State AG Opinions
Free state attorney general opinions with plain-English summaries, full citations, and the original source on every page.
No opinions match these filters
Try a different search term or clear the filters.
If the State adds supplemental life insurance, accidental death and dismemberment insurance, and supplemental disability insurance to the new statewide flexible benefits plan (NC Flex), would those options duplicate the benefits already provided by the State's mandatory retirement systems and Disability Income Plan, violating N.C.G.S. §§ 116-17.2 and 143-34.1(d)?
No. Supplemental life, AD&D, and disability insurance offered through NC Flex would provide benefits over and above the existing mandatory state plans, not duplicate them. The statutory no-duplication…
An 'irrevocable' preneed funeral contract can only be revoked by 'a court of competent jurisdiction' under § 90-210.65(e). Which court is that, how do you start the case, and what happens when the contract purchaser has been declared incompetent?
Any trial-division court of the General Court of Justice (superior or district) is a 'court of competent jurisdiction.' Start the case with a regular civil complaint naming as defendants the purchaser…
Did a Delaware school board give proper notice when its meeting agenda just said 'Personnel' before interviewing principal candidates in closed session?
No, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG found the Woodbridge Board of Education violated FOIA by listing its executive session only as "Personnel" without citing the specific statutory ground fo…
Can a register of deeds accept computer-printed UCC financing statement forms generated by a bank's PC software, instead of the traditional pre-printed carbon-paper forms?
Yes. The Uniform Commercial Code does not require any specific form for a financing statement. As long as the document includes the required content (debtor and secured party names and addresses, sign…
Does Minnesota's 1994-95 uniform election day statute (Minn. Stat. § 205.07, as amended) apply to home rule charter cities such as Crystal, requiring biennial four-year council terms instead of the city's three-year terms?
Yes, with January 1998 transition. The AG concluded that the 1994 and 1995 amendments to Minn. Stat. § 205.07, subd. 1, when effective January 1, 1998, apply to both statutory and home-rule charter ci…
Can insurance companies refuse to write property insurance in certain geographic areas of North Carolina, like the coastal counties, and what is the Insurance Commissioner's authority to require coverage?
Yes, with limits. Outside the motor vehicle context, NC statutes do not require insurance companies to insure every applicant. But under G.S. 58-63-15(7)(c), insurers commit an unfair trade practice i…
The 1995 General Assembly gave the NC State Bar $500,000 'to further the criminal justice system.' Can the State Bar grant part of that money to a private, nonprofit corporation (the Center for Death Penalty Litigation) that supports capital defense work?
Yes, if the State Bar concludes the Center's work actually 'furthers the criminal justice system.' Enhancing the system by improving legal representation in capital cases is a public purpose, and publ…
When the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare subpoenas records from another state agency under § 56-227C, can that other agency refuse on the ground that the records are exempt from the public under the Idaho Public Records Act?
No. The Public Records Act governs only the public's access; it does not limit administrative subpoenas. Section 9-343(3) expressly preserves administrative discovery, and a 'legal excuse' under § 56-…
Can the same person serve as both town supervisor and the mayor of a village inside that town?
No. The AG concluded that a person may not simultaneously hold the offices of town supervisor and mayor of a village within the same town. The two are incompatible under the Ryan v Green test because …
Can a NY town shorten the supervisor's term back from four years to two years after voters approved the longer term?
Yes. The AG concluded that a town board may reduce the term of its supervisor from four to two years by enacting a local law subject to a mandatory referendum. Although Town Law § 24-a only provides f…
If a Delaware school board explains in writing why a teacher was put on leave, does it also have to hand over her personnel file to a concerned parent?
No, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG found that Woodbridge School District had complied with FOIA when it explained in writing why a teacher had taken a leave of absence and offered to meet w…
Can the Maine governor lay off state workers or stop spending appropriated funds to push through Productivity Task Force changes before the Legislature acts?
Mostly no. The AG concluded the Governor could trim All Other spending and lay off employees to capture productivity savings, but could not use either lever to eliminate a statutorily mandated state p…
Could a tribal law enforcement officer arrest a tribal member off the reservation on a tribal court warrant, and could an Idaho state officer arrest someone off the reservation based on a tribal court warrant?
Both required state statutory authorization. A tribal officer needed both state statutory recognition of tribal warrants and deputization to arrest off-reservation; a state officer needed both state s…
When North Carolina lets a person clear their criminal record (expunge it) under § 15A-145 (under-18 misdemeanor first offender) or § 15A-146 (dismissed or acquitted charge), can the petitioner clear multiple offenses, or only one?
Only one. Both statutes are written in the singular throughout: 'a crime,' 'a misdemeanor,' 'the charge.' That word choice plus the no-prior-expungement bar tells the AG that the legislature meant a s…
Could a 1995 Idaho ballot initiative recognize private 'volunteer militia organizations' as part of the state militia and shield them from legislative regulation, gubernatorial oversight, and adjutant general control?
