Can the Arkansas Attorney General weigh in on a dispute over Arkansas Activities Association eligibility rules?
Apply this to your situation
This page answers the general question as of 2022. Ezel answers yours: what it means for your facts, under current Arkansas law, with citations.
Plain-English summary
Senator Kim Hammer asked the Attorney General to weigh in on a dispute over Arkansas Activities Association (AAA) rules and the scope of AAA's authority. Attorney General Leslie Rutledge declined. The AG's office only opines on questions of state law interpretation under Ark. Code Ann. § 25-16-706. AAA rules are not state law. The AAA is a voluntary association of school districts that have signed agreements to abide by jointly-adopted rules; questions about those private rules belong with the AAA, the member districts' counsel, or a court, not with the AG.
The opinion cited Arkansas Activities Ass'n v. Meyer, 304 Ark. 718, 805 S.W.2d 58 (1991), where the Arkansas Supreme Court recognized that regulating student athletics legitimately falls within the purview of a voluntary association like AAA, acting in conjunction with the member schools.
Currency note
This opinion was issued in January 2022. The legal framework around AAA's voluntary-association status has not changed in a way that would alter this declination, but if you need to understand how AAA rules interact with current state law (for example, the 2023 LEARNS Act and any related school choice provisions), check the latest AG opinions and the AAA handbook.
What this means for you
If you are a school administrator with an AAA dispute
Based on this opinion, the AG will not adjudicate AAA rule disputes for you. Your remedies sit inside the AAA process: appeals through the AAA Board of Directors and AAA-prescribed dispute mechanisms. From there, judicial review of an AAA decision (typically on contract or due-process grounds) is the next step.
If you are a parent challenging an eligibility ruling
The AG cannot intervene in transfer eligibility, residency, or scholastic-eligibility disputes that turn on AAA rules. Work through the school's appeal channel and AAA's administrative process. If you believe the AAA decision violates state or federal law (not just AAA's own rules), state courts can review.
If you are a state legislator weighing reform of AAA's authority
The opinion implies a structural point: until and unless the General Assembly enacts statutory rules governing high school athletics, AAA's rulebook lives in private-contract space, not in the Arkansas Code. Legislative reform requires statute, not an AG opinion.
If you are an attorney representing an AAA-affected client
Frame the dispute as state-law (constitutional due process, breach of contract, civil rights) rather than as a request for AAA rule interpretation if you want a court (or the AG, where state law is the gateway) to engage. Pure rule-interpretation challenges are channeled through the AAA's internal process.
Common questions
Q: What is the Arkansas Activities Association?
A: A voluntary association of Arkansas school districts that jointly govern interscholastic athletics and activities. Member districts sign written agreements committing to AAA rules. The Arkansas Supreme Court in Arkansas Activities Ass'n v. Meyer recognized that this kind of regulation legitimately falls within the association's purview.
Q: Why doesn't the Attorney General have authority over AAA rules?
A: Ark. Code Ann. § 25-16-706 limits the AG's opinion-writing function to questions of state law. AAA rules are private contractual rules, not statutes or regulations. They sit outside the AG's interpretive jurisdiction.
Q: How do you challenge an AAA eligibility decision?
A: Through AAA's internal appeal process first. Some decisions can then be reviewed in state court on grounds like breach of contract, due process violation, or arbitrary action by a quasi-public body. The AAA handbook and your school district's legal counsel can map the specific path.
Q: Are there any AAA rule areas where state law overrides?
A: When AAA rules conflict with state or federal statutes (for example, anti-discrimination laws, special education requirements, or specific legislative directives), the statutes win. But the AG's office still opines only on the state law question, not the AAA rule.
Background and statutory framework
Many states regulate interscholastic athletics through a quasi-public association. In Arkansas, that role is filled by the AAA, an unincorporated voluntary association whose membership consists of the school districts themselves. Membership is contractual: each district signs an agreement to abide by AAA rules in exchange for participation eligibility for its students.
The structure is intentional. State legislatures have generally found it more flexible to delegate the operational details of athletic eligibility (transfers, residency, age limits, hardship waivers, postseason brackets) to a member-driven body than to write them into the code. The trade-off is that disputes over those operational rules stay outside the state's main statutory-interpretation channels.
Ark. Code Ann. § 25-16-706 is the AG's opinion-writing statute. It authorizes opinions for state legislators, prosecuting attorneys, and certain other officials, on questions of state law. The reciprocal limit, articulated in this opinion, is that the AG does not opine on private rules, contracts, or association governance.
Citations and references
Statutes:
- Ark. Code Ann. § 25-16-706 (scope of Attorney General opinions)
Cases:
- Arkansas Activities Ass'n v. Meyer, 304 Ark. 718, 722-23, 805 S.W.2d 58, 61 (1991) (recognizing AAA's authority to regulate student athletics through voluntary-association structure)
Prior AG opinions referenced:
- Ark. Att'y Gen. Op. 2003-107
- Ark. Att'y Gen. Op. 92-107
Source
Original opinion text
Opinion No. 2021-080
January 11, 2022
The Honorable Kim D. Hammer
State Senator
1201 Military Road PMB #285
Benton, AR 72015
Dear Senator Hammer:
This is in response to your request for an opinion from this office concerning the Arkansas Activities Association ("AAA"). As background for your request, you have submitted information about the AAA's rules and certain issues surrounding the interpretation of those rules and the scope of AAA's authority.
RESPONSE
Regretfully, I am unable to be of assistance in this matter. The issues identified in the material attached to your correspondence appear to involve the interpretation and application of AAA rules. The AAA is a voluntary association of member school districts that have agreed, through signed, written agreements, to abide by AAA rules. Questions concerning the interpretation and application of the agreed-upon rules fall outside the scope of an opinion from this office, which must be limited to questions of state law interpretation.
(See Ops. Att'y Gen. 2003-107, 92-107 (regarding the AAA's history and its rulemaking authority). The Arkansas Supreme Court has observed that "[i]t legitimately falls within the purview of a voluntary association like the AAA, acting in conjunction with the schools, to regulate [student athletics]." Arkansas Activities Ass'n v. Meyer, 304 Ark. 718, 722-23, 805 S.W.2d 58, 61 (1991). Ark. Code Ann. § 25-16-706 (Repl. 2014).)
Again, I regret I cannot be of assistance in this instance. Please feel free to contact me if I may be of future assistance in some other respect.
Sincerely,
LESLIE RUTLEDGE
Attorney General
Get today's answer for your situation
You just read a 2022 opinion on this question. Ezel checks the current Arkansas statutes and case law and answers your specific situation, with citations.
Opens in Ezel Pro. Every answer cites the law it relies on.