Arkansas Attorney General Opinions
Free plain-English summaries of attorney general opinions issued in Arkansas, with full citations and the original source on every page.
No Arkansas opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
Does an Arkansas sheriff's deputy's forced resignation count as a 'termination' for FOIA disclosure of misconduct records?
Yes. AG Tim Griffin concluded that a forced or coerced resignation, where the employee resigns 'in the face of certain, impending termination,' is treated as a 'constructive termination' that satisfie…
Can my city release a police officer's termination letter and internal affairs file to a FOIA requester in Arkansas?
Yes, in this case. AG Tim Griffin concluded that the City of Cabot's records custodian was right to classify Officer Son Le's termination letter, letter of reprimand, and internal affairs investigatio…
What can a city release when someone FOIAs the file of a recently fired employee, including the termination letter, internal emails, and a social worker's note?
Most of the file comes out, but not all. Routine grievance correspondence, supervisor statements, signed workplace policies, and similar documents are personnel records and must be released (with pers…
Can a police department release a FOIA-requested suspension report on three named officers when the officers themselves object?
Yes. Suspension reports that explain the basis for the suspension are employee-evaluation records. The four-part FOIA test is met here: the officers were suspended, the discipline is final, the report…
I resigned in lieu of termination from a state job. Can my former employer release my voluntary separation form, resignation letter, and the email and memo about the events that led to my forced resignation?
Yes. The voluntary separation form and resignation letter are personnel records, releasable subject to redactions. The email and memorandum are evaluation records, but a forced resignation counts as '…
I'm a journalist asking for state employee termination notices. Why won't the agency release them?
Because the termination notices stated the grounds for termination, they qualify as employee-evaluation records, which are subject to a strict four-element release test (suspension or termination, adm…
I asked Washington County for discipline records on two former employees and the custodian denied everything. Can the county hold all of that back?
Mostly no. The AG concluded the blanket denial is largely inconsistent with FOIA. The emails, three separation notices, and an investigation closure letter are personnel records that should be release…
I'm a police officer who was terminated and now my termination letter has been requested under FOIA. Can the city actually release that letter?
Yes. The AG concluded that the Cabot termination letter is properly classified as an employee-evaluation record because it states the grounds for termination, and the four-element release test under s…
When can a city release records about a fired police officer, including the termination letter and the internal affairs report on the officer's misconduct?
Most of them can come out. The AG concludes Fayetteville's decision to release the termination letter and the OSP investigative memorandum on the former officer is consistent with the FOIA, because al…
Should a sheriff's office release the disciplinary file and resignation letter of a deputy who resigned in lieu of termination?
Yes, the records should be released. AG Tim Griffin agreed they are employee-evaluation records under FOIA, but found that the four-part release test is met: the deputy's resignation in lieu of termin…
Can a former Arkansas deputy block release of his 2014 misconduct investigation records nine years after termination?
The custodian's decision to release the records is consistent with FOIA. Investigative records of police misconduct meet the four-part test for evaluation records: the deputy was terminated, the termi…
Can a sheriff's office release the Internal Review of a deputy who 'voluntarily' resigned just before being fired?
Yes. Sebastian County Sheriff's Office can release the Internal Review of former deputy Thomas Gage. A 'forced or coerced resignation' (resigning in the face of impending termination) operates as a co…
Can the Arkansas Public Defender Commission release suspension and termination letters about a former employee facing criminal charges?
Yes. The Arkansas Public Defender Commission's decision to release a former employee's suspension letter, termination letter, and email correspondence (with personal contact information redacted) is c…
Can a former Arkansas Department of Education employee block release of his termination letter?
Yes, the termination letter must be released. When a termination letter includes the grounds for termination, it is classified as an employee evaluation. It must be disclosed if (1) the termination is…
When two officers were terminated for misconduct, can the police department release their full IA files to a public records requester?
Yes. The Conway Police Department's decision to release internal-affairs files for two officers who were terminated based on those files is consistent with the Arkansas FOIA. The four-part test for di…
Can a police department withhold a third-party recording of an officer's private call from a public records release?
The Conway Police Department may withhold the audio recording of a private spousal phone call (and its transcript) from a public release of an internal-affairs file because the recording is a personne…
When does the Arkansas FOIA require disclosure of a state police officer's employee-evaluation records, and what gets redacted?
Yes. The ASP custodian's decision to release the officer's two disciplinary files (2005 and 2007) as redacted is generally consistent with the FOIA. Employee-evaluation records may only be released wh…
Can the Arkansas State Police release a former trooper's termination letter under FOIA when the misconduct involves departmental rules?
Yes. The Arkansas State Police's decision to release a former trooper's termination letter detailing the policy violations that led to discharge is consistent with the Arkansas FOIA. Misconduct by swo…
Can Arkansas State Police release personnel and evaluation records of a former employee who is now running for sheriff?
The Arkansas AG concluded the Arkansas State Police custodian's decision to release former employee Jim Milam's personnel and employee-evaluation records, with redactions, was mostly consistent with F…
Can a former Arkansas State Police trooper block release of his personnel and evaluation records in response to a FOIA request?
