mirrors the federal license definitions in 18 U.S.C. § 921 et seq., but the NC legislature has not declared federal licensure conclu…
During North Carolina's emergency prison-cap releases, which inmates can the Parole Commission grant parole to under the 1994 amendments to G.S. 148-4.1?
The AG concluded the Parole Commission could parole all nonviolent inmates not sentenced under Structured Sentencing (Article 81B of Chapter 15A) during emergency release periods. The 'notwithstanding…
Can a North Carolina city prohibit consumption of malt beverages and unfortified wine on state highways that pass through its corporate limits?
No. The AG concluded N.C.G.S. § 18B-300(a) permits adults 21 and older to consume malt beverages and unfortified wine without restriction. A city may regulate consumption only on property 'owned or oc…
Can a North Carolina county use eminent domain to take land that it plans to donate to the state for a prison site?
No. The AG concluded that a county has no power of eminent domain to acquire land it intends to convey to the state. Counties only get the condemnation powers that the legislature has expressly grante…
If a North Carolina county cuts its mental health funding contribution, does it still get full state expansion funds, and what does the rule against using fee income to replace local tax revenue actually mean?
Counties can cut their contributions, including retroactive cuts to the prior fiscal year's budget. But that decision can cost the area authority state expansion funds because the Secretary has discre…
Can a North Carolina town amend its charter by ordinance to limit when the mayor can vote, even if the original charter was created by the now-abolished Municipal Board of Control?
The AG concluded yes. Part 4 of Article 5 of Chapter 160A (sections 160A-101 to 160A-111) gives any city the power to modify charter provisions by ordinance to fit the options listed in § 160A-101. Ri…
Can the state designate an entire historic house that doubles as office space as a nonsmoking area if part of it functions as a museum and library?
Yes. The AG concluded that because the entire Humber House was used to exhibit artifacts and to house a library open to the public, the whole building qualified as both a 'museum' and a 'library' unde…
Can a private publisher claim copyright on NC's General Statutes text, and can the state limit who gets a copy of the digital statutes database?
No to both. The Michie Company cannot have a state-enforceable copyright on the text of the NC General Statutes, the section numbering and chapter/article titles, or the history notes (prepared by Gen…
Once the General Assembly fixed the Carteret-Craven county boundary in a statute, can the NC Geodetic Survey Section adjust the line on the ground to accommodate landowners whose property would otherwise be split between counties?
No. Article VII, Section 1 of the NC Constitution gives the General Assembly the power to fix county boundaries, and the 1993 statute used coordinates with a defined plus-or-minus tolerance. The Geode…
Can the personal representative of a North Carolina decedent's estate apply for state Commercial Leaking Underground Storage Tank Fund reimbursement for cleanup of contamination from tanks the decedent removed before death?
Yes, but the estate inherits both the rights and the limitations the decedent had. The AG concluded a personal representative steps into the decedent's shoes under G.S. 28A-18-1(a), so the estate's el…
Can the NC Air Cargo Airport Authority make grants to the Global TransPark Development Commission, or does it have to use a different legal mechanism to send money over?
Not grants, but yes, payments under a contract. The Authority has no explicit grant-making power. It does have express statutory authority to contract with state and local governments and other author…
When a corporation buys equity in a qualified North Carolina small business and takes the 25% qualified business investments tax credit, why does the state make the corporation reduce its tax basis AND add the credit back into taxable income, partially canceling the benefit?
Both adjustments come from explicit statutes, not administrative discretion. N.C.G.S. § 105-163.012(d) requires reducing basis in the equity for the credit (which delays the tax benefit until sale). N…
Did the DOT Employee Insurance Committee's request for proposals for 'variable universal life insurance' violate the rule that only one insurance company can occupy each state-employee payroll deduction slot?
Maybe, depending on whether 'variable universal' meant the same thing as the 'universal' life product DOT already had in a slot. Because the industry uses the terms interchangeably and the Department …
Can a North Carolina town swap easements with a corporation when a town commissioner owns a major stake in that corporation?