No. The Idaho Constitution gives the legislature authority to regulate the militia (Article 14, section 2), the governor command-in-chief authority (Article 4, section 4), and authority over commissio…
Could a 1995 Idaho ballot initiative cut the sales tax rate from 5% to 3% by amending Idaho Code § 63-3619 alone, while leaving the 5% use tax in place?
No, that approach would discriminate against out-of-state sellers in violation of the Commerce Clause. Local retailers would collect 3%, out-of-state retailers (and use-tax remitters) would still owe …
Could a 1995 Idaho ballot initiative successfully exempt food, water, and clothing from Idaho sales tax by amending Idaho Code § 63-3619?
The AG flagged that amending the sales-tax statute alone would leave the use tax in place, undercutting the petitioners' goal. The petitioners should add a new exemption section under § 63-3622 and de…
Could a 1995 Idaho ballot initiative criminalize all abortions performed once a fetal heartbeat or brain stem activity could be detected, with mandatory capital punishment for any violation?
No. The proposal would have outlawed many previability abortions in violation of the 'undue burden' standard from Planned Parenthood v. Casey, and the initiative process cannot amend either the U.S. o…
When state coastal reserve boundaries (Masonboro Island, Rachel Carson, etc.) include private property that the state hasn't yet purchased, can the state apply its coastal reserve use restrictions to the private parcels, and can it block private landowners from building piers into the adjoining state-owned submerged waters?
No on both. The Coastal Reserve statutes regulate state-acquired property, not private in-holdings within boundary lines drawn for future acquisition. Applying them to private property would amount to…
Can a NY town approve a single combined sewer rate for two separate sewage-works corporations operating in different areas?
No. The AG concluded that each sewage-works corporation organized under Transportation Corporations Law Article 10 must petition for a sewer rate tied to the cost of operating and maintaining its own …
When a NC state agency settles a lawsuit with another agency, does the settlement have to be styled as a 'consent judgment' under N.C.G.S. § 114-2.2 to be enforceable, or can a court-approved settlement agreement do the job?
The 1995 NC AG opinion concluded a court-approved settlement agreement is enforceable on its own terms. Section 114-2.2 governs consent judgments specifically but does not require every state-agency s…
Can a NY village set a fixed term of office for a police chief whose position is in the competitive class of civil service?
No. The AG concluded that a municipality may not establish a term of office for any position in the competitive class of the civil service, including a police chief who serves as the executive head of…
Could Delaware's tax division get Social Security numbers from the DMV's driver records to enforce state tax laws?
Yes, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG concluded that Delaware's Division of Revenue could access Social Security numbers held in Division of Motor Vehicles records, through the state's shared…
Can a NY county enter a mutual aid agreement with a county in another state for fire and emergency services?
Yes. The AG concluded Cattaraugus County could enter a mutual aid agreement with Potter County, Pennsylvania, using General Municipal Law Article 14-G (interlocal agreements with public agencies of ot…
Can the State of North Carolina and its cities and counties accept bids and contract with out-of-state motor vehicle dealers who are not licensed in North Carolina, or does Article 12 of Chapter 20 require all dealers to hold an NC license to sell vehicles to public entities?
Yes. Out-of-state dealers do not need an NC license to sell vehicles directly to the State or its political subdivisions. The licensing statute protects NC citizens from fraud in private transactions;…
Building on the prior week's opinion, can the NC House Ethics Committee split its proceedings (closed session just for a minor witness's testimony, open session for the rest), and can it consider investigatory reports in closed session?
Yes to both, with conditions. The AG concluded that if the Committee can close meetings under N.C.G.S. § 143-318.11(a)(6) at all (a question the prior opinion flagged as unresolved), the Committee can…
Can a NY town pass a 'pay to play' law banning contracts with people who donated to town officials?
No. The AG concluded that Southampton's proposed law (no town contracts over $1,500 to persons who had donated more than $100 to town officials or candidates) was both inconsistent with and preempted …
When the NC House Ethics Committee investigates sexual harassment charges against a member, can it (1) keep the investigatory reports it commissions confidential, and (2) take closed-session testimony from a 16-year-old former House page and then publish a transcript with the page's name redacted?
No to both. The AG concluded that investigatory reports the Committee receives are public records (News & Observer Publishing Co. v. Poole) and the Committee cannot withhold them. On closed-session te…
Can a NY county clerk accept a DBA certificate when the assumed name looks like a person's name, and can the clerk fix obvious filing errors?
Yes on both. The AG concluded a county clerk may accept a General Business Law § 130 assumed-name certificate at face value when it explains the secondary or historic meaning of the name, may not insi…
After the 1995 statutory amendments that stripped some independent powers from the State Superintendent of Public Instruction, did the Superintendent still have authority to sign contracts on behalf of the State Board of Education?