The custodian's decision to release the records appears consistent with the Arkansas FOIA. A former employee's privacy objection alone is not enough to block disclosure of personnel records, and the p…
Can a city release the termination letter of a former firefighter under Arkansas FOIA when the letter explains why he was fired?
Yes. The City of Cabot's decision to release a former firefighter's termination notice was consistent with FOIA. The notice qualified as an employee-evaluation record because it stated the reasons for…
Could Springdale PD release Officer Boyd's disciplinary summary even though Boyd objected the requester gave no reason for asking?
Yes, in all likelihood. Officer Rusty Boyd's objection rested on the requester not explaining her motive. The AG identified that under the Arkansas FOIA the requester's identity or motive is generally…
Could Springdale Police Department release a Springdale officer's disciplinary record listing the policies he violated and the action taken?
Yes, in all likelihood. The disciplinary summary record at issue (covering Officer Kyle Naish's name/rank, incident date(s), policy violations, and disciplinary action) likely satisfied all four prong…
When the Arkansas Department of Health releases a discipline file on a high-ranking employee, is that consistent with FOIA?
Yes. AG Rutledge concluded the ADH custodian's decision to release the three records (one personnel record, one mixed personnel/evaluation record, and one evaluation record), as redacted, was consiste…
Does media coverage of an alleged 'abusive workplace' at Pulaski County Election Commission create a compelling public interest in disclosing the underlying employee complaints under Arkansas FOIA?
Indirectly answered. The AG explained that the compelling-public-interest analysis only matters if the records are evaluation records and there has already been a suspension or termination. Where ther…
Can a city withhold a police chief's suspension letter from public records when other related records have already been released?
The AG questioned the withholding. Letters from a police chief explaining the reasons for suspending an officer are employee-evaluation records, but if the disciplinary action is final and the public-…
Can a former police officer block release of internal investigation records related to his 2013 sexual misconduct termination, even six years later?
No. The AG concluded the four-part test for releasing employee-evaluation records was met: he was terminated, the discipline was final, the records formed a basis, and there was a compelling public in…
Can a public-university employee block release of complaints made about him by saying disclosure would be embarrassing or that there's no compelling public interest?
No. "Harmful and embarrassing" is not the test for releasing personnel records under the Arkansas FOIA. "Compelling public interest" applies only to employee-evaluation records, not personnel records.…
Can a former Arkansas school employee block release of his personnel file when an FOIA requester asks for grievances, suspension letters, and termination records?
The AG could not give a definitive answer because he had not seen the actual records the custodian was prepared to release. But the requester's motives and the subject's privacy and harassment objecti…
When an Arkansas school district investigates and suspends an employee for misconduct involving a student, can the district withhold the investigative records by saying there's no compelling public interest?
Likely no. The AG concluded the public has a compelling interest in disclosure when the conduct occurred during school hours and affected a student. Even when the employee holds no leadership role, th…
Can a city release a former employee's disciplinary records under the Arkansas FOIA when the employee objects?
The AG concluded the City of Marianna's custodian could release two disciplinary records of a former employee in response to a FOIA request. The four-part test for employee-evaluation records was met:…
Can a police department release a fired officer's personnel and investigative records under FOIA over the officer's objection?
Yes. The Fort Smith Police Department's decision to release the records was consistent with FOIA. The terminated employee's belief that his termination was unfounded was not a legally sufficient groun…
When does the Arkansas FOIA require a city to release disciplinary records of a senior public employee, even over the employee's objection?
When the disciplinary record involves repeated infractions by a high-ranking employee, including matters touching public funds, the AG considers the 'compelling public interest' standard met and the c…
Can a city withhold all records of an employee's computer-policy violation under the Arkansas FOIA employee-evaluation exemption?
No. Fort Smith improperly classified all records of an employee's computer-policy violation as exempt employee-evaluation records. Most are not evaluation records at all; the actual evaluation records…
Was a Springdale police suspension record properly redacted before release under the Arkansas FOIA, when the suspended officer wanted broader redactions removed?
Yes. The custodian's decision to release the records as redacted was consistent with the FOIA. The records formed the basis of the officer's suspension, the suspension was final, and there is a compel…
Can a Jefferson County agency withhold a former employee's salary, termination letters, and personnel file from a FOIA request?
Mostly release. AG Rutledge could not opine without seeing the records, but laid out the standards: a former public employee's salary must be released, termination letters that only reflect the fact o…
When can a Fort Smith Traffic Control Manager's disciplinary records be released under the Arkansas FOIA?
Yes. The Arkansas AG concluded the custodian's decision to release records of an adverse disciplinary action against Fort Smith Traffic Control Manager Gary Six was consistent with the FOIA. The recor…
When can a Fort Smith city employee's disciplinary records be released under the Arkansas FOIA?
Yes. The Arkansas AG concluded the custodian's decision to release records of a recent adverse disciplinary action against Fort Smith Streets Department Electronics Technician Cody Mathis was consiste…
Can an Arkansas school district withhold employee evaluation records from a FOIA request if no final discipline has been imposed?