No. The exchange would violate G.S. 14-234, which prohibits public officers from contracting with their own governmental unit when they have a financial stake in the deal. The major-stockholder commis…
Can a parent take their teenager's driver's license to the DMV and have it cancelled, or does the teenager have to agree?
The teenager has to agree. DMV's policy required both the minor licensee and a parent or guardian to sign the voluntary-surrender form. Without the minor's signature, DMV had no statutory authority to…
Do registered lobbyists and their principals have to file a separate set of expense reports after every special (extra) session of the North Carolina General Assembly, or only after each regular session?
Only after regular sessions. N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 120-47.6(a) and -47.7(a) require expense reports within 60 days of the end of the regular session of the General Assembly. The statute is silent on extr…
Can a North Carolina mountain county use the 1993 mountain ridge road service district statute to fund maintenance of subdivision roads that were platted after October 1975, or only the older platted ones?
Only the pre-October-1975 ones. Chapter 378 of the 1993 Session Laws collides with G.S. 136-98, the 1931 statute that took counties out of the road-building business. Because repeal by implication is …
Can North Carolina increase the penalty for habitual felons and still use prior felonies committed before the new law's effective date to count toward the recidivist designation, without violating the ex post facto clause?
Yes. The ex post facto problem is solved by an effective-date clause keyed to the date of the triggering (latest) felony. As long as the triggering felony occurs after the new penalty takes effect, th…
Are Orange County teachers who earned Career I or Career II status under the 1985 Career Development Pilot Program entitled to keep their enhanced pay after Orange County adopted a differentiated pay plan?
The AG concluded the 'hold harmless' provision in G.S. 115C-363.11(c) was triggered when Orange County adopted a differentiated pay plan in 1990-91 under the School Improvement and Accountability Act …
If someone on unemployment is offered a job that depends on passing a drug test and they fail the test, can the state cut off their unemployment benefits?
The AG concluded yes. Under the unemployment statute, failing without good cause to accept suitable work disqualifies a claimant from benefits. If a claimant on benefits is offered a job contingent on…
If a court sets up a special-needs trust funded by a personal injury settlement, do the new Medicaid trust rules under OBRA 1993 treat that trust as if the disabled person established it themselves?
Yes. The AG concluded that 42 U.S.C. § 1396p(d) reaches a trust funded with settlement or judgment proceeds even when a guardian or court formally creates it, because the proceeds are the property of …
Can North Carolina recover Medicaid expenditures from a deceased recipient's estate if Congress requires it, or does the General Assembly have to pass enabling legislation first?
NC must pass enabling legislation. The AG concluded that even though federal OBRA 93 required states to establish Medicaid estate recovery programs, NC lacked any state statutory mechanism for the Div…
If investors put money into a North Carolina business in November or December 1993 and the Secretary of State registered the business as a Qualified Business Venture later in December, did the investors qualify for the state Qualified Business Venture investment tax credit?
Yes, for investments made through December 31, 1993. Chief Counsel John R. McArthur officially adopted the prior Boylan interpretation: registration with the Secretary of State at any time during the …
Does North Carolina's RICO Act treat federal currency-structuring violations (breaking up cash deposits to dodge the $10,000 bank reporting rule) as 'money laundering' activity?
Yes, according to this 1993 AG opinion. Although NC's RICO Act doesn't define 'money laundering,' the AG read it broadly enough to include structuring a currency transaction in violation of 31 U.S.C. …
In a NC county building shared by sheriff's office staff and other county business, who decides where people can smoke: the county commissioners or the sheriff?
Both, depending on the room. County commissioners have broad authority under G.S. § 153A-121 (health ordinances) and § 153A-169 (county property supervision) to regulate smoking in county buildings, i…
When is a 'non-profit' volunteer fire department itself an OSHANC-covered employer, and what factors should the Department of Labor weigh in deciding?
The principal factor is whether any member receives compensation for service. If at least one member is paid (wages, sick pay, vacation pay, bonuses, etc.), an employer-employee relationship exists an…
Are video poker machines that involve skill and pay out only merchandise credit legal in NC after the recent amendment to the anti-slot-machine statute?