Yes, but only under the existing State Board delegation. The AG concluded that the 1995 amendments eliminated the Superintendent's independent statutory contracting power but did not revoke a 1989 Sta…
If a North Carolina county department of social services has custody of a child in an abuse or neglect case, can DSS let the parents' lawyer interview the child when the child's own court-appointed guardian ad litem or attorney advocate objects?
No. Once a juvenile petition alleging abuse or neglect is filed and the court appoints a guardian ad litem and attorney advocate for the child, the responsibility for protecting the child's legal righ…
When a North Carolina superior court judge ruled in Maready v. City of Winston-Salem that § 158-7.1 economic development incentives were unconstitutional, did that ruling immediately bind every other county in the state, and were Guilford County commissioners personally on the hook for honoring an existing 1993 reimbursement contract for developer-built water and sewer lines?
No on both fronts. A superior court ruling binds only the parties to that case, not city and county governments statewide. Only a NC Court of Appeals or Supreme Court ruling would have statewide effec…
Does the NY tropical hardwood purchase ban cover every tropical species, or only the species the statute lists by name?
The AG concluded that State Finance Law § 165 prohibits the state and its agencies from purchasing only the roughly forty tropical-hardwood species listed by name in the statute. The general definitio…
Can a Texas city or county ban licensed concealed handguns in its parks, or a transit agency on its buses?
Representative Ron Wilson asked, after the 1995 concealed handgun law passed, whether a rapid transit authority could bar licensed concealed handguns from its buses and whether cities and counties cou…
Could a Texas business post a sign barring concealed-handgun license holders, and how could the owner enforce it?
Yes. The 1995 concealed-handgun law did not prevent private business owners from excluding license holders under the criminal-trespass statute, and a posted sign was the most effective notice. Owners …
Can a NY town agree to provide police protection only to a village inside the town and skip the rest of the town?
No. The AG concluded that if a town establishes a police department under Town Law § 150, it must serve the entire town including any village without its own police force. A town cannot lawfully provi…
When a chain restaurant builds a new location using a corporate prototype plan, can a North Carolina county environmental health specialist re-review and disapprove the inside design, or only the site-specific outside factors?
Only the site-specific outside factors. The AG concluded that the State approves prototype franchise/chain restaurant plans, and county environmental health specialists exercise their authority under …
Can a Texas school district transport students in a vehicle that isn't a certified school bus?
The Texas Education Agency asked whether a school district could buy, lease, rent, or use a vehicle that does not meet federal and state school bus safety standards to carry students. The Attorney Gen…
Does North Carolina's Commission of Indian Affairs have the authority to recognize a newly organized 'Lumbee Tribe of Cheraw Indians' tribal council as the official government of the Lumbee Tribe, or to take sides between that council and the Lumbee Regional Development Association?
No. The AG concluded that the Commission of Indian Affairs is a creature of the General Assembly with only the powers conferred by statute, and nothing in N.C. Gen. Stat. § 143B-406 or § 143B-407 give…
When a Minnesota city extends its subdivision regulations to land within two miles outside its limits, and the surrounding county has its own zoning ordinance covering the same land, whose rules govern subdivision and zoning on that land?
Different things go to different authorities. The AG concluded that under Minn. Stat. § 462.358, subd. 1a, a city's extraterritorial subdivision regulations control over the county's subdivision regul…
When the General Assembly tells a state agency it can't spend money on a federal-court-mandated program except from specifically appropriated funds, can the agency still move lapsed salary money over to cover a shortfall?
Yes. The AG read § 143-23(a1)(3) and the conflicting 1995 budget provisions in pari materia and concluded that transferring lapsed salaries to cover the Thomas S. shortfall was lawful because the over…
When the 1993 General Assembly transferred 'the legal counsel and support staff' of the Banking Commission to the Department of Justice, did that mean one Commission attorney or two?
One. The 1993 Session Laws used singular language ('the' attorney, 'an' attorney) in three different provisions, so the legislature intended to transfer only one attorney (plus support staff) from the…
Can a NC state agency charge another government agency a fee for performing a duty that a statute requires the first agency to perform?
No. When the General Assembly assigns one agency the duty to provide records or services to another government agency as part of a comprehensive statutory scheme, the providing agency cannot tack on a…
If a Delaware town council votes on something that wasn't on the meeting agenda, can it fix the problem by voting again the right way?
Yes, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG found that Georgetown's Town Council violated FOIA when it voted to evict the Chamber of Commerce from Town Hall without listing the matter on the meetin…
If someone sues in court over a Delaware records request, does the Attorney General still rule on the same FOIA complaint?
No, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG found that once a complainant filed a Superior Court lawsuit that included a FOIA count over the same records dispute, her separate petition asking the At…
Can the NY Commissioner of Agriculture send a deputy in his place to ex officio board meetings of a public benefit corporation?
Yes. The AG concluded that Agriculture and Markets Law § 17(a) and (c) authorizes the Commissioner of Agriculture and Markets to delegate his ex officio responsibilities on the board of directors of t…
Can a NY landowner pull their property out of the village if they get some but not all village services?
No. The AG concluded that Village Law § 18-1804 lets a property owner seek exclusion from the village only if the property receives none of the listed improvements (sidewalk, electric lights, sewers, …
Is Texas's one-year residency requirement for a liquor license constitutional?
The Texas Alcoholic Beverage Commission asked whether the Alcoholic Beverage Code's one-year residency requirement for liquor license and permit applicants violates the U.S. Constitution, given that t…
Could the Maine AG prosecute legislative staff for documents found on Capitol computers under the state-computer-misuse statute?
No prosecution recommended. The AG analysis concluded none of the four categories of documents found on legislative computers would support a § 1890-B prosecution: political documents that did not adv…
Did the legislature accidentally re-activate Idaho's old 1-percent property-tax cap when it passed the 1995 school-funding bill, and if so, can counties or courts actually enforce a 1-percent cap?
On its face, yes, the 1-percent cap (Idaho Code § 63-923) was no longer nullified by cross-reference to other statutes after 1995. But the cap is impossible to implement under Idaho's existing tax-app…
Does the new federal-mandate child-support insurance enrollment law apply to NC's state employee health plan?
No. The 1994 NC law that required health insurers and private employers to enroll children of noncustodial parents on demand (without waiting for open enrollment) did not apply to the State Health Pla…
Does a Texas state agency have to pay county clerk filing, records, and courthouse-security fees?
The Attorney General concluded in 1995 that the Texas Railroad Commission had to pay county clerk fees when it filed the well-plugging notices required by Natural Resources Code section 89.043(e). The…
Does Maryland's emergency medical services agency regulate 'litter van' stretcher transport, or does the Washington-area transit commission?
The opinion concluded that 'litter van' stretcher-transport services fell within the statutory definition of 'ambulance' and were generally subject to licensing by the Maryland Institute for Emergency…
Under pre-Structured-Sentencing law, can the Post-Release Supervision and Parole Commission combine an inmate's multiple consecutive armed robbery sentences into one aggregated term for parole-eligibility computation under G.S. 15A-1354(b), even when the consecutive sentences were imposed at the same sentencing hearing?
No to both. The Parole Commission cannot aggregate armed robbery sentences imposed for offenses committed before October 1, 1994, even if the consecutive sentences were imposed at the same hearing. Th…
After two school districts vote to merge but before the merger takes effect, can the interim joint board sign a new contract with a superintendent that scales back the contract rights he was promised in the merger plan?
Yes, but only to limit, not to expand. The AG concluded that under NCGS 115C-67 an approved school merger plan has the force of law and can be amended only by the General Assembly. The plan's Section …
When the North Carolina General Assembly meets in joint session to confirm a Governor's appointment to the State Board of Education, are the House and Senate votes counted separately or as one combined total of all legislators present?
Combined as one. The AG concluded that Article IX Section 4(1) of the NC Constitution requires confirmation of State Board of Education nominees by the General Assembly in joint session, which makes t…
Can a Delaware governor's advisory council hold private meetings with invited guests under the state's open-meetings law?
No, under the law as it stood in 1995. The AG concluded that the Governor's Council on Equal Employment Opportunity qualified as a public body under FOIA because it was partly funded with public money…
Can a NY county legislator also serve on the county health department's review committees and as the farm bureau representative to the soil and water conservation district?
No. The AG concluded county legislative service is incompatible with sitting on the Utilization Review Committee or Professional Advisory Committee because those committees make professional evaluatio…
Does a NY village building inspector have to live in the village, or can the village let him live anywhere in the county?
The default is village residency, but the village can broaden it to the county. The AG concluded the Depew building inspector is a public officer (he enforces sovereign regulatory powers over housing,…
Could a 1995 Idaho ballot initiative raise the state minimum wage to $6.25 per hour by 2000, eliminate the tip credit, end overtime exemptions, and remove farmworkers, domestic workers, and minors from the minimum wage entirely?
Yes. The AG found no constitutional or statutory bar to any of the four changes. The federal Fair Labor Standards Act has a savings clause (29 U.S.C. § 218) that expressly lets states enact more gener…
How these opinions are useful
- Understand state law: AG opinions are authoritative interpretations of how state law applies.
- Persuasive authority: Not binding like court decisions, but they carry significant weight.
- Government guidance: Often clarify how state agencies and officials should interpret statutes.
- Legal research: Cite AG opinions in letters, motions, and legal arguments.