Yes. Under the Arkansas FOIA, employee evaluation records must be withheld unless the employee was suspended or terminated, the discipline became administratively final, the records formed a basis for…
Can a teacher's suspension and resignation records be released under Arkansas FOIA?
Yes. The records of a school district employee's disciplinary suspension under the Teacher Fair Dismissal Act are releasable under Arkansas FOIA when the employee resigned before the school board rule…
Could the Little Rock School District release a teacher's personnel and disciplinary records in response to a FOIA request, and what had to be redacted?
Mostly yes, with two carve-outs. The AG concluded that the custodian's decision to release the records to a FOIA requester was generally consistent with FOIA. Two specific issues: (1) insurance premiu…
Can the public get a letter from a public agency telling an employee about disciplinary action through an Arkansas FOIA request?
Yes, with redactions. The AG concluded that the disciplinary letter to a West River Valley RSWMD employee was an employee evaluation record, that the four-part test for release (suspension or terminat…
When a city releases a former employee's personnel file under FOIA, what gets redacted and what about disciplinary letters?
The AG concluded that the City of Little Rock's redacted release was consistent with the FOIA. Most documents were properly personnel records subject to disclosure, but a March 2015 disciplinary lette…
Can a city release a redacted record of disciplinary-interview conversations about a city supervisor who received a three-day suspension, over the supervisor's objection that witnesses will be identified?
Yes. The AG concluded that the interview-conversation record was an employee-evaluation record under *Thomas v. Hall*'s three-part test. With the supervisor suspended, the proceeding final, and the re…
Can the Arkansas State Police release the internal-affairs investigation file of a former recruit when the events are 15 years old?
No, in the AG's view. The records were employee-evaluation records that met three of the four required elements for disclosure (the employee was terminated, the termination was final, and the records …
How does Arkansas FOIA apply to a request for the personnel file of a recently-terminated state employee, split into seven categories of records, including some that the agency wanted to withhold for lack of compelling public interest?
The AG reviewed seven categories and concluded that the custodian's classifications were largely correct, but flagged additional redactions in Categories 1, 2, 4, and 5 (personnel numbers, banking inf…
Does the passage of 13 years dissipate the 'compelling public interest' element of the FOIA employee-evaluation test, so that internal-affairs records of a former Sherwood police officer can be withheld?
Maybe. The passage of time can dissipate a compelling public interest, but it is not alone determinative. The age of the records and the fact that the person is no longer an employee both factor into …
Can a city release police officer suspension records when the underlying misconduct was off-duty private conduct with no public impact?
No. The AG said Fayetteville's decision to release the suspension records was inconsistent with the FOIA. Because the off-duty incident involved no taxpayer misuse, no criminal conduct, no public safe…
Are a city employee's emails, expenses, travel records, and personnel file subject to FOIA disclosure?
Travel records, expenses, and dates of employment are clearly public records. Emails, letters, and memos depend on whether they document official functions. The AG could not opine on specific records …
Can an Arkansas sheriff's office release a deputy's suspension letter to a third-party FOIA requester even though the deputy was not involved in any of the matters the requester was investigating?
Yes. The suspension letter is an employee-evaluation record showing a violation of rules designed to avoid undermining public trust. As a law enforcement officer's discipline record meeting the four-p…
Can an Arkansas county sheriff's department withhold a 13-year-old letter of reprimand and suspension issued to a deputy just because the underlying incident never became publicly controversial?
No, in the AG's view. Age and lack of public controversy alone are not enough to defeat the compelling-public-interest test for releasing a law enforcement officer's disciplinary record, especially wh…
Under Arkansas FOIA, can a school district withhold documents that formed the basis for firing a teacher who worked daily with students?
The AG could not rule on the specific Bentonville records but said the documents likely qualified as employee-evaluation records, not just personnel records. If so, the public's compelling interest in…
When should an Arkansas state agency release the records that led to firing an employee?
The AG agreed with the AHTD HR director's decision to release four records connected to a former employee's suspension and termination. Three were employee-evaluation records that met all four statuto…
When can the press get records from an Arkansas police officer's internal investigation?
Hearst Television's KHBS got partial relief. The AG sided with the custodian on two internal investigations that did not result in suspension or termination (those records stay closed). But he overrul…
Can a sheriff's office release disciplinary records of a former deputy under Arkansas FOIA when the misconduct involved interactions with the public?
Yes, with one redaction. Disciplinary records of law enforcement misconduct that affects the public typically carry a compelling public interest sufficient to satisfy the four-part FOIA test, but a fa…
When an Arkansas custodian releases a law enforcement officer's termination letter under FOIA, can the custodian redact the terminated employee's name?
No. Once an employee evaluation record meets the four-part test for release, redacting the subject's name is inconsistent with FOIA because the identity is central to the public's compelling interest.…
Browse Arkansas opinions by topic
Attorney general opinions in Arkansas are written by the Arkansas Attorney General's office in response to questions from state agencies, legislators, and prosecutors. They are not binding like court decisions, but courts and agencies treat them as persuasive guidance on how state law applies. Every opinion above has a plain-English question and short answer, plus a link to the full original text.