Maybe. The amended N.C.G.S. § 14-306 contains an exemption for machines used for amusement that involve skill. A particular video poker machine fits the exemption only if both conditions are factually…
Can a funeral home get in trouble for having an unlicensed person on staff if the funeral home didn't know the employee's license had lapsed?
Yes. The AG concluded that a funeral establishment has an affirmative duty under Board regulations to verify the current license status of each licensed employee when applying to renew the establishme…
Does North Carolina's school-involvement leave statute (four hours per year) apply to public school employees, and is the 'year' a calendar year, a fiscal year, or something the employer can pick?
The NC AG concluded that N.C.G.S. § 95-28.3 applies to public school employees and other state and local government workers, that the four hours is a minimum the employer must allow (not a maximum), a…
Can North Carolina pass a local act letting a city promise not to annex a manufacturer's property for years in exchange for payments in lieu of taxes, or does that violate the state constitution?
The AG concluded the Eden-Miller Brewing preannexation local act (Chapter 418 of the 1993 Session Laws) is facially constitutional. The legislature has plenary power over municipal boundaries under Ar…
When is a volunteer fire department considered part of a municipality or county such that the city or county itself becomes responsible for OSHANC compliance, including citations and penalties, for fire-department safety violations?
Only when the municipality or county exercises sufficient control over the volunteer department, shown by clear and convincing evidence. The AG identified five major factors: ownership of land and equ…
Can the NC Banking Commission raise or lower the maximum interest rate on larger consumer finance loans, or only on the smaller loans?
Only on the smaller loans. The Banking Commission has explicit authority under G.S. § 53-173(f) to redetermine and refix the maximum interest rate for consumer finance loans made under § 53-173 (up to…
Can a North Carolina consumer-finance company sell new types of credit insurance to its borrowers, including joint accident and health policies and single or dual interest motor vehicle physical damage coverage?
Yes for credit joint accident and health insurance, no for single or dual interest motor vehicle physical damage insurance unless the Commissioner of Banks gives written permission. Joint accident and…
When a North Carolina consumer-finance licensee applies to do other business at the same office where it makes loans, is the licensee entitled to an evidentiary hearing, and what role does the State Banking Commission play in reviewing the Commissioner's decision?
Yes to an evidentiary hearing when there is any likelihood the application will be denied. The Administrative Procedure Act applies. The State Banking Commission reviews the Commissioner's decision on…
When a private doctor performs a child medical evaluation for DSS in a suspected abuse case, are the doctor's records confidential, or do they become public once they leave DSS custody?
They stay confidential. NCGS 7A-544 applies a blanket 'strictest confidence' rule to every part of a DSS protective services investigation. Administrative rules, state DSS policy, and the chain of con…
If the State of North Carolina keeps backup CDs of a commissioned sound sculpture in its building, can the public force the State to hand over copies under the public records law?
No. The AG concluded that an artist who retained federal copyright in a state-commissioned sound sculpture kept the right to control duplication, and federal copyright law preempted the state Public R…
Can a county board of health adopt a smoking rule that applies to a state university campus, and when does state preemption kick in?
Yes, the AG concluded, but only briefly. Because the Commission for Health Services had not issued a statewide smoking rule for state institutions, Orange County's local board of health could adopt a …
When a court orders someone on probation or parole to perform community service hours at a non-profit or government agency, is the worker an OSHANC-covered employee, and is the agency an OSHANC-covered employer responsible for worker safety?
No. Community service workers are not OSHANC-covered employees. The receiving agency cannot fire them (only transfer them back), pays no wages, and does not have ultimate control over their work envir…
Can a North Carolina state university issue students a campus debit card for buying books and meals, and can it open that same debit system up to private off-campus businesses?
On the first question yes, on the second no. ECU's closed-loop debit card for on-campus purchases was a prepayment-for-services arrangement, not a bank deposit, so it did not violate state or federal …
If two doctors who owned a clinic before April 1, 1993 transfer the clinic's assets to a new corporation they also own, do they keep the grandfathered 'grace period' that lets them refer patients to that clinic until July 1, 1995?
Yes, but only for themselves. The doctors never relinquished their investment interest in the underlying clinic when they transferred its assets to a new corporation in which they also held stock. The…
If a doctor with an investment interest in a private nursing home prescribes nursing home care for Medicaid patients but does not pick a specific facility, is that a prohibited self-referral?
No. The 1993 self-referral statute defines a 'referral' as forwarding a patient to another provider or to an entity providing designated services. When the physician only prescribes the level of care …
Can the North Carolina State Board of Refrigeration Examiners enforce its licensing laws against commercial refrigeration work done on the Cherokee Indian Reservation?
Yes, as long as the contractor is not a Cherokee Indian residing on the Reservation. The AG concluded neither federal nor tribal law preempted North Carolina's right to require non-Cherokee refrigerat…
Can a city bill a state university (or other state agency) for stormwater utility fees, the way it bills any other property owner in town?
No. Sovereign immunity blocks the city from collecting under the ordinance alone. NC cities have express statutory authority to bill private property owners for stormwater service, but Chapter 160A do…
Does a commercial refrigeration contractor need a county building permit before installing a commercial refrigeration system?
Yes. The AG concluded that commercial refrigeration systems are within the county inspection department's enforcement jurisdiction under G.S. 153A-352, and the State Building Code (Volume III, Chapter…
When a district court seat opens, which county bar associations get to vote on the nomination list submitted to the Governor — the bars in the judicial district as it exists today, or the bars in the district as it existed on January 1, 1987?
January 1, 1987 controls. The NC AG concluded that N.C. Gen. Stat. § 7A-142 (read together with § 84-19) freezes the membership of each judicial district bar for nomination purposes to the judicial di…
Can a North Carolina county pay to extend water and sewer service to the commercial parts of a private mixed-use development?
Yes. The AG concluded G.S. 158-7.1(b)(5) authorized a county to extend or assist in extending utility services to industrial facilities, whether publicly or privately owned. Read together with the pub…
If a disabled sportsman asks a North Carolina state agency to let him use a motorized vehicle in an area where the agency's own administrative rules ban motorized vehicles, can the agency just waive the rule for that one person under the ADA, or does it have to go through formal rulemaking?
Formal rulemaking. An agency cannot just waive its own administrative rules case-by-case to accommodate a person with a disability, because G.S. § 150B-19(6) prohibits any rule that lets an agency wai…
Can a trade association get a list of which state nursing-home surveyors passed or failed the federal qualification test, or is that confidential personnel information?
The AG concluded the list is confidential personnel information that cannot be released under N.C.G.S. § 126-22. Because failure could lead to an employee being removed from the survey team, the pass/…
Can a NC county manager, acting on the fire marshal's request, issue a memo declaring certain county buildings smoke-free and have that be legally binding?
No. The AG concluded that a NC county manager has no statutory authority to set policy on the use of a county building. G.S. 153A-169 places the power to issue orders, ordinances, or resolutions conce…
Can the same person serve as the Mount Olive City Attorney and as a commissioner of the Mount Olive Housing Authority, given that G.S. § 157-5 says 'No commissioner may be a city official'?
Yes, on the facts presented. The AG concluded that 'official' in G.S. § 157-5 is synonymous with 'officer,' and that whether the city attorney is a 'public officer' turns on whether the position exerc…
If a NC state advisory council 'elects' its vice-chair and secretary at an annual meeting by simply closing nominations without taking any vote, is that election valid, and how can the body fix it?
No, it is not valid. The AG concluded that the June 2, 1993 election of vice-chair and secretary of the Governor's Advisory Council on Aging was null and void because no vote was taken, in violation o…
If a North Carolina driver gets a second DWI within seven years, do they have to spend 48 hours in jail in a row, or can the time be split up?
At least 48 of the mandated seven days have to be consecutive. A second DWI within seven years triggered Level Two punishment under N.C.G.S. § 20-179(c) and (h), which required a minimum of seven days…
Browse North Carolina opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in North Carolina are written by the North Carolina Